What AI chatbot do you use and why? And some other AI questions
I started using chatbots yesterday and it surprised me how complete and articulate answers are. Main topics would be apparel, sewing, cooking, finance, ETFs, taxes, house maintenance, retirement.
Do you consider AI good enough to substitute human interaction? Because I remember a south park episode where randy marsh ignores his wife to interact exclusively with a bot. A parody of course but we have already plenty of AI porn and AI short stories for gullible people… and it works because they don’t stop watching (and sometimes believe it to be real).
I was always kind of an anti AI guy due to privacy, to avoid LLMs monetizing my questions and because I didn’t want to be a moron who has nothing better to do than to watch AI slop, but this is a tool so pervasive and practical I’m only isolating myself if I opt out of it. Thoughts?
Are there any questions you won’t ask a bot so the company behind it doesn’t monetize your input?
Comments
I do not use any AI chatbots. I have ethical, sociological, religious, and environmental reasons for never ever using them.
If I’m isolating myself by opting out, so be it. I do not want to cook the planet for fucking markov chains.
Furthermore, I actively look down on anyone who uses them. I regard them with humanity, as I watch their intelligence and independence and capacity for critical thought dwindle until they’re nothing more than a shell who instinctively reaches for some slop machine when presented with anything of any difficulty.
My brother was once a masterful artist. He is now nothing more than a meatbag with ChatGPT access, and he is incapable of creating what he made just five years ago.
My condolences about your brother. I am noticing a few of my loved ones are in the early stages of losing their capacity for reasoning and learning to these chatbots. It is a horrifying and heartbreaking thing to witness.
Meanwhile, I am driven first and foremost by my desire for correct information, but have reached the same conclusion.
a markov chain is a very specific and different thing
LLM inference fits the definition a Markov chain, where the state is the input string to the LLM and the LLM’s output is taken to be the probability distribution for the next state transition. The state space is the finite set of token strings fitting in the LLM’s context window. The process of selecting the next token to output thus follows the Markov property. A whole readable string of text is generated by iterating this Markov process until the current state ends in an end-of-string token (or some other method).
As an aside, this is one major reason why people say thay LLMs can’t learn. They are memoryless. Their output is wholly derived from the input state in a deterministic manner (barring inconsistencies in hardware or execution environment) that does not change after training (which is a separate process from inference).
ok but basically anything is markovian if you include enough in the state, which doesn’t feel like it fits with what op was trying to imply
also I’d argue sampling makes it non deterministic
While it certainly appears that you’ve abandoned this thread, with little interest in responding…
Before you start asking any chatbot about finance, taxes, or retirement, try asking it about things you’re already an expert in.
I suspect you will find that the answers are often nonsense, or even counter to what its citations write.
Chatbots do not have any intelligence they are just autocomplete.
By the way, I hope you understand that by asking anything AI-related. You’re making your post vulnerable to be angrily reported by anti-ai virtue signalers running around.
Do you think all disagreement is virtue signaling?
No?
Because people online don’t just simply disagree, they go on superiority complex power trips to try and take down what they don’t like if directly confronting someone extremely doesn’t work.
It appears I misread “reported” as “responded”. I apologize.
None. Because chatting with AI is cringy as hell.
Please do not use llm as a substitute for relationships or relationship counselor or psychologist or so, it’s extremely harmful to you even in ways you can not see. And it doesn’t even tell you the truth, it just tells you what you probably want to hear based on the huge dataset that was fed to it. If you must, use it for work if you are in technical field, but remember we all pay for it with everything that is more expensive because of it (and that includes even food) and of course our environment pays for it dearly.
Those who can, do.
Those who can’t, use AI.
If I wanted something to answer my questions with info from the ether, I’d rather take a tab of acid and talk to the cat that hangs around my apartment’s dumpster than ask an ai. Most simple questions that I have are easily solved with a simple web search and there is no point in asking ai, and anything more complicated where the answer isn’t on the first page of the web search, the ai hallucinated something that was wrong and made zero sense. Absolutely atrocious use of power, water, land, and DRAM.
https://sh.itjust.works/pictrs/image/4ebab3d4-0a25-4b5c-a6db-4eebcfb46976.jpeg
I’m in.
People have their reasons for hating AI, and they are largely valid. However, the blind hate leads to proclamations that are untrue and undermine their whole argument. I’ll do my best to give a sober analysis from the point of view of a skeptic who believes AI does have a place in the world.
The answers AI provides are often pretty good because it goes out and pulls information from websites and puts together a cohesive answer. It does the search for you and it summarizes the results for you in seconds. However, inaccuracies can creep in such as flipping left and right because they are closely related conceptually. A domain expert can often catch these errors but a “layperson” doesn’t have all the tools to question and push back against such inaccuracies.
What I’m saying is responses can look accurate and complete, and often are, but until you validate them, they shouldn’t be used for anything important. You are in the wow stage of discovering AI but the first time you rely on it and it steers you wrong, you’re going to flip to AI is useless and wrong pretty quickly. That’s not right, either but it feels right. Use it to speed up things you can already do, but don’t rely on answers just because they are articulate.
Lastly, be careful about sycophancy or agreement. Chatbots are simple to argue into any position. But because you win an argument with AI, don’t think that means your position is right or your argument holds water. If you go at a bot with barely coherent reasons to be anti-vax, it’ll support you.
That all being said…
They are pretty good for rubber ducking and brainstorming. They aren’t as good as another actual person but if it’s you by yourself or you with AI, the AI at least comes with a different perspective.
However inaccurate they may be when searching for answers, google is such a cesspit these days that AI is no less accurate and substantially faster. That’s why they I order the ai summary now and attempt to block use by AI searchers.
They can be helpful for organizing if you are a disorganized person. They can a offer proofreading and editing help BUT don’t have it rewrite the final copy. Give it a first draft, have it revise that or give feedback, and then rewrite the final version in your own voice.
Final advice:
Never, ever, pass ai work product off as your own. I like to say AI is a tool, not a product. Incorporate its input, but the moment you substitute ai words or judgment for your own you’ve removed any value or authority from what you are providing. If someone else has to validate every word of what you provide, you’ve pushed the work that was yours onto the recipients. Think of it this way: any supporting fact is provisional until verified by someone qualified to do so. Even if the ai is 98% accurate, ever cited fact has the potential to be wrong until it is proven. If you don’t (or can’t) prove them, what you have is a suggestion phrased as fact.
everyone who downvotes this post are armchair activists. pay them no heed.
LLMs are exceptionally useful as search engines and information collators; the recent daybreak models from OpenAI are actually impressive, they’ve been finding vulnerabilities in software thats gone unnoticed for years and even decades. the future is computer-assisted-intelligence, whether these armchair activists like it or not.
if your opinions are so vehemently in disagreement with mine, or any others’; then go out and do something about it. don’t cry and whine on the internet. write to your local congressmen/senators/prime ministers/etc. go out and sacrifice your comforts for your beliefs, but don’t -ever- say that “oh boohoo woe is me, the world is shit and all I can do is whine and cry on the internet”.
now with that being said, I personally have found Claude to be exceptionally useful in information collation; with local hardware running abliterated/uncensored/heretic models for information-secure stuff, so that tasks can be set up to run overnight. its been quite the useful tool.
edit: already got sixteen downvotes, LOL
Go back to your mommy’s basement and cry over a plate of nuggies and chips lmao
Willful ignorance is the worst ignorance.
Your –number one– most valuable resource is time. I know exactly how LLMs, and ML in general works. I am under no illusions of “this is the best thing ever”, or “we’re all gonna die to skynet”.
LLMs, and ML in general, have made it so that the average employee no longer spends most of their time doing mundane bureaucracy and documentation. This is objectively a good thing. Instead of spending 2-3 hours drafting and writing a report, you can feed the raw data into an LLM, have it spit out a report according to a pre-prepared boilerplate, and then review it. This task takes Claude on the free tier, maybe a minute; for the super data-heavy stuff. Its’ accuracy is also ~99.8% correct, and the human review fixes that ~0.2% in maybe a few minutes after that. We are down from 2-3hours of tedium, to maybe 4 minutes of double-checking. That’s a massive time-save.
Modern open-source models can be run on anyone’s hardware (at varying levels of speed), making the only benefit of datacenters, as mentioned above, time. If I can offload a task that would take 5 hours to run locally, onto a datacenter rack that completes it in mere seconds, that is a very good trade.
Gave you another downvote, since it seems to upset you so much
lol
lmao, even
https://cdn.discordapp.com/emojis/393566686965530678.webp?size=256&animated=true
I use Claude, I find it best for technical tasks and I ditched ChatGPT when they started bending over for Trump.
I like the idea of creating software and things in general, but I’ve never really been interested in programming. Having a bit that can do the boring part for me has made lots of stupid little projects possible where they wouldn’t have been before. I also use it to research for me on random boring topics which might otherwise have taken me at least an hour. I know people talk about protecting all these sites that require humans to visit but then I remember how many times I’ve tried to look up a recipe and instead got somebodies life story. Or times when over tried to look up a command and had to scroll past ten paragraphs of filler crap before I get to the answer.
This entire disaster of a comment exemplifies why people hate AI.
What’s so terrible about the comment? It sounds like they’re using an LLM to help make a bunch of things a little easier for them to deal with.
I use GPT all the time for doing complex searches that traditional search engines can’t handle. I ask for citations so I can verify the information, and it’s saved me a tonne of trouble.
“I like the idea of making things but I don’t want to make things.”
Programming requires a certain amount of learning, dedication, and mindset. I’m not going to slag someone off because they’d rather not get in to it.
“I want to be a parent. I love being a parent; it brings me great joy. I don’t want to do the icky parts like changing diapers, or making them go to sleep, preparing food for them, taking them to the doctor for checkups. I have a nanny for that, you know, for the boring parts. How would I rate myself as a parent? Probably a 9/10. I deduct a point because I can be too attentive to my baby sometimes. I don’t know why some people find parenthood troublesome.”
Sure but what does “I’d rather not get into it” mean if not “I don’t like doing it”?
Thank you, that’s exactly it. I’ve learnt Python and C in the past but never enjoyed it. If there’s 10 steps to a project and one sector is programming, then by getting an LLM to do that one step I can do the other nine. Why spend weeks doing something I don’t enjoy when I can get an AI to do it in 30 minutes?
I used to use Copilot because I have a Windows PC & MS account & it was right there, but now I main Claude & I’ve found it far superior.
Sign in to comment. Sign in