30
does anyone feel like searching doesn't give them a answer?
searching a specific problem, on what search engine it is…
no satisfactory answer. what else is there? other than just asking questions on lemmy?
searching a specific problem, on what search engine it is…
no satisfactory answer. what else is there? other than just asking questions on lemmy?
Comments
If you use Google, try moving away from that! Half of its results are sponsored and the other half SEO optimised crap nowadays, and there are better search engine alternatives. I would push you towards Qwant and Ecosia, because they are working together to develop a search index independent from Google and Bing (which is being trialled in France and Germany!), and they both have much stronger privacy policies, being hosted in the EU after all. They are both as easy to use as Google, no excuses for something being too “different” (it’s just a search box and your results)
Between Qwant (blue and glowy) and Ecosia (green and flat), the difference is mostly whether you prefer the look of one over the other. Ecosia is also a non-profit that uses some of its revenue to plant trees, which is pretty awesome! If you want to look at their reports, they’re easily accessible on their website. Qwant is still great though, and you will get good results from either!
Avoid Startpage (owned by an advertising company as far as I understand) and Brave (involved in weird crypto stuff, replacing affiliate links, etc.). DuckDuckGo has become a lot closer to Google in terms of the number of sponsored results now, plus they are based in the U.S.
And of course, SearXNG is awesome too, there are lots of public instances (see searx.space for a list), and you can self-host it too. It basically aggregates results from the search engines of your choosing!
well just make a post with the wrong answer and somebody will come to correct you
That used to be the case. Now, LLMs slurp up the wrong answer and regurgitate it until it’s just what everyone believes.
If you look closely, you just created a liar’s paradox with parent comment.
Yup, good ol’ Betteridge’s Law
nope its Poe’s Law
It’s the Pareto principle, numbnuts.
I subscribed to Kagi over a year ago. Once and a while I’ll try another engine and they’re all terrible by comparison.
Highly recommended if you can swing it.
Search has grown worse IMO to push you to use ai more. Ai reviews, ai sites, they need to give the appearance of it working better so you’ll use it. To do this they dumbed it way down.
Use something other than Google or Bing, like Ecosia, Qwant, or Mojeek.
Search has been worse for over a decade, SEO optimization race killed it plus advertising.
Yes but it got exponentially worse to promote AI!
Idk I just use 4get and serxng mainly. Sometimes that Google AI overview is helpful at work tho
It’s gotten terrible over the last 5 years. AI slop is infecting everything and causing so much noise, it’s impossible to find real info anymore.
Best I can suggest is searches across Starpage, DDG, Qwant and Brave. When one fails, try the next one.
tenbluelinks.org gets you to have the web api for google. Can install it in your browser. I’ve been using it fr a year, even managed to build a shortcut (I named it “Google no AI”) in Safari on iOS and searches are tolerable on google again.
yes, which is why i add “reddit” to the end of each search. if i dont find my answer there, i come here
Cant do it anymore, they have limited it as a search trm and reddit require sign in. And also reddit is astroturfed to shit now too
weird, i dont get a prompt to sign in unless the community has “adult content” which seems to be interpreted loosely at times lol
I was getting away with it for months, came yo an end two weeks ago. Sucks but I would rather go without than take part.
I get a prompt to sign in for every Reddit link, no matter what it is now
Old reddit desktop mode
Requires an account now
Oh woops, haven’t used reddit since we started lemmy
What are you searching for?
Search has gotten progressively worse over the past 10 years, and 5ish years ago it got so bad that it was a problem.
I gave up on Google as a search engine as the results nowadays seem like filler content tailored towards page rankings.
I started using Kagi about a year ago, and searching feels useful again. Highly recommended.
Or just stores. God forbid I just want a user manual for something but instead it’s 3 pages of marketplaces and then ads for the damn thing for a couple weeks.
Noai.duckduckgo.com
Still not the best, but it searches the web in the old school way, so it’s more reliable.
I stubbornly clung to Google despite years of increasing problems out of habit and convenience. I just switched to DuckDuckGo a few weeks ago because I was finally fed up.
The turning point was trying to remember a song with only a few words in my head. I searched multiple variations of it, with and without quotes. The AI response (because I hadn’t turned it off) basically said, “nah mate, there aren’t any songs that say anything like that,” and search contained less than 10 total results, none of which were helpful.
Finally I remembered a few more words and searched again, and found the exact song. And it included, verbatim, a line I’d previously searched in quotes.
I also searched it on Kagi and didn’t get any results, sadly (I really love the concept of Kagi).
Since switching to DDG has been like going back 8 years in search quality—way better.
That’s my go to as well. I just wish the default page was the noai one and if you wanted slop you had to go to ai.duckduckgo.com
Just add it to the list of available search engines, and then make it the default?
I think what your seeing is search engines don’t work like they used to. They give you what they think you want not what you asked for. Google might have been the first to make there search worse. They want you to use AI instead now. It also sucks. I usually try other search engines other than the main ones. Also indexing the entire web is not easy and would take a large amount of resources to do so some of the smaller ones seem incomplete.
Not really.
Try refining your search terms and/or use advanced search.
Well, IMHO it depends on what kind of answer you expect and what question do you ask.
Maybe you’re not good in asking. Maybe the question is to open ended. Maybe you’re the first person asking.
Yeah, search engines are shit these days. I make posts on help forums if I can’t get an answer. Or am in various Matrix rooms where I might ask as well.
There’s also the issue with the internet being filled with seo slop and bot comments so even if you use a good search engine it’s still feeding you mostly shit.
I often use the time filters to filter out content before 2020. (Of course only for timeless topics)
I also use uBlacklist to filter out obvious AI Slop especially those just reposting human stuff, like grokipedia. (there are also ready made lists for that) as well as highlighting great sources like wikipedia, mdn and what not.
I would say, search isn’t supposed to give you an answer.
It’s supposed to give you the places to learn about the answer.
Ask an LLM. Haters will tell you it’ll just make stuff up but the answer you get is almost certainly correct. Just use your common sense to validate the results just like you would with a search engine.
Let there be downvotes.
How do you validate the answers when you can’t get results through something like a search engine?
Why wouldn’t you just use the validation steps to get the valid answer the first time instead of asking the bullshit machine first?
Not a fan of AI but i did use Duck.ai a couple of times and when i asked, it usually put the source under its answer.
There is an underlying issue with how AI presents sources in a way that doesn’t make it clear why those sources were selected or if they are the current source.
For example, one of the few times I tried AI the sources were older versions of documents not posted to the current website or in half of the cases contradicted the ai answer text. My favorite example is that it used a proposed law as a skurce for a change that never made it out of committee, but also included a link to the actual law that had the right information. A good search engine would just link directly to the law for the correct answer. If it was right a few times in a row I can see someone not checking sources after a while and that introduces a trusted vector for misinformation.
At least with a search engine I can generally tell if the site in the results is reliable, like a university or known organization.
Yeah, manual searching is definitely better in that case. AI could be use as a last resort if you can’t find something or just a quick answer, and even in that, it isn’t reliable much since depending on what AI is trained on and the company behind it. I.e save electricity, your time and use manual searching…
I test them every now and never just so I can be better informed when I call the utter shit (still deeply unethical regardless of quality of the results)
I nce asked chatGPT to make me a 1000€ PC build. It told me that 16GB of DDR5 ram was only 90€, and provided me a link to buy it. To no Ines surprise the link had it listed for 400€. Also it game me a motherboard and CPU combo which were incompatible.
Another one was that my wife was looking for a specific type of yoga classes in our area, but we could not find it. Asked chatGPT with the specific cities and country I was looking for it, and it gave me a link to a yoga studio in a different continent.
If you still.have to validate the results with a search engine, what ianthe point of the massive waste of energy and water?
It’s certainly either correct or laughably incorrect. One of the two. Who are the boring idiots who don’t love playing such a fun game?! And who cares how many rainforests we burn down too, right?!
Use ai
I’ve found AI to be absolute dog shit for any technical issues I’ve tried using it to find answers for. Every time I’ve wasted 10-15 minutes reading and trying to verify it’s nonsense before I give up and just find answers the old fashioned way (or wing it and hope for the best if I can’t). It’s also crap at finding products, which you would think would be an easy one.
What’s an example of a technical issue?
I use it more to rubber duck and also scaffold or search Google and it self to link me to things that I then can read. Other times if I’m reading something and I don’t understand I’ll again feed it into it and then talk it through with it. It’s so much faster than trying to do it with search engines now
A recent one was trying to fix the overscan on a retropie I was trying to get working on my TV. Nothing it told me worked and it changed answers or provided shit that it hallucinated several times.
There was also the time where I was trying to alter a program for a macropad I have that it was just spitting out nonsense.
Ah bummer. I find things wrong here and there. My favorite is when you don’t do anything and ask if it’s sure. Sometimes without any new input it’ll say “you’re right I’m totally wrong the answer is…”
I just see it as a tool. I don’t have much luck searching through endless forums or documents for hours just to find the section i need is worthwhile. I can at get to a direct answer and if it’s wrong I troubleshoot like I do anyways.
You’re going to get downvoted and so am I for agreeing with you because that’s the nature of the internet currently.
I often have a hard time figuring out how to search for what I want. I’ve found I can actually work through some things with ai easier than I can with a search engine and quicker than waiting for the right human to help me.
Absolutely same experience.
This is a bit of a tangent, but I find I’m at odds with a lot of things lately. I’m just miserable lol. One example is I love to learn new things. As an example I learn coding. Early on there’s great resources. Very clear videos of new content creators who have answers. Over the years everybody wants to code. Now the content creators explode. The content slowly over time becomes less useful. Now when I search I have millions of videos on the same thing because they’re all chasing the one video that week whose metrics were the highest. Soon searching for educational videos is super difficult. It’s a broken system.
AI is like that early day now so it’s still fun to use and gets right to the heart of the problem I’m trying to solve and it’s interactive. That’s how I learn. I have a conversation. I’m sorry it’s killing the world. But I’m honestly done being a leftist hero I thought I’d be when I was younger. I’m so tired and I just want to learn stuff and I’m tired of every new thing that comes out being some evil according to the latest lefty gripe.
Look at bitcoin. It fucking sucked. Still sucks. But if any of us invested in it years ago we’d be retired. But we were all here telling each other to stay away. What did that get any of us? Pride? Digital acceptance that we all complied with the latest hater trend? We’re still poor and crypto still exists. It was just an eye opener to me that people online are holding each other back. Id rather use the tools I have to better my position. If it works then it works and I’m not going to let the faceless amorphous body of haters hold me back.
A lot of talk online is just that. All talk. Most of the people (when it’s actually people and not bots) behind these keyboards aren’t doing anything meaningful to change their or others positions in life.
If you’re not finding answers you’re searching wrong, using the wrong search, or being blinded by cascading ads and sponsored content.
noai.duckduckgo.com
Or the content isn’t readily available… Many things have instructions and images out there, others just don’t. Especially when searching something niche or struggling with something not many people do. The answer would be to record that information if we figure it out and find a community online or official site to see if you can submit it but a lot of people don’t want to waste that hour when they just lost however much time trying to figure out something that set them back.
it’s literally a skill issue
So many search engines these days don’t even follow the rules you give in the search like using +/- to include/exclude terms or putting things in quotations to search a specific phrase. Your Google-Fu is now irrelevant because of this bullshit.
Sign in to comment. Sign in