Skip to content

Comment on Should I actually be prepping right now out of fear of hackers?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • @someone@lemmy.todayOP· · edited

    Fuck you. I hate mental health professionals, I am asking a question about whether I should buy a solar backup that costs a few hundred dollars, you do not know me. Fuck you for saying I am paranoid for considering a fucking backup power device amidst recent groccery store hackings in Europe when there is a war in Europe and the US is currently at war.

    Leaps of logic? The mental health field got a Nobel Prize for removing parts of people’s brain and still use that abomination of pseudoscience, the DSM, that has delineations more arbitrary than a roulette wheel. Has the APA as a profession ever apologized to the mental health patient community for lobotomies? The APA started in the 1800s and lobotomies started in the 1930s. There has been no public apology on icepick brain removal referrals because mental health professionals are all shit. Have the heirs of greedy doctors who got rich off of removing brains compensated the families or heirs of patients who were duped?

    Narcissistic Personality Disorder is literally based on Greek mythology. How is that not psuedoscience? Please, tell me the rational scientific logic behind their main diagnostic book using Greek myths as a part of the diagnostic descriptive history and nomenclature?

    Does Physics have categories of forces based on Hera? Does Math include categories based on a likeness to Zeus? The field is not a real science, the intellectual foundations are based on Freud, a cokehead, making shit up, and yes, there are some experiments that are not psuedoscience but much of the work is based on dollars that promote corporate products. There are metastudies now showing SSRIs barely do better than a placebo. Mental health care is fucking pseudoscience because it mixes real data with bullshit and then when the truth comes out later, there is no apology, just a published article and on to the next snake oil. You are delusional for thinking that somehow getting a crock pot and mixing in pseudoscience, corporate interests, and science gives mental health some sort of intellectual legitimacy.

    Therapists can absolutely do wellfare checks to get patients they think are difficult locked up in involuntary care. Do not act like there is this brick wall in between the greedy fraudulent fraternal disciplines. They are two heads of the same snake.

    0
    • Engaging with this is unproductive, but a few points:

      • You are being paranoid, objectively. That paranoia may be justified (or in this case, not really), but it does exist, otherwise this post wouldn’t
      • And we used to think the Earth is a few thousand years old, and we used to think certain races are superior, and we used to think the cosmos orbited the Earth, among other things. Science learns over time. The specific case you’ve brought up, split brain research, though highly unethical by today’s standards, taught us so much about the human brain, as well as the removal of the hippocampus in patient H.B. You’re right, these were unethical, but the results aren’t pseudoscience. Again, science develops, and it’s why lobotomies and removing the entire corpus callosum or hippocampus are illegal today
      • You treat the fields of mental health medicine as a universal monolith, not a bunch of independent doctors
      • Narcissism is named after Narcissus. It is not based on the myth. It’s a well established and proven condition (my own grandmother has it). They aren’t diagnosing based on Greek myths, they’re diagnosing based on patterns of behavior. Why are you so worked up about narcissism? Narcissists clearly exist, and they need help. Anyone that has known a narcissist will tell you that. You could have picked an actually dubious diagnosis, not one that many, many people struggle with.
      • Modern mental health treatments since the cognitive revolution and then later humanism/positive psychology have been evidence based and improved over time. If something is shown to not work or not be based on evidence, it’s discarded, just like every other field of science.
      • Your last point, while technically true, is so vanishingly unlikely as to be worthless to bring up. No, they can’t, that’s malpractice, and is grounds for a rather lucrative lawsuit. If someone is locked up, it is because they demonstrated a serious risk to themselves or others. I have told my therapist I was feeling suicidal more than once without being committed. My close friend was committed, and it was because she had formulated a plan and prepared the materials to kill herself.

      There is no snake, it’s just doctors trying to help people. Just as within any profession, there is a minority of money-grubbing assholes. Just read their reviews! It isn’t that hard.

      My pet theory? You’re upset that you were diagnosed with something (potentially the narcissism you bizarrely ranged against), and have decided to blame the entire mental health profession instead of trying to improve yourself. It clearly works, if you just look at the numbers.

      0
      • Recommend you read The Anatomy of an Epidemic. You are absorbing a lot of bad science and good propaganda.

        1
        • Oh, my. Not that book. I can see why your views are so biased and skewed. Yes, over prescription exists. No, the entire field is not bogus. That book was widely planned by medical professionals across the board. It’s like you just suggested an antivax book as a rebuttal to primary care. There are valid criticisms and investigations it makes, but the conclusions it draws are sweeping and heavily biased. It picks and chooses evidence to only support the narrative it wants to tell. You just told me I’m absorbing propaganda by citing a known propaganda piece.

          If the science is bad, why can’t anyone prove it? The field is based on peer-revieved and and replicable studies. Your position is based on a hit piece.

          -1
          • I share your love of science and research. And part of science is, you know, looking at the research instead of hearing “trust me bro.” Unlike, say quantum physics, the science is pretty accessible.

            Anatomy of an Epidemic is based on actual research by actual scientists and some of the conclusions he draws in the book are the same conclusions drawn by researchers in other parts of the world. One example given in the book (or perhaps a lecture) is that schizophreni had a much higher natural recovery rate before medicine–and this was based on data from hospitals. People would have their psychotic breaks and then they would go to the hospital for a few months or years and then they would return to normal working life without problems or treatments.

            Today, being schizophrenic is a permanently disabling condition, and the author proposes, quite reasonably, that psychiatric meds are actually creating a depedency and a permanent disability. Psychiatrists in other parts of the world are now experimenting with looking at anti-psychotics for short term use.

            I appreciate the time-saving instinct of dismissing anything that can be framed as “anti-science.” But one thing I learned in my study of Chinese Medicine is that cultures can generate huge amounts of information and theory to make weak ideas look quite impressive actually, and that is the space that psychiatry and therapy both occupy.

            Edit: Anyway, if you just want to look at therapy and not psychiatry, the best book looking at the research, from a therapists perspective, is The Heart and Soul of Change. Also see: Dodo Bird Theory and Replication Crisis.

            1
            • Again, citing evidence is worth nothing if you only value the evidence that supports your point, not the larger body that contradicts it. Whitaker is a hack. He looks at the differences in outcomes on schizophrenia and decides it’s the meds that are at fault, not the much more likely and well-supported science that says it’s probably individualist vs collectivist cultures. His proposal is based entirely on correlation and the narrative he wants to sell, and isn’t backed by science. Studies do not support his claims.

              I am not simply dismissing something I disagree with as anti-science. I’m dismissing a journalistic hit piece with dubious and cherry picked evidence as anti-science because it is. Correlation does not prove causation, especially when we already have very good explanations!

              This conversation is going nowhere. A few parting points:

              • Therapy works for millions. The techniques and methodology are well-researched, supported by studies, and replicable
              • An industry having an unethical past does not mean the present is the same, otherwise literally every industry would be evil.
              • There are valid critiques of therapy, and it doesn’t work for everybody. However, even the sources you cite all agree that mental healthcare does work and is valuable, they just disagree with mainstream views.
              • You are very dismissive of the vast body of evidence that contradicts your view and also the experiences of those that have found value, lifesaving value even, in mental healthcare. The refusal to recognize that your view is not universal and cherry picking of evidence only when it already agrees with you is conspiracy behavior. I will not continue to argue with a conspiracy theorist
              • You could just as easily argue that therapy didn’t work for you and you had bad experiences with some mental health professionals without ascribing that to the industry as a whole. Clearly, therapy and psychiatry do work for many people, rich or poor, from various cultures. That is an undeniable fact.
              • You can disagree with the actions of beliefs of some, or even a majority of the industry without treating it as some magical unified front where everyone agrees. There are vastly different approaches and views on mental healthcare, and they disagree vehemently. You are in opposition to a field of medicine that has saved many, many lives, mine included.

              It is okay to not want therapy personally, it is not okay to decry any participation in industry that has saved many lives and is full of people who generally just want to make the world a better place.

              -1
      • @someone@lemmy.todayOP· · edited

        Me in response to mental health suggestion: “My boundary is I don’t like mental health and wouldn’t want even free services because I’ve had bad experiences.”

        Assholes on Lemmy: “Your boundaries mean nothing to me: you need to see mental health professionals and the fact that you don’t want that means you’re objectively paranoid, delusional, and a diagnosed narcissist.”

        In physics, things like fundamental forces were experimentally determined. In math, things like primes and number theory were studied because it helped us understand numbers more.

        In the mental health field, humans were classified into “what most rich white men find bothersome” and they literally used a Greek myth to classify people. Maybe your grandmother had trauma, maybe she was neurodivergent, or maybe she had unmet emotional and sexual needs and couldn’t articulate and became annoying as a result. Yes, using a Greek myth for the basis of part of a taxonomy on how to classify “disruptive” people is completely unscientific.

        I do not think that taking a group of people and going “these people sort of resemble a Greek myth” is helpful or intellectually rigorous. There is no brain science behind the classification. Additionally, the artificial construct between “Personality” disorders versus other mental illness is bizarre logic based on religious superstition; everything takes place in the brain. It’s not like depression takes place in the brain but personality comes from the soul and they are different. Everything “human” is determined by biochemical physical process.

        You paid someone a lot of money to talk with you. When someone sees a therapist, you pay them money, and they will in turn classify the people you don’t like as narcissists. After a certain amount of money, they classify YOU as an empath. That’s how the con works.

        I’ve never been diagnosed with narcissistic personality disorder and diagnosis is not why I am upset. I genuinely think the mental health field is incredibly exploitative of vulnerable people. The fact that you’re an apologist for removing people’s fucking brains while glossing over the fact that mental health professionals are still unethically misinforming vulnerable people of the risks of ECT proves your lack of insight into the fact that this is still a field that regularly engages in corrupt unethical behavior. I am upset right now because I clearly set a boundary and that boundary was I don’t like the mental health field and am not interested in that and I’ve now received multiple responses on how that means I need mental health.

        And yes, I do believe the entire field is a fucking monolith of shit.

        -1
        • If you had said, “I had bad experiences with therapy, and don’t feel it worked for me,” that would be valid reasoning. Instead, you decided that because of your own personal anecdotes and a wild misunderstanding of the history of mental healthcare, the entire field, universally, must be evil. That’s like having a negative experience at the dentist and deciding that all dentists are evil. You place your own personal experiences and anecdotes above everyone else.

          Therapy works for many, many people. It’s okay to decide it doesn’t work for you or not go because of bad experiences. It’s not okay to generalize the entire field and minimize the value that so many people have received from it. Your view is very, very skewed and no longer based on reality, but instead your own preconceived biases that confirm or deny evidence when you receive it.

          -1
        • You are misusing the term boundary, and ironically weaponizing therapy-speak to suppress valid critique.

          You clearly did not read my comment or know anything about how mental health classification works. Again, it’s not based on the Greek myth. The myth is based on the same real world phenomenon. That’s like saying that lightning isn’t real because of Zeus.

          I did not pay someone a lot of money. I paid them almost nothing, because of low-cost assistance programs. They are operating at a loss by helping me, because they’re good people. Therapists shouldn’t classify people that aren’t their patients as anything. If I was a narcissist, they might diagnose me. I don’t pay them to validate me, I go there through financial aid programs so they can help me deal with my struggles as a neurodivergent person.

          I’m not an apologist for removing anyone’s brains. That was and is fucked up. Just because it’s fucked up doesn’t mean we didn’t learn anything. As an example, Marie Curie and the radium girls died or faced disfigurement due to radiation, which we didn’t understand at the time, and unethical working conditions around radiation. That doesn’t make the information we learned about radiation pseudoscience, just as the information we learned from split brain research and removing parts of the brain is real science, even though it was evil.

          “I set a boundary,” no, you expressed distaste for something and followed it with a wall of misinformation, vibes, and lies. You don’t understand mental healthcare, but you think you do. The irony of misusing therapy-speak while railing against therapy is not lost on me.

          Therapy works and you need it, clearly.

          -1
          • @someone@lemmy.todayOP· · edited

            weaponizing therapy-speak? what the fuck are you talking about and what does that even mean?

            I neither want nor know that lexicon, and if you want a monopoly on certain phrases, you can fucking have them because i wouldn’t intentionally touch that trash discipline with a 1000000 foot pole.

            If you wish to write out an enumerated list of words that I can’t use lest they be “weapons” somehow (whatever the fuck that even means), please do so. I have genuinely no desire to be part of your therapy world, and I’m fine with your monopoly if you actually tell me the forbidden phrases.

            And you paid those therapists, maybe not with your money, but there was taxpayer money or funding that somehow went to those people. They weren’t working for free. I don’t have to see the balance book to know that.

            You’re genuinely impossible.

            I absolutely want nothing to do with the mental health industry. Why is that so fucking hard for you to understand?

            0
            • You are misusing the term boundary. A boundary is a term with a specific definition, and it’s entered the common cultural lexicon as a misused “I don’t like this thing.” A boundary would be, “Please don’t talk to me about therapy. If you continue to talk about therapy, this conversation is over.” A boundary includes a demand and consequences if not met. You did not set a boundary, you ranted misinformation about an industry, then played the victim when your lies were engaged with. If you want to set that boundary, then yes, the conversation would be over.

              Weaponizing therapy-speak means taking terms that entered the cultural lexicon through therapy, like “setting a boundary,” and misusing them to suppress valid criticism. You did not set a boundary, you decided that you wanted to rant your misinformation without challenge, and disliked being challenged.

              You either aren’t reading or aren’t comprehending my messages. For the last time, it is okay to want nothing to do with therapy. That is your prerogative. It is not okay to lie and spew unsupported misinformation about lifesaving healthcare. I am engaging with you the same way I would engage with an antivaxxer. Your positions are untenable and not supported by evidence.

              For one more time, because you still aren’t getting it:

              You are allowed to dislike therapy and want nothing to do with mental healthcare. I’m not stopping you.

              Spreading lies about lifesaving medical care is not okay, and you were rightfully called out for it.

              The last thing I want is for a vulnerable person that needs the help to be discouraged away from receiving it due to seeing these types of lies, and have terrible consequences for it. Therapy is proven to decrease the rates of suicide and symptoms of depression, anxiety, and other mental struggles. It might not be right for you, but you should not be pushing others away, especially with straight up misinformation.

              0
              Continue this thread 2 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in