Skip to content

Comment on What wouldn't you have minded so much if it had only been executed better?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • @Steve@communick.news· · edited

    Cheaper oil didn’t eliminate automobiles

    Cheep oil enabled the wide spread use of automobiles. I don’t know why you’d think anyone said it eliminated them.

    systematic dismantling of a superior vehicle industry

    Not what I’m referring to. See Killers of the Flower Moon (2023) for details.

    My point is, at the time Electric wasn’t superior. It was cleaner, easier, and nicer to operate, but far less capable. Hense inferior at the time.

    If we pretend you’re correct and gasoline was invented after electric vehicles

    The first “Electric Carrage” was invented in the 1830s. The first mas market version in the US was in 1890.
    The process for refineing crude oil into other products such as gasoline, was invented in 1891.

    Because industrialists did collude to block the development of the electric car

    First: The electric was made my industrialists also. There were no noble “good guys” in this environment.
    Second: My point again, is it didn’t matter that the oil industrialists screwed over the electric industrialists. Electric at the time couldn’t begin to compete with internal combustion engines.

    0
    • Your “point” is that you don’t understand the question or answer.

      0
      • Let me try to explain once more.

        The question asks what do you wish was executed better so we’d have it today.

        Your answer is early EVs at the turn of the 20th century.

        My critique is that they executed as well as they could, it still wasn’t good enough.

        Does that make sense now?

        -1
        • Your assertion rhat stagnant technology and unsustainable fuel is a better foundation for the automobile industry than dynamic, improvable technology and renewable resources makes the exact same amount of nonsense it did the first time.

          The oil barons applaud your devotion to grime.

          Your answer is early EVs at the turn of the 20th century.

          nope, not at all. read.

          0

Sign in to comment. Sign in