Comment on What wouldn't you have minded so much if it had only been executed better?
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
Gasoline cars made industrialists money, but the rest of your assumptions are incorrect.
There were several electric vehicles in production in the early 1900s, 20-30 years after gasoline vehicles had been developed, popular because they were already more comfortable, reliable, cleaner and easier to fix and maintain, and would become more so as production improved.
Oil barons systematically bought out and destroyed all electric vehicle companies throughout the late 1800s and early 1900s.
Until industrialists systematically destroyed electric vehicle infrastructure, the future of the automobile was either stagnant, largely unimprovable combustion engine vehicles that the world was forced into for a century, or electric vehicles which are much more easily improved but because they last longer and consume less fuel, don’t make exploitatatuve industrialists as much money.
If fuel companies and industrial capitalists hadn’t blocked and destroyed the potential of electric vehicles 100 years ago, EV technology would be decades ahead of where it is now and automobile exhaust and noise pollution would never have been a global issue in the first place.
And we could have charged those electric vehicles with… checks notes… burned fossil fuels, just to lose efficiency for giggles.
Some y’all’s understanding of capitalism is straight childish. “There was always a better solution, but the evil capitalists held it down!”
Know why the world went with burning oil? Because it was the most bang (heh) for the buck. That simple. No evil men smoking cigars in back rooms required. Now we have better tech and can move on, but that wasn’t the case until recently.
Yes, in your utopian little world, we all could have worked together for the better solutions from the start. Oh, wait… would those solutions have cost more and consumers would have fucked those off? It must be an evil plot! (Though is mostly is at present time.)
Funny enough, I made the perfect meme last year to describe this conversation.
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/3c0d649b-5558-49d9-be8d-6c0eb363f1a3.png
You’re just missing the term “path dependency”
The incredibly efficient ICE that loses 70%+ of generated power at peak efficiency?
The rapid advance of battery technology in just the last decade is one example of what the global fuel industry could have been, and electric cars would have kickstarted that.
Technologies build on what came before. We could not have had this new battery tech 30-years ago. That was my main point. Could we have evolved away from ICE sooner? You fucking bet! But not so much in the 20th century, and now it’s past time to press the attack on renewables.
Everybody swears you can’t do something until it’s done, then in hindsight, it was inevitable. The automobile industry could have stuck with EVs and chose not to because of short-sightedness, so a bunch of our technology is a century behind.
It happens.
I’m back to, technologies build on what came before. Lion battery factories weren’t possible without oil. We couldn’t have cranked out 18650s in the 70s, and why would we with oil so abundant? (OK, except for that one time. 🫤) Did evolution take a wrong turn lately? It often does!
Oil was so cheap and plentiful, and global warming wasn’t a thing. We can point to industry reports or ancient newspaper articles that saw it coming, but it wasn’t in the public conscious.
What I’m trying to spit out, and failing to do, is that getting away from oil is both a societal and technological evolution. In hindsight, of course we could have done it sooner! But there are those pesky societal and technological changes that hadn’t come yet.
After the turn of the 20th, electric vehicles were still a niche novelty marketed exclusively to wealthy women. And at a time when women needed a man to open a bank account for them. If you were stuck marketing to women in 1908, its because you had literally no other market for your product.
They lacked the power or range to actually do anything meaningful. The internal combustion engine while noisy, smelly, dirty, and complex, was able to do actual work. By 1920 a whole trucking industry suddenly existed, tractors and industrial farm equipment were becoming common. Engines were doing things electric vehicles couldn’t begin to match for decades more.
Like I said, cheep oil from the ground is what made all the difference. If that discovery was 30-50 later maybe electric could have gotten a foothold and become something. But that’s only a maybe.
Any shenanigans the early oil companies did (and there was much shenanigans) was unwarranted. Even with a perfectly fair market electric vehicles couldn’t compete at the time.
By the way, this is comming from someone who’s been drooling over electrics since the GM EV1, and loves his year old Ioniq 5. Today electric is superior in every way. 100 years ago that just wasn’t the case.
Oohhh boy. Cheaper oil didn’t eliminate automobiles, profit motive did, which is the critical difference here.
The “shenanigans” you’re referring to was the systematic dismantling of a superior vehicle industry that threatened entrenched interests.
If we pretend you’re correct and gasoline was invented after electric vehicles, you’d still be missing the point of this post.
The question is which inventions users would appreciate more if they had been implemented correctly.
If oil barons hadn’t deliberately killed the electric car in order to protect their investment in and dedication to crude oil as a fuel, I wouldn’t mind automobiles so much.
Because industrialists did collude to block the development of the electric car, streets have been loud and dirty and motor oil has been poisoning the earth for a century when none of that ever needed to happen.
Cheep oil enabled the wide spread use of automobiles. I don’t know why you’d think anyone said it eliminated them.
Not what I’m referring to. See Killers of the Flower Moon (2023) for details.
My point is, at the time Electric wasn’t superior. It was cleaner, easier, and nicer to operate, but far less capable. Hense inferior at the time.
The first “Electric Carrage” was invented in the 1830s. The first mas market version in the US was in 1890.
The process for refineing crude oil into other products such as gasoline, was invented in 1891.
First: The electric was made my industrialists also. There were no noble “good guys” in this environment.
Second: My point again, is it didn’t matter that the oil industrialists screwed over the electric industrialists. Electric at the time couldn’t begin to compete with internal combustion engines.
Your “point” is that you don’t understand the question or answer.
Let me try to explain once more.
The question asks what do you wish was executed better so we’d have it today.
Your answer is early EVs at the turn of the 20th century.
My critique is that they executed as well as they could, it still wasn’t good enough.
Does that make sense now?
Sign in to comment. Sign in