Skip to content

Comment on Musicians: do you notice your ability to hear and understand music is different depending on the instrument you play?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • i also grew up playing clarinet. the fact that it overblows a 12th makes it really hard to see patterns, because the fingerings are different for every note in every octave, without getting into the trill keys

    i still predominantly play winds, but i “think” in piano because that’s what i learned theory on. it’s kinda the lingua franca because it’s built around western theory, what with the white keys being the naturals. can’t play for shit though!

    someday i’d like to get a harmonetta because the way notes are laid out makes stacking thirds into chords easy. it’s a shame they never really took off

    0
    • Were you mostly reading music? I was playing by ear, and two things about that 12th: it’s really just a fifth, and the scale pattern at five are basically the same as at one–whole step, whole step, half step… so I think I remember the fingerings working the same. Plus, I’ve got the right half of the circle of fifths memorized as a guitarist, but the left hand side needs a little work for all the clarinet keys (and I’m not transposing shit, thinking about the notes as their true values).

      harmonetta

      This is the worst thing you’ve ever done, friend, introducing me to this marvelous instrument that is simultaneously unavailable! I thought it would scratch my currently-unaffordable accordion itch, but the only thing I found was one for 700 pounds on Reverb, already sold!

      But if you’re into easily making chords, the Stradella left hand side of the base, arranged in fifths, has major, minor, major 7, and diminished chords all in a row. Super easy. But I think building chords yourself probably teaches you a lot more.

      1

Sign in to comment. Sign in