Comment on “We Cannot Defend Europe Without These Satellites”: Denmark Sounds Alarm Over Ukraine Starshield Disruptions
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
Yes. Space is big. Very big. People vastly underestimate how much room there is even in LEO. We haven’t even scratched the surface of how much we can put up there; and in LEO, Kessler syndrome is not really an issue. It will be decades, if not centuries, before the number of satellites becomes a real issue.
Let’s try to put a little perspective on this. Currently, there are ~20,000 satellites in orbit. Seems like a big scary number. But let’s actually think about this. Imagine if there were only 20,000 cars on the road across the entire US, or the EU if that’s easier to think about. 20,000. Across ALL the roads. It would probably feel pretty empty right?
Well, most satellites are smaller than cars and the amount of available space in orbit is exponentially greater than the amount of space on all roads. Literally not a problem.
But you’re wrong. Because you seem to think that “too many” is only a matter of when collisions start to occur, but that’s a completely arbitrary threshold. The fact is that the huge increase in number of satellites in orbit, compared to before Starlink, is having a significant detrimental effect on the ability of telescopes to gather data for astronomy. They are indeed a “star shield”, because they’re shielding us from properly being able to see and study the stars. They make our collective horizon smaller.
I knew this argument was coming. Satellites showing up in telescopes is essentially a non problem. Ever since astrophotography switched to digital, we have easily been able to filter out satellites and airplanes (which are a much bigger nuisance btw). You get the occasional article or post that has a picture of what happens when you take a super long exposure and DONT filter out the satellite/plane streaks, and it’s used as click bait going “See!? Look at what our hubris of launching satellites has brought! You should be mad! You should be afraid! You should be afraid AND mad!”
Now, to be fair, when trying to look at EXTREMELY distant or faint objects, satellites do start being a problem; but those kinds of observations are difficult even with clear skies, that’s why we have space-based telescopes like Hubble and the JWST. But those are edge cases. For the vast majority of ground-based star gazing, it’s been a solved problem for a long time now.
Thank you for explaining, that’s actually pretty comforting to learn.
Sign in to comment. Sign in