Comment on Can we control an ssd temperature by throttling it somehow, like we can do with cpus?
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
Superglue is ca glue. Ca glue chemically bonds to itself and mechanically bonds to the surfaces it’s put between. I would like to know the kind of glue you are talking about. I never instructed the op to glue a nut to their ssd, however that would be a fine thing to do.
If it’s not clear by now: yes, I believe the problems will be resolved with a heatsink. They asked about how to stop losing ssds in an environment with passive cooling and the answer is a heatsink. Even if I didn’t have a wealth of theoretical knowledge that can simply be regurgitated while on the toilet to people who will not read it, I also have experience dealing with flash memory in sealed, passively cooled and high vibration environments which indicates that conclusion.
Here’s how a heatsink will resolve their problems: the heatsinks huge increase to their nand chips thermal mass will reduce the effect that periodic reads and writes have on its die temperature and the heatsinks much greater surface area and better transfer properties will dump that heat into the ambient air much faster than the surface of their nand chips package will.
Their pc has vents and is designed to rely on passive cooling. Perhaps it will last a long time, perhaps not. Pulling the ol “would that end racism? Would that end sexism?” Is akin in this instance to rushing into the operating theater to disrupt an in progress remediation of gunshot trauma to inform the staff that the persons heart disease is a big deal.
And how’s that going considering 3 ssd failures and current idle temp of 67C versus the expected 40’s? You’re clearly not so dumb that you don’t know that a heatspreader will have its limits when you’re up against dead air so this is plainly what’s called being wilfully obtuse. And OP is the one who will suffer for it.
Funny, I’d liken your advice to putting a bandaid on a gunshot wound. But keep telling yourself you’re a trauma surgeon and not the janitor in a lab coat that OP was unfortunate enough to stumble into. Learn to admit when you’re wrong.
Based on what we know about the pc it’s going fine. The pc is still running. Were asked about how to fix a problem with an ssd.
You seem real bent out of shape about this. It’s not a big deal. The op got lots of advice and input, I sent them two links to heatsinks that will most likely fit just fine. Why not just wait and see how things turn out? There’s no need to continue to be insulting and confrontational.
Dumbass.
The knowledge and experience to reliably predict how this will end and empathy for anyone who has to deal with a PC sudden (or more likely slow and bizarre) death event.
Okay dumbass.
There is no reason to be aggressive, insulting and confrontational the way you are.
If you can’t make your point without resorting to personal attacks then consider not replying until you’re cooled off.
It’s pretty clear from what I said that I’m referring to the pc still running fine while multiple ssds have died.
From what I can tell the other components the op references are: the WiFi module. Unfortunately radio baseband chips were well into their implementation without any kind of heat mitigation era when this pc was manufactured. That’s another part that could likely benefit from sticking a heatsink on, lots of desktop motherboards and even some laptops have some kind of heatsink or pad coupling the radio to the chassis. Probably glue a nut to that too, straighten it right out. Radio is even more duty cycle dependent than ssds due to the nature of ip communication. It’s likely what drove thousands of devices to be designed without any way to deal with the heat from those little things. Why spend five times the cost of the chip sticking a sink on there when it’ll just automatically throttle down to protect itself was probably the engineering calculus.
What does the present +22C leap from expected idle ssd temps signify? How much energy does this take, where is it coming from and how much do you expect it to drop with even a puny 60mm fan circulating air in the area? What does not addressing this signify for overall system lifespan?
It doesn’t take much experience to get these answers right (which you have loads of!!!) but it does take skill to be this wilfully dense. Which puts you among that one group of people you always find in any newbie-oriented hardware forum, people who offer bad but seemingly well-meaning advice, but are well-meeaning only up to the point where they have to admit they are wrong at which point they do what you’re doing and double down for ego’s sake. This deserves ire.
FYI when a real trauma surgeon hears “heart problem”, they’re thinking beta blockers, blood thinners and vasodilators - you know, the stuff most cardiac patients take that would cause you to bleed out on the operating table without special precautions. An ironic demonstration of your inability to scratch beyond the surface of any given topic. I bet you don’t even clean the toilets properly.
Sign in to comment. Sign in