Skip to content

Comment on the fascists are running tech

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • The fear of opening a port is what killed us IMO.

    Imagine connecting to another computer, without (Gasp!) going through a centralised server?!!

    /Rant off I guess

    35
    • I’m still kinda that Opera Unite didn’t take off. It was a decentralized server built into the Opera browser, that was easy enough for regular people to use. You just set it up in a config UI in the browser and could enable features like chat, blogs, photo galleries, a music player, etc. At the time, everyone had UPnP enabled, CGNAT wasn’t a thing, and Opera handled UDP hole punching for it, so it mostly just worked. https://www.wired.com/2009/10/opera-unite-puts-the-web-server-in-your-web-browser/

      This was back when Opera were still based in Norway, had their own browser engine, and were very innovative. A large number of features that became commonplace were in Opera years before any other browser, like tabbed browsing, full-page zoom (browser zoom used to only increase font size while keeping everything else the same size!), restoring your tabs when you re-open the browser, pop-up blocker, a new tab page that shows your commonly accessed sites, private/incognito browsing, sidebars, and more.

      Sure, there’s a bunch of downsides to a server being built into your browser, but it was an interesting idea. People that don’t know anything about servers were able to easily try it out.

      30
      • Oh man, now you ruined my evening, I didn’t know about that, it’s awesome!

        Maybe I wouldn’t have spent so much time building a modern P2P decentralised sharing protocol if I already knew it was tried and killed off…

        Thanks for the history nugget!

        ++

        4
        • @dan@upvote.au· · edited

          Unfortunately regular people don’t understand why they’d use something like this rather than just using Facebook, Instagram, Google Photos, etc. and the major limitation of self-hosting this way is that it’s only accessible when your computer is on, which regular people aren’t used to.

          A lot of people also had pretty limited bandwidth. I was in Australia on ADSL2+ with around 9Mbps down and 700Kbps up.

          I think plug-and-play NAS systems are the closest equivalent today, especially now that a lot of people have faster connections. Comcast boosted upload speeds in some markets last year - in my area their regular plans start at 300Mbps down and 100Mbps up. A lot of NAS systems are still missing the “regular person can easily set it up” aspect though, and I’m not sure if they handle sharing stuff with external users.

          3
          • Just FYI there are distributed systems who will mutualise resources so you can both have a decentralised system and also don’t have your computer on all the time.

            I also think those bandwidths are largely enough for “facebooking” 😋

            1
      • I really hope technologies like Veilid, Tailcat, and I2P take off more, but they require Developer, Developers, Developers!

        3
    • I miss the BBS days.

      1
    • what if instead of doing that, we put all of society’s resources towards inventing a fascist mode of production where the a curated fake-ass prohibitively expensive to update past-slurry is projected onto the future in such a way that expertise is devalued truth is slain the zone is always flooded with shit and everything is garbage that only sometimes looks like it works?

      4
    • I think that’s already a consequence, TCP/IP is very much a protocol suite that works well for client/server architectures, and HTTP (which eventually, somehow, became the de facto “everything” protocol) even more so. So when you mix these roles and you have machines that act as both client and server at the same time all the deficiencies come to light quite easily. A world with first-class support for mutual authentication and authorization, encryption, peering, roaming, etc at the lowest of network levels was possible, but that ship has sailed.

      1
      • You can plug all that jazz on top of IP. No problemo, servers do it all the time.

        That’s absolutely not the problem, the problem is centralized servers only.

        0
    • Its a genuine risk though. People get hacked left right n center with the protective layers we currently have. If that was taken away it would be to risky to do anything serious on a computer.

      -2
      • Complete BS. This is the scaremongering that got us here.

        0
        • No its getting hacked that got us here. The internet is a hostile place.

          0
          • “hAcKeD”

            That’s what happened when people loaded up virus executables, then when some database got breached and their instagram got “hacked”. No one gets hacked if they aren’t a national threat ir something.

            You can dead secure an open port, routers do it all the time, so that point is 100% moot, and if you have a sturdy protocol (think Linux-FOSS built, on some specific user) it’s as good as it can be.

            So even a tech illiterate could use it.

            Fearmongering is what got us here.

            1
            • I think this response is making you seem tech illiterate. I dont think there is any value in continuing this. You can continue exposing everything to the internet and being shocked at why no one else does the same.

              -2
              Continue this thread 3 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in