Why did nobody fight back when the platforms closed their data?
Been thinking about this and want to know if it bugs anyone else.
It’s crazy to me that Twitter, Reddit and Facebook all cut off API access and people just went quiet on it. There was noise and complaints but no solutions. Usually when stuff like this gets locked down a counterculture shows up around it. Workarounds, open alternatives, people who make it their thing to keep it open. Like file sharing or ad blockers.
That didn’t really happen this time and I can’t figure out why. With all the propaganda and fake stuff out there right now, wouldn’t being able to see what’s spreading be important to understand? And isn’t them shutting it down a pretty large signal that it is important?
Maybe there’s a boring explanation I’m missing. But the part that gets me is the other possibility, that there’s some kind of suppression force we might not even be aware of.
Is that terrifying to anyone else or am I overthinking it? Just curious what people who were around for it think.
Comments
We fucking did! The great Reddit exodus was in response to them closing down their API. That’s why there are so many of us here on Lemmy or other platforms.
Likewise for Twitter, though less so after Elon bought it and turned it into a Nazi platform.
There are folks who still staunchly advocate for open platforms, federation, protocols, etc. These things cost a lot of money and effort to maintain, and those are in short supply now. Not to mention the DMCA makes it a legal quagmire.
Late stage capitalism keeps everyone exhausted. The constant cavalcade of bullshit in politics keeps people mentally drained. There’s only so much time in a day, and if 12 of your 16 hours are dedicated to work there’s not much breathing room for anything else.
I’m calling bullshit on this. The entire internet was built by people spending years building things and cracking them. The speed of solutions have only increased for us too. So why have those solutions stopped. This post isn’t about why don’t we have a Twitter or Facebook clone. It’s asking why didn’t we break the barriers they put up. 20 years ago a 16 year old would be up all night saying fuck Elon and finding a way around the thing they tried to implement. Even now the way people Crack drm. They’re wizards of you like at what is needed to Crack these cryptographic problems.
I guess what’s missing from my mind to yours is why would we do that. I just think the reason they walled this off is so they can run essentially race baiting and culture shifting content like modern cointelpro without opposition, us from getting in the way. If we could say find Facebook groups and collect data for whose posting when and how and what you start to see patterns and can expose the network. But the minute something like AI was out there and anyone could easily shift this massive amounts of data they locked it away and we all went ok that’s fine. So maybe I’m crazy, I know i sound crazy, but I fucking hate racists, I just think there’s so much more we could be doing as a group.
Apparently you weren’t there. We fought, and left when that failed. I modded dozens of niche subs and took my time elsewhere.
This post is like if OP went to Normandy asking why nobody fought the nazis.
Nice analogy. I like it.
Exactly. It was a HUGE issue, especially with Reddit. It started with Reddit changing their API policies and charging insane prices. All third party Reddit readers pleaded with their contacts at Reddit about how the new API changes would kill third party apps, to basically be told too fucking bad.
Users started deleting their accounts or deleting/poisoning their comment history. Once it was clear nothing was going to be done by Mr. Piggy, users decided to either use old.reddit or some other reddit reader clone until word got out about Lemmy/mBin/Mastadon/Bluesky etc.
Yep. Thanks.
There are still ways to scrape reddit content without the API, the data isn’t ‘closed’ despite their anticonsumer practices. The main thing you need API for is participating in those sites, and if you want to know what the fighting back is… Well, you’re looking at it. We left! I’m having a grand old time.
I agree. I also wonder why anyone would want to fight for a site that keeps getting worse and worse?
And not by accident!
Because these spaces now generate so much racism and anti science and anti leftist trash that it leaks into every part of culture and society. I watch kids on their phones all day. They don’t go to lemmy. They go to Facebook, TikTok, Twitter, Reddit. Everybody here is saying left leaning users all left so what is left? What content are the kids today seeing and learning and building their world views from? I get you don’t personally like it. But are you ready for these kids to be voting and running for government and being your coworkers and employer in the next 10 years?
I think they voted this last time, and I’m all in. There are all ages here on lemmy
99% of users on these platforms don’t even know what an API is.
Sure but more of us do here don’t we? I would have thought more people here would share ways to collect it. If we still had access I bet we would have learned alot about how the propaganda is spreading. Who, what and where it was originating from. It’s just strange to me there isn’t a ton of interest in it. Like barely any.
I took people saying they’d punch a nazi to mean they would be willing to fight nazis. Instead I kind of feel like people saw nazis take over their places and went ok we’re going to go over here now.
Whereas I see fighting back as finding out how many comments are needed to tip a post in favor of the left wing, and kicking the nazis off the platform or stopping thier momentum. You know fir mah lazer shit. Leftist coordinate back in the day. Today it’s just not happening.
I just feel like the moment arrived and we were asleep.
We did fight Nazis, then we left. What else do you want? Most of reddit is bots now anyway. Where do you think lemmy came from?
Exactly. What i want is to be able to look into the bots and what they’re doing. I’m just surprised saying this out loud people are like “its not important” to me is literally the most important thing. We’re sitting here on lemmy with the most tech savvy people on the left and people are content with just having a place to read the daily “fuck Trump” post.
We should be looking at and exposing how these networks are working. Racism and right wing culture is growing so fast and rapidly. This blue wave isn’t a result of the left being preferred, it’s a result of the right fucking up and that’s something we should be weary of cause it’ll bounce back. It’ll bounce back because the right control all our digital space and have the eyes and ears of most people since the major platforms have seen these exodus. They can rapidly put information out now.
My thing is why isn’t there a bigger fight on the left to identify and jam this up. Why does it seem like we’re organizing a protest every 6 months but the online stuff were just sitting around.
They’re private companies. Walled gardens intent on luring you in with free goodies and empty promises.
This is like asking “You went to a stranger’s house party with free drinks and chips and they said everyone that stayed had to freebase crack and give some guy your ID. Why didn’t you fight back to stay at the party and drink their free beer and not freebase crack and give up your ID? Why didn’t you seize control of the stranger’s house? They gave you free beer, so you had rights!”
They can do anything they want, as they own the domain and servers and code. Social media is not a human right just because enough people use it. And people did complain. But ultimately, the only real choice is to simply leave the party once it gets weird. The trick they pull is making you think you can’t leave and have to stay.
Let me guess, you also use free email and don’t think about all the data harvested from you that pays for that email hosting and data storage?
You are literally posting on the platform built to fight back.
🤷♂️
Yeah I came here to say, this is the solution lol
It’s literally the reason I’m here, after 15+ years on reddit. And haven’t looked back.
Same, I‘m not leaving my content in a walled garden to help a corporation worth billions make more profit.
(Wikipedia) Reddit API Controversy
The pushback from reddit cutting its api access was subreddits closing access, intentionally making using the platform more difficult, and moving to alternatives
While reddit couldn’t exactly stop the last two, a sizable amount of the participating subreddits had their moderation team forcefully replaced, not always by people experienced in managing such large communities
The scars of the event are absolutely still around tho, a lot of people on lemmy are originally from reddit (myself included), many old comments are Redactd, and some traditions were born out of it (r/programmerhumor post titles being camelCase was part of their protest)
johnoliver.jpg
I feel like everyone who cared about reddit closing its API, is here. (I know that’s why I moved here and haven’t been back since.) I stopped using Twitter around the time they started charging more, but Elon kinda killed what was left anyway. I left facebook 10+yrs ago at this point, so I don’t know about their API.
Honestly though, API’s aren’t that big of a deal to 99.9% of people.
People moved to Lemmy to build an open alternative. Everything you described as not happening is happening on Lemmy.
I really do see your point, but I don’t think you’re giving younger generations enough credit. There’s a growing movement of young people opting out of big tech. They’re dusting off their parents’ old iPods, going back to retro games, reading physical books, and so on.
Honestly, I’ve always considered myself a technologist, but with the direction tech is heading, I’ve decided to mostly opt out too.
So much of our technology has been compromised. The oligarchs who control it can use AI to fake whatever they want and push any agenda they like. The disruption you’re describing is nothing compared to the all-out psychological assault we’ve been under for years. Anything you try will get filtered out or buried by their countermeasures.
Open source is the best thing we have going for us. Even so, I think the best thing we can collectively do is… disconnect.
And reconnect IRL.
The average user doesn’t know or care what API access is. The small percentage who do have moved to the alternatives we have today.
A lot of the people who could develop workarounds moved to Lemmy. We are the open alternative.
came to say this. I came during that upheval over here. Ironically not so much because of the api thing as much as I had found there was an alternative. I think I had seen things about mastadon before but I never liked the twitter thing so it did not appeal. When I found out there was an open source and not centralized control forum experience like this I was jazzed.
What do you mean by work around?
You did. I did. We’re here.
Lemmy launched in 2019, not 2023. I actually looked at it previously and there were like three servers with few communities or topics of discussion other than tankie and extreme-left politics. Now there are a bunch of servers, mostly run by level-headed people, and a bunch of communities about all sorts of topics.
The migration was smaller than I’d hoped, but it happened, and we should do our best to make sure it’s a welcoming place for the next wave.
There definitely seems to be a new wave that I’m a part of. I went to Tumblr from reddit in 2023 but it didn’t really stick. If I get tired of Lemmy I don’t know where I’d go at this point tbh, I’m hoping the federated layout means I can just sort of bounce from instance to instance if one grows stale.
You usually don’t need to, because you can reach most communities from most instances.
The only major fight was Reddit and that was because major tools were designed around their access. Twitter cut access when it was still relatively new and Facebook never offered meaningful access.
Reddit just started a trial in my region where you can’t access it any more without logging in - well fuck them - app deleted, hello Lemmy 🙂
Hello there, grab a cookie!
The people that did care did fight. The problem is that the people who cared enough to fight or take a stand are dwarfed by the people who don’t even know what an API is, and the companies ability to make huge money off the remaining companies that use the APIs.
In the world of capitalism your fighting back only matters if you hit their bottom line. Nothing the tech literate folks could do would make the math around Reddit and twitters API changes work in our favor.
API access to a web app is controlled entirely at the server. There’s no external workaround that anyone could implement that would do anything. Any action that would be effective would require breaking into the corporate servers, which would be blatantly illegal and would also be found fairly quickly and fixed, so the risk would not be worth the reward. Anyone with the necessary skills and experience already knows this.
Literally nobody fought back? What’s your definition of “nobody” and “fight back”?
[deleted]
would say when most comments I saw online said some version of “don’t even argue with them, it’s like wrestling with pigs” is when I started to notice our spaces being given away.
I’ll be the first to admit I’m terminally online. With that comes alot of vibes, so I get this is vibes. But my experience is that leftists don’t like confrontation. I saw many spaces start out resisting when MAGA and racists began to show up, but they quickly lost interest and left. My instinct when I see a space getting turned is to stubbornly prevent it as much as possible. Other people have more common sense. But it’s almost always inevitable.
Look, I noticed this prior to 2016. I know at least one step in how they accomplished this. They built a network. They made some accounts like parent nodes connected to child nodes, and each one would build networks and sub networks in different areas. Then once those accounts had a good amount of real human followers, they connected the human followers together. Now they had a logistical supply line to disseminate information rapidly. The parent node drops a story and within hours its posted everywhere. Then your Dan Bonginos and Charlie Kirks and Shapiros boost it.
It isn’t organic. It didn’t just build itself, it was forced, and the left didn’t do anything similiar.
There were multiple steps where I saw the right building something, and to this day they’re still doing it. Why the fuck is there a Bobs Burgers group on Facebook who only posts about trans people in bathrooms. There’s one for every cartoon.
What i said is hyperbole sure, but like this api issue, I feel like things are oddly silent and I’m worried while the right are building things, we’re destroying them thinking we’re building them.
Why would anybody use these obvious tools of fascist billionaires in the first place? Cast it into the fire! Delete it!
So you left but the world is still on these fascist billionaire tools. Their kids are on their learning. They will be adults one day. So running away to lemmy is great for a minute. Are you ready for the next generation raised on nothing but MAGA and heritage foundation digital spaces?
You can say fuck em all you want but I think we’re making a huge mistake right now and it’s terrifying to me how people don’t see it and or actively encourage it
They did. They just didn’t fight enough or in a tough enough manner. Also, not everyone is so tech literate or even know what that means.
They’re all so big now, and the vast, vast majority of people posting to them do not care. They don’t know what an API is, they didn’t know there were third party apps to begin with, and the dismantling of all of that third party infrastructure happened in a totally different world to their own. That has left the “counter culture” having to decide between all of that content they’ve been binging for years, and that is still over there because they weren’t the ones making it, or having to do the work of building something new and empty.
And yet, there are still 10s of thousands of us here…
Reddit is fucking terrible, a wasteland filled with bots, AI and loser mods on power trips, who happen to be also unpaid. I can’t wait for it to crash like digg did.
XMPP was the first to fall and most just accepted it. gTalk federation with Facebook? That was 2015~
In my case, it’s because I’m fully done with reddit. There is no salvaging anything from it. I’d rather just be in user-friendly spaces like lemmy and irc.
Sign in to comment. Sign in