Comment on Should I actually be prepping right now out of fear of hackers?
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
I share your love of science and research. And part of science is, you know, looking at the research instead of hearing “trust me bro.” Unlike, say quantum physics, the science is pretty accessible.
Anatomy of an Epidemic is based on actual research by actual scientists and some of the conclusions he draws in the book are the same conclusions drawn by researchers in other parts of the world. One example given in the book (or perhaps a lecture) is that schizophreni had a much higher natural recovery rate before medicine–and this was based on data from hospitals. People would have their psychotic breaks and then they would go to the hospital for a few months or years and then they would return to normal working life without problems or treatments.
Today, being schizophrenic is a permanently disabling condition, and the author proposes, quite reasonably, that psychiatric meds are actually creating a depedency and a permanent disability. Psychiatrists in other parts of the world are now experimenting with looking at anti-psychotics for short term use.
I appreciate the time-saving instinct of dismissing anything that can be framed as “anti-science.” But one thing I learned in my study of Chinese Medicine is that cultures can generate huge amounts of information and theory to make weak ideas look quite impressive actually, and that is the space that psychiatry and therapy both occupy.
Edit: Anyway, if you just want to look at therapy and not psychiatry, the best book looking at the research, from a therapists perspective, is The Heart and Soul of Change. Also see: Dodo Bird Theory and Replication Crisis.
Again, citing evidence is worth nothing if you only value the evidence that supports your point, not the larger body that contradicts it. Whitaker is a hack. He looks at the differences in outcomes on schizophrenia and decides it’s the meds that are at fault, not the much more likely and well-supported science that says it’s probably individualist vs collectivist cultures. His proposal is based entirely on correlation and the narrative he wants to sell, and isn’t backed by science. Studies do not support his claims.
I am not simply dismissing something I disagree with as anti-science. I’m dismissing a journalistic hit piece with dubious and cherry picked evidence as anti-science because it is. Correlation does not prove causation, especially when we already have very good explanations!
This conversation is going nowhere. A few parting points:
It is okay to not want therapy personally, it is not okay to decry any participation in industry that has saved many lives and is full of people who generally just want to make the world a better place.
Do you have a good point-by-point, research-based refutation of Anatomy of an Epidemic?
Anyway, I’m not saying therapy isn’t helpful. I’m saying it’s not science. Look into the Dodo-bird theory on wikipedia if you want an inkling of what i’m talking about. If there was one form of therapy that worked well, we would know about it. So far, the evidence is incredibly weak, outside of CBT for anxiety.
Sign in to comment. Sign in