Skip to content

Comment on Big Walk Used AI In 'The Final Stretch' Of Development, Kicking Off Intense Awards Debate

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • It’s never about their use case. Its about how ai steals everything in order to provide any answer at all, and how destructive even providing that answer ends up being.

    This might seem reasonable on its face, but who did the LLM company steal the answer from without accreditation? Who’s neighbourhood is being ruined by the data centre?

    It’s that ultimately there is no ethical use of LLMs

    1
    • Well id argue local llms + don’t support the people making them is probably fine, so long as you’re not letting it do web searches constantly so you aren’t ddosing the internet.

      0
      • They absolutely do. Just because you took the plagiarism machine offline after it stole everything and then destroyed ecosystems and neighborhoods to produce the resulting dataset doesn’t mean it’s any better than the fascist empowering online ones. It’s exactly the same. Being ever so slightly better because you’re using your own power from the power company instead of someone else isn’t worth the destruction caused to get to a point where your offline sycophant machine can sometimes confidently not lie to you.

        0
        • How? I’m not paying any of the companies or supporting the people who made it in any way. This is the equivalent of a vegan eating some meat that was about to be thrown in the trash. I’m also only using it for coding some personal use slop anyway, and most of the stolen code was GPL / MIT license which means for personal use there isn’t even a license issue. Me using it offline and telling everyone not to pay for it and that the data scraping is terrible is nowhere near the same as someone paying and supporting these companies.

          0
          • This. I’d love to see how a model trained 100% on resources that are out of copyright or permissive licensing might actually work out.

            There’s actually a lot of historical media and plenty of code that could qualify

            -1
    • Google search is using AI at this point, but prior to that should summarize popular results when it wasn’t just pointing at SEO’ed crap or various stack-overflow/EE/Quora articles.

      AI for a similar purpose - finding and collating publicly available information - seems ok to me. I’m more interested in the various solutions I’ve contributed online being available and useful to somebody than attrition.

      But if course the models themselves are built on a lot more than that, unfortunately. Still, AI doing basic search and analysis to provide suggestions versus actually writing the core software seems like a good evolution of “search” functionality

      -1
      • Almost all content providers would disagree. Anyway, I don’t use Google because of this.

        1

Sign in to comment. Sign in