Comment on Should I actually be prepping right now out of fear of hackers?
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
I’ve had terrible experiences with mental health professionals and would never see any mental health professional again, under any voluntary circumstances, and hate them all.
I also think issues caused by financial insecurity are more likely to be wrongly pathologized by mental health professionals who then want to treat societal dysfunction, financial insecurity, and trauma as something requiring huge amounts of big pharma druggings. Yes, not all clinicians immediately want to drug their financially insecure patients, but I’m not playing that Russian roulette game and going to see some professional, who could literally have me committed if they think I seem off and won’t take their drugs, and just hope they don’t tend to push drugs. And no, searching for a trauma therapist is not a guarantee. I don’t want to be on big pharma drugs, I don’t need a government monitor who reports to the state and locks me up if they have concerns, fuck that.
If you are an upper-middle class housewife with money for lawyers and a strong support network and you have no unusual opinions and you want attention and big pharma drugs, then mental health experts are the perfect place to get more attention. Poor people should avoid mental health professionals at all costs. Big pharma drugs are often metabolically poisonous, lead to brain volume loss compared to people not taking them or taking a placebo, and no one at all has studied the long-term epigenetic effects of these drugs and whether epigenetic impacts are heritable in future generations in negative ways. The mental health industry is a psuedoscientific discipline that only recently stopped treating female hysteria with clitoral stimulation and cutting out the brains of patients and has replaced that with diagnostic criteria based on classical Greek myths and techniques to destroy brain cells with electricity (ECT). The mental health industry is in large part used to monitor and classify people who seem disagreeable or problematic, as well as others, and hell the fuck no, I am not going to some asshole to drug me and do who knows what.
You can see a therapist without seeing a psychiatrist…
Just tell them you’re not interested in medication. You seem very unregulated. I am poor. Negative money. I see a therapist, and it’s been very helpful. You’re making a great deal of leaps in logic based on anecdotes and personal biases and ascribing them to a well tested and researched field of medicine. You’re not just wrong, you’re letting yourself spiral into paranoia instead of getting help.
You’re building up an entire field into this absolute monster when it’s generally so benign. You’re only at risk of institutionalization if you are an imminent risk to your own life or others, and if that is the case, you need the help. Our carceral mental health system is pretty shit, but it’s better than dying. Again, therapists don’t typically prescribe medications. Psychiatrists do. Go see a mental health counselor or a licensed therapist, not a psychiatrist, and you’re in no risk of “big pharma drugs” being pushed on you.
Mental healthcare is not psuedoscience. It’s well tested and proven. Everything you’re jumping to in your third paragraph is just delusion. It’s just talking to someone, dude. Like. Just talking. You talk through your problems with someone that is trained to help you process them. You don’t need to take any medication if you don’t want to, and your therapist typically can’t prescribe those anyways. If you have a chronic deficiency, medication might help, but you can’t be forced to take it.
Fuck you. I hate mental health professionals, I am asking a question about whether I should buy a solar backup that costs a few hundred dollars, you do not know me. Fuck you for saying I am paranoid for considering a fucking backup power device amidst recent groccery store hackings in Europe when there is a war in Europe and the US is currently at war.
Leaps of logic? The mental health field got a Nobel Prize for removing parts of people’s brain and still use that abomination of pseudoscience, the DSM, that has delineations more arbitrary than a roulette wheel. Has the APA as a profession ever apologized to the mental health patient community for lobotomies? The APA started in the 1800s and lobotomies started in the 1930s. There has been no public apology on icepick brain removal referrals because mental health professionals are all shit. Have the heirs of greedy doctors who got rich off of removing brains compensated the families or heirs of patients who were duped?
Narcissistic Personality Disorder is literally based on Greek mythology. How is that not psuedoscience? Please, tell me the rational scientific logic behind their main diagnostic book using Greek myths as a part of the diagnostic descriptive history and nomenclature?
Does Physics have categories of forces based on Hera? Does Math include categories based on a likeness to Zeus? The field is not a real science, the intellectual foundations are based on Freud, a cokehead, making shit up, and yes, there are some experiments that are not psuedoscience but much of the work is based on dollars that promote corporate products. There are metastudies now showing SSRIs barely do better than a placebo. Mental health care is fucking pseudoscience because it mixes real data with bullshit and then when the truth comes out later, there is no apology, just a published article and on to the next snake oil. You are delusional for thinking that somehow getting a crock pot and mixing in pseudoscience, corporate interests, and science gives mental health some sort of intellectual legitimacy.
Therapists can absolutely do wellfare checks to get patients they think are difficult locked up in involuntary care. Do not act like there is this brick wall in between the greedy fraudulent fraternal disciplines. They are two heads of the same snake.
Engaging with this is unproductive, but a few points:
There is no snake, it’s just doctors trying to help people. Just as within any profession, there is a minority of money-grubbing assholes. Just read their reviews! It isn’t that hard.
My pet theory? You’re upset that you were diagnosed with something (potentially the narcissism you bizarrely ranged against), and have decided to blame the entire mental health profession instead of trying to improve yourself. It clearly works, if you just look at the numbers.
Recommend you read The Anatomy of an Epidemic. You are absorbing a lot of bad science and good propaganda.
Oh, my. Not that book. I can see why your views are so biased and skewed. Yes, over prescription exists. No, the entire field is not bogus. That book was widely planned by medical professionals across the board. It’s like you just suggested an antivax book as a rebuttal to primary care. There are valid criticisms and investigations it makes, but the conclusions it draws are sweeping and heavily biased. It picks and chooses evidence to only support the narrative it wants to tell. You just told me I’m absorbing propaganda by citing a known propaganda piece.
If the science is bad, why can’t anyone prove it? The field is based on peer-revieved and and replicable studies. Your position is based on a hit piece.
Me in response to mental health suggestion: “My boundary is I don’t like mental health and wouldn’t want even free services because I’ve had bad experiences.”
Assholes on Lemmy: “Your boundaries mean nothing to me: you need to see mental health professionals and the fact that you don’t want that means you’re objectively paranoid, delusional, and a diagnosed narcissist.”
In physics, things like fundamental forces were experimentally determined. In math, things like primes and number theory were studied because it helped us understand numbers more.
In the mental health field, humans were classified into “what most rich white men find bothersome” and they literally used a Greek myth to classify people. Maybe your grandmother had trauma, maybe she was neurodivergent, or maybe she had unmet emotional and sexual needs and couldn’t articulate and became annoying as a result. Yes, using a Greek myth for the basis of part of a taxonomy on how to classify “disruptive” people is completely unscientific.
I do not think that taking a group of people and going “these people sort of resemble a Greek myth” is helpful or intellectually rigorous. There is no brain science behind the classification. Additionally, the artificial construct between “Personality” disorders versus other mental illness is bizarre logic based on religious superstition; everything takes place in the brain. It’s not like depression takes place in the brain but personality comes from the soul and they are different. Everything “human” is determined by biochemical physical process.
You paid someone a lot of money to talk with you. When someone sees a therapist, you pay them money, and they will in turn classify the people you don’t like as narcissists. After a certain amount of money, they classify YOU as an empath. That’s how the con works.
I’ve never been diagnosed with narcissistic personality disorder and diagnosis is not why I am upset. I genuinely think the mental health field is incredibly exploitative of vulnerable people. The fact that you’re an apologist for removing people’s fucking brains while glossing over the fact that mental health professionals are still unethically misinforming vulnerable people of the risks of ECT proves your lack of insight into the fact that this is still a field that regularly engages in corrupt unethical behavior. I am upset right now because I clearly set a boundary and that boundary was I don’t like the mental health field and am not interested in that and I’ve now received multiple responses on how that means I need mental health.
And yes, I do believe the entire field is a fucking monolith of shit.
If you had said, “I had bad experiences with therapy, and don’t feel it worked for me,” that would be valid reasoning. Instead, you decided that because of your own personal anecdotes and a wild misunderstanding of the history of mental healthcare, the entire field, universally, must be evil. That’s like having a negative experience at the dentist and deciding that all dentists are evil. You place your own personal experiences and anecdotes above everyone else.
Therapy works for many, many people. It’s okay to decide it doesn’t work for you or not go because of bad experiences. It’s not okay to generalize the entire field and minimize the value that so many people have received from it. Your view is very, very skewed and no longer based on reality, but instead your own preconceived biases that confirm or deny evidence when you receive it.
You are misusing the term boundary, and ironically weaponizing therapy-speak to suppress valid critique.
You clearly did not read my comment or know anything about how mental health classification works. Again, it’s not based on the Greek myth. The myth is based on the same real world phenomenon. That’s like saying that lightning isn’t real because of Zeus.
I did not pay someone a lot of money. I paid them almost nothing, because of low-cost assistance programs. They are operating at a loss by helping me, because they’re good people. Therapists shouldn’t classify people that aren’t their patients as anything. If I was a narcissist, they might diagnose me. I don’t pay them to validate me, I go there through financial aid programs so they can help me deal with my struggles as a neurodivergent person.
I’m not an apologist for removing anyone’s brains. That was and is fucked up. Just because it’s fucked up doesn’t mean we didn’t learn anything. As an example, Marie Curie and the radium girls died or faced disfigurement due to radiation, which we didn’t understand at the time, and unethical working conditions around radiation. That doesn’t make the information we learned about radiation pseudoscience, just as the information we learned from split brain research and removing parts of the brain is real science, even though it was evil.
“I set a boundary,” no, you expressed distaste for something and followed it with a wall of misinformation, vibes, and lies. You don’t understand mental healthcare, but you think you do. The irony of misusing therapy-speak while railing against therapy is not lost on me.
Therapy works and you need it, clearly.
Amen, brother.
Not sure things are as universally dark as you think they are, but you are 100% more right than people who tell everyone to “get therapy” for any problem and assume therapy only does harm rarely and only then out of personal malice and not systemic blindness.
I think the biggest lie around therapy is that it is science, and the biggest mistake therapy has made is in subsuming itself under psychiatry within the medical model. Science is the new religion and therapists are merely the new priests, hustling their mumbo jumbo to justify their positions.
Not to say that therapy can never be helpful, but it’s like a case of folk medicine where there’s a few things that work for some conditions, but nobody understands why. In the case of therapy, literally nobody understands why some therapists are better than others. There is literally no book you read or course you can take or model that you can apply that will lead to you being a better therapist. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn’t. Where is the humility?
[And a huge caveat: it sure does look like science, but if you love science and research methods, it’s a rich treasure trove of problems; see especially: replication crisis.]
Anyway, self-therapy, either bibliotherapy (reading), journaling, doing your own exploration is totally cool. If you want to suffer reddit briefly, the sidebar or r/therapyabuse (or was it r/therapycritical) had some amazing non-medical options. One of the biggest harms therapy has done is claiming a monopoly on the human psyche, sometimes to the extent where people don’t even feel qualified to work on themselves.
I appreciate the idea of /r/therapyabuse, but I wouldn’t want to join a subreddit to talk with people about therapy and why my personal experiences were not good. I hate the mental health industry, all of it, and that includes talking about therapy experiences, and if I could snap my fingers and excise the entire phrenological cesspool like a tumor, removing it completely from the planet, I would do so with no hesitation. I also believe that in another 50 years, if the planet is still habitable for human life, a new crop of Charlatans will be saying how completely wrong the mental health industry was today, but will, in turn, have an entire new batch of semi-evidence-based greed-fueled scams available.
I totally get it. I was mentioning r/therapyabuse only because it has a good list of non-“therapy” resources. Talking about how therapy sucks can be helpful, but, yeah, it’s better to focus on living the life you want if you can.
Good luck to you!
Thank you. :-)
Hey, full disclosure I’m a mental health provider so you are wholly in the right to question the position I stand on this but for that it’s worth, I’m in the field because I had very similar feelings to you and fell validated by letting my experiences help others.
There’s a lot in this post that is an accurate read but I do genuinely want to emphasize that the past 15 years has seen a lot of these things become the albatross of this field as it shifts culturally towards doing better. My company for instance is the government approved mental health provider for one of the most populated counties in the state and it’s not even remotely capable of medicating people, let alone giving shock therapy. The best we can do is med management which involves interviewing you once every 3 months and getting refills ordered for you.
More importantly, they provide a lot of services that aren’t Therapy and that’s what I really want to point you towards. Personally, I do parent peer support. My job is to visit other parents of children with behavioral and mental health issues and just encourage them to fo the best. I joke that I’m something between a well meaning neighbor and a state appointed friend.
I really think you would benefit from some genuine peer support. I’m going to be frank, some of what you’re saying is pushing the crazy line and while I’m not one to judge I think your focus could really use an outside perspective and some human contact. I want to emphasize that I’m not calling you crazy, our infrastructure is held together by zip ties and bent clothes hangers, a stiff breeze can probably knock out the power grid where you are, because it literally does every June around here. That said, a bunker full of canned beans and 9mm isn’t going to improve that.
Get yourself a camping stove or a propane grill, learn a few good recipes for rice and beans, but fumpingball your money into solar and generators isn’t going to get you anything but less money. The banks getting hacked would only be possible if the wealthy didn’t need them to control the masses and the tiny cabal of wealthy pedophile psychopaths already run the world. Prepping for an apocalypse isn’t going to give you the security you’re looking for.
For what it’s worth, I take that control back in my life by deciding how I engage with the culture I have grown to resent. I make as much as I can and when I can’t I try to learn how before I go buy it. Turns out nice furniture is a lot cheaper when you build it yourself.
You evil lying manipulative fucker. You know damn well that if YOUR company can’t force medications and shock therapy, you can do a wellness check that will often lead to a situation in which medication is can either be involuntarily administered or involuntary patients who refuse medications can be threatened with prorogued holds. Also, in locked facilities, it is typical to abuse patients who don’t have access to information and say “You can either let us do ECT and you can leave in 2 weeks, or you may need to stay in here a few months.” Doctors in such facilities also regularly lie about the extent of the memory loss caused by ECT, saying it typically comes back and is temporary when many patient reports say it as permanent damage. The fucking arrogance! The lobotomy won the Nobel Prize because of hubris from pseudoscientific avaricious men who made inconvenient people into imbeciles and the attitude still carries on, doesn’t it?
Suck my balls you asshole. There was literally just a hack at Microsoft, there have been hacks of refrigerators cooling stored food in Europe, and I was inquiring as to whether it made sense to spend limited funds on a small portable power device. Rot in hell you smug condescending shithead.
Bruh. You really need some mental care if this is representative of your inner workings. The person above is giving you some great advice, but you think they are some evil demonspawn, lmao.
But sure, go ahead and buy a gas stove and some cans, that is definitely going to fix you right up
Fuck you. I literally said “I’ve had terrible experiences with mental health professionals and would never see any mental health professional again, under any voluntary circumstances, and hate them all.”
How is that not a clear unequivocal boundary? And this mental health asshole responded, when I just said I hate mental health professionals, and says, without having examined me, based on a fucking internet post, that I am “pushing the crazy line” because I don’t like mental health professionals and think they are exploitative. On a fucking post where I am asking about whether I should get a fucking battery backup in case of a multi-day power outage…
So yes, when people violate my clear express boundaries that are unambiguously articulated, I am not happy about it. Fuck you for saying buying cans will fix me sarcastically when I have admitted to being somewhat poor and am trying to take emergency preparation seriously. You’re a shitty mean person. I have every right to be validly angry when I clearly write I don’t like mental health professionals and would never engage with them and then three people respond and say “Well clearly that means you need mental health care.”
Me: I have questions about emergency preparedness and am poor.
Asshole on the Internet: Bro you just need therapy.
Me: I don’t like mental health professionals and think they often drug poor people and don’t really understand how drugs are often used to mask societal dysfunction. I would never again voluntarily see a mental health professional.
Multiple Assholes on the Internet: Fuck your boundary, you must be crazy and delusional and paranoid and need mental health services.
Me: Wow, you’re actual assholes and am upset, I clearly said I don’t want that, I genuinely think the mental health field lacks a solid intellectual foundation and often engages in corruption. Here are some examples.
You: Bruh, this is bad, clearly you need mental health services. Your poor person cans and poor person gas stove and emergency preparation are pointless.
" i hate all people doing this one profession because i had a bad experience" is simply not a valid position for a sane adult to have, period.
throwing slurs around and suggesting the person is evil and whatnot is also not very hinged, on response. I understand you had a bad experience and i am not saying you need to be sent to the looney bin. But your weird blanket hatred of any mental health worker is literally just evidence that you need one, if only to fix what the first one apparently broke.
That being said, i am also a mental health patient, and and while i didnt have the best experiences myself it did get me back on solid ground.
What youre saying is the equivalent of getting mugged by foreigners and then blanket hating anyone with a tan.
Your position is childish and insane. If you didn’t want people to comment on your position. Maybe you should have just kept it to yourself.
Sign in to comment. Sign in