Deflation (opposite of inflation) encourages people to put money under the pillow and wait for it to increase in value. If everyone does this the economy stagnates.
Inflation encourages people to spend the money now or invest it. Your spending is someone else’s income and their spending is your income. Investing is you risking your money to have someone else buy something that hopefully makes them more productive.
Too high inflation causes loss of trust in the currency and people start hoarding bricks or something else non perishable and the economy stagnates.
So central banks say that they will manipulate the currency so that the inflation is around say 2% which is low enough for people to trust it but high enough to encourage spending/investing.
Yes, but a healthy economy becomes more active if there is a healthy inflation to provide additional lube. 2% is roughly where inflation offers pretty good lubricant without being a pita
It’s worth calling out that there’s no real justification for that 2% figure. It’s a number that was pulled out of the air by the New Zealand version of the Fed in the late 80s, and it seems to work well, so everyone copied it.
There’s pretty broad consensus among economists that deflation is bad, and that inflation above about 3-4% is bad. Beyond that, we’re literally just guessing.
It’s a number that was pulled out of the air by the New Zealand version of the Fed in the late 80s, and it seems to work well, so everyone copied it.
I think it’s worth pointing out that it’s all part of the neoliberalism fad that originated around that time. There are other ways to run an economy, but this inflation target one works well for neoliberalism because the wealthy own assets which hold their value through inflation. The middle class and below have money, which loses value through inflation. They pay what money they do have largely (directly or eventually) to the wealthy who then use it to buy more assets.
Sorry I may have channelled too much Gary Stevenson there.
Just want to point put the whole “Deflation makes people not want to spend” thing is bullshit conjured up by a wealthy economist.
In reality the inverse happens - deflation makes the general population spend and inflation makes people save. This is because if you’re expecting things to get expensive, you stop spending on things you might want so you can have money for emergencies and things you might need. This isn’t even theory - you can just look at historical spending patterns.
Inflation primarily benefits the wealthy, because hoarding billions is pointless under deflation.
I have read that it’s also very hard to break out of deflation so you can’t just try it a little, and the same goes for hyper inflation. A bit like walking the razors edge. What’s your thoughts on that?
Could someone for once please explain what you guys actually mean when you say the wealthy are hoarding money? I don’t think I’ve ever gotten a straight answer to this.
Let’s say I make $2500 a month, and I buy a car. The payments are $250 a month, so that’s 10% of my income.
If Elon Musk buys a car, even though it costs $3 million, while my car cost about $35,000, he doesn’t even need a loan. He just buys it, and the change in his bank account is so small that he can barely see the difference. He could buy ten more cars like that and not notice.
And yes, he can keep buying cars, but at some point there just stop being more cars to buy. Lamborghini can only make so many new models every year.
Maybe I spend $25 on lunch. Maybe Elon spends $2500 dollars on lunch. He spent a hundred times as much as me, but he makes millions of times more than me, and he can only eat one lunch.
So at some point there’s just a limit to how much the rich can actually spend. Yes, it’s a lot more than any single one of us, but it’s a lot less than all of us put together. We spend, they save. Where my paycheck goes into rent, car payments, food, and so on, Elon’s money goes into investments. In fact, he’s mostly paid in investments. So my money goes to other people, whereas his money stays in his pocket.
No because it doesn’t answer my question. I asked about hoarding wealth - you’re talking about spending habits. Your average billionaire can’t just walk into a bank and withdraw, say 10 million. They probably don’t have anything even close to that much of liquid wealth.
Already have thousands of times over. My ‘net worth’ is almost entirely due to my ownership stakes in Tesla and SpaceX. I have <0.1% that is cash. Tesla and SpaceX employees all receive stock/options and Tesla is >80% owned by retail investors and index/pension funds, so value increases apply >80% to them.
You’re right! They can’t just walk into a bank and withdraw 10 million!
Instead, they take out a loan for 10 million against a collateral of 20 million in stocks, expense the interest, claim 0 income and therefore no income tax, and have that transferred to their bank account. Then they withdraw 10 million, while their stocks continue to gain (or lose) value, and at some point they have to take some portion of their dividends as income rather than rolling them into more stocks or, God forbid, sell some of those stocks to pay back the loan.
In a technical sense, no, that money isn’t just sitting in a bank account, but there’s a weird effect. If you only have a small amount of stocks, say a few million worth, you can sell them off in a relatively short period without harming the stock because it’s just a blip at most in normal volatility. If you have a lot, say billions, you can sell enough to do whatever the average person would ever want to do with only slightly more volatility than is some nobody did it, and much of that is due to the visibility of a billionaire doing that. If that billionaire needs more than a few million, he can just follow the process outlined above with no impact at all to the stock market and a number of benefits to himself. So in a practical sense, if you only have a little stocks, say millions, accessing those millions may take days or weeks, but if you have billions, you can access it only slightly slower than I can withdraw $100.
This money is still in the economy and helping to economy to function overall, but the majority of that benefit is only experienced by one person, the billionaire. This is effectively them hoarding those billions, not because they’re sitting in an account but because a single person is experiencing the majority of that benefit while the rest is spread across thousands or perhaps millions of people.
The relative amount of spending that rich people do to their net worth or whatever is much much smaller than the amount of spending middle class and poor people do.
If you think of a minimum wage worker who rents, nearly every dollar they make is back into the economy nearly immediately.
I on the other hand have maybe a third of my yearly income sitting in a high yield savings account.
Someone calculated that the amount that musk spent on the elections was the equivalent of a minimum wage worker spending like $30. He’s not doing that daily so he’s not using the equivalent amounts of money.
That is not what I asked about, though. The claim was that they’re hoarding money/wealth. This makes it sound like they have a lair full of chash somewhere like Scrooge McDuck.
Musk owns multiple succesful companies. His “wealth” is the value of these companies. You can’t buy a house by stating you own SpaceX, they want cash.
Comments
Focus on simplicity rather than details:
Deflation (opposite of inflation) encourages people to put money under the pillow and wait for it to increase in value. If everyone does this the economy stagnates.
Inflation encourages people to spend the money now or invest it. Your spending is someone else’s income and their spending is your income. Investing is you risking your money to have someone else buy something that hopefully makes them more productive.
Too high inflation causes loss of trust in the currency and people start hoarding bricks or something else non perishable and the economy stagnates.
So central banks say that they will manipulate the currency so that the inflation is around say 2% which is low enough for people to trust it but high enough to encourage spending/investing.
So inflation isn’t actually good, it’s an active economy that’s good
Yes, but a healthy economy becomes more active if there is a healthy inflation to provide additional lube. 2% is roughly where inflation offers pretty good lubricant without being a pita
It’s worth calling out that there’s no real justification for that 2% figure. It’s a number that was pulled out of the air by the New Zealand version of the Fed in the late 80s, and it seems to work well, so everyone copied it.
There’s pretty broad consensus among economists that deflation is bad, and that inflation above about 3-4% is bad. Beyond that, we’re literally just guessing.
I think it’s worth pointing out that it’s all part of the neoliberalism fad that originated around that time. There are other ways to run an economy, but this inflation target one works well for neoliberalism because the wealthy own assets which hold their value through inflation. The middle class and below have money, which loses value through inflation. They pay what money they do have largely (directly or eventually) to the wealthy who then use it to buy more assets.
Sorry I may have channelled too much Gary Stevenson there.
Just want to point put the whole “Deflation makes people not want to spend” thing is bullshit conjured up by a wealthy economist.
In reality the inverse happens - deflation makes the general population spend and inflation makes people save. This is because if you’re expecting things to get expensive, you stop spending on things you might want so you can have money for emergencies and things you might need. This isn’t even theory - you can just look at historical spending patterns.
Inflation primarily benefits the wealthy, because hoarding billions is pointless under deflation.
I have read that it’s also very hard to break out of deflation so you can’t just try it a little, and the same goes for hyper inflation. A bit like walking the razors edge. What’s your thoughts on that?
This songs like it makes sense, but a reference would be very useful
Could someone for once please explain what you guys actually mean when you say the wealthy are hoarding money? I don’t think I’ve ever gotten a straight answer to this.
It’s really just simple math.
Let’s say I make $2500 a month, and I buy a car. The payments are $250 a month, so that’s 10% of my income.
If Elon Musk buys a car, even though it costs $3 million, while my car cost about $35,000, he doesn’t even need a loan. He just buys it, and the change in his bank account is so small that he can barely see the difference. He could buy ten more cars like that and not notice.
And yes, he can keep buying cars, but at some point there just stop being more cars to buy. Lamborghini can only make so many new models every year.
Maybe I spend $25 on lunch. Maybe Elon spends $2500 dollars on lunch. He spent a hundred times as much as me, but he makes millions of times more than me, and he can only eat one lunch.
So at some point there’s just a limit to how much the rich can actually spend. Yes, it’s a lot more than any single one of us, but it’s a lot less than all of us put together. We spend, they save. Where my paycheck goes into rent, car payments, food, and so on, Elon’s money goes into investments. In fact, he’s mostly paid in investments. So my money goes to other people, whereas his money stays in his pocket.
Make sense?
No because it doesn’t answer my question. I asked about hoarding wealth - you’re talking about spending habits. Your average billionaire can’t just walk into a bank and withdraw, say 10 million. They probably don’t have anything even close to that much of liquid wealth.
From Elon’s twitter
You’re right! They can’t just walk into a bank and withdraw 10 million!
Instead, they take out a loan for 10 million against a collateral of 20 million in stocks, expense the interest, claim 0 income and therefore no income tax, and have that transferred to their bank account. Then they withdraw 10 million, while their stocks continue to gain (or lose) value, and at some point they have to take some portion of their dividends as income rather than rolling them into more stocks or, God forbid, sell some of those stocks to pay back the loan.
In a technical sense, no, that money isn’t just sitting in a bank account, but there’s a weird effect. If you only have a small amount of stocks, say a few million worth, you can sell them off in a relatively short period without harming the stock because it’s just a blip at most in normal volatility. If you have a lot, say billions, you can sell enough to do whatever the average person would ever want to do with only slightly more volatility than is some nobody did it, and much of that is due to the visibility of a billionaire doing that. If that billionaire needs more than a few million, he can just follow the process outlined above with no impact at all to the stock market and a number of benefits to himself. So in a practical sense, if you only have a little stocks, say millions, accessing those millions may take days or weeks, but if you have billions, you can access it only slightly slower than I can withdraw $100.
This money is still in the economy and helping to economy to function overall, but the majority of that benefit is only experienced by one person, the billionaire. This is effectively them hoarding those billions, not because they’re sitting in an account but because a single person is experiencing the majority of that benefit while the rest is spread across thousands or perhaps millions of people.
The relative amount of spending that rich people do to their net worth or whatever is much much smaller than the amount of spending middle class and poor people do.
If you think of a minimum wage worker who rents, nearly every dollar they make is back into the economy nearly immediately.
I on the other hand have maybe a third of my yearly income sitting in a high yield savings account.
Someone calculated that the amount that musk spent on the elections was the equivalent of a minimum wage worker spending like $30. He’s not doing that daily so he’s not using the equivalent amounts of money.
That is not what I asked about, though. The claim was that they’re hoarding money/wealth. This makes it sound like they have a lair full of chash somewhere like Scrooge McDuck.
Musk owns multiple succesful companies. His “wealth” is the value of these companies. You can’t buy a house by stating you own SpaceX, they want cash.
Sign in to comment. Sign in