Skip to content

Comment on Is South Korea "Over"? Is Japan on the verge of "Collapse"? Do these narratives have real evidence or just exaggerating/fearmongering?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Sudden large population changes can cause problems. Everyone seems to inherently understand the issue with rapid growth, but I often see people saying rapid decline is totally fine and sometimes even a good thing, actually.

    Every job suddenly being understaffed would be a challenge. Every piece of infrastructure suddenly being oversized creates inefficiencies. National pensions take money from workers and give it to the elderly, which only works if workers far outnumber the elderly. Some countries are headed to a 1:1 ratio and China is estimated to soon have 5 dependents for every 1 worker. Pension plans will go bankrupt.

    All of this will happen all at once, everywhere, in a few decades. I don’t think it’s going to create apocalyptic scenarios, but people were freaking out over gas prices being twice as expensive, imagine what they’re going to do when their pension payments stop.

    0
    • the global economy is built on massive amounts of debt which literally borrow from future growth in productivity to build today. If there isn’t more people to build stuff next year than this year, the whole thing falls apart.

      Economic collapse sounds good to an anti-capitalist but it doesn’t feed them or their family, it leads to mass starvation and disease.

      0
    • It’s not a huge deal. It’s self balancing to a degree and it will be hard on pensions in a short term but will see drastically lower housing costs.

      0
    • Yeah the number of people on Lemmy cheering on demographic collapse is insane. Things need to happen at a slow controlled pace, and it doesn’t look to be happening that way.

      0

Sign in to comment. Sign in