If I recall correctly, he’s talking about just advanced life. Habitable planets is its own category, and honestly tends to be squeezed into assumed parameters for what we know is possible, aka Earth. We’ve had those lines pushed before, when we found life in ocean trenches that we didn’t think would be “habitable”.
But his theory on the (small) window of time for life to evolve to advanced forms and intelligence for most stars was mind blowing to me. The only counter that works against it for all places is the number of chances it has to happen in different varieties in just this galaxy, not to mention the millions of others out there. We may never contact anyone else, but to think that with an average star’s life and a number of steps back we still got to where we are and yet it never happened anywhere else is very egocentric, almost as much as the old models where everything goes around the Earth.
Did it happen in this section of the galaxy? He may be right enough that no, it’s only a few in this galaxy, somewhere. And there’s the problem of distance again. So we might as well be along, without some new discovery to get past the speed of light.
Agreed. Professor Kipper talks about cosmic ooze being probable but the probability of advanced life keeps falling with every new model or discovery, is his point lately.
Right. The argument against abiogenesis (outside of the religious take) has always been how it’s too complex or the odds are against it, but there’s a good breakdown on the very old TalkOrigins archive taken from Usenet that shows from an odds pov, there’s not an astronomical amount of chemical combinations to make simple chemical replicators such a rare thing, indeed it’s a small number, and it’s more just having the conditions right long enough and enough tries. Well, we had that with early Earth. Once it cooled down enough, we had most of the planet’s surface running experiments over millions of years. Several different combinations were probably found and took off, and competition ended up with the few that were left. It’s certainly happened elsewhere too, there is nothing special about Earth outside of the parameters needed (which we’re not sure on which are absolutely needed).
I think recent research might even suggest that not only is it possible for life to begin with the right conditions, but that it’s almost a given something starts brewing the minute things get “right”.
Ooze may be everywhere, but leaps like towards multicellular complexity, seem to require an abundantly rare set of cosmic conditions that Earth seemed to give us by sheer, abundant luck. Plate tectonics lasting this long, a peculiarly stable G-type star, just enough meteorite impacts but not too much, stable temperatures that lasted billions of years. It took like 1.4 billion years to develop into complex forms. And from what we can see about the galaxy and universe, these conditions seem hard to find. We have a painful statistical case of one despite millions of planets now well within our gaze and measurement.
Like before, borrowing heavily from Cool Worlds Labs (Colombia University) calculations and peer reviewed models for my above reflections.
Yes, I think there’s merit to the Rare Earth Hypothesis, where a lot of things we have may be needed to some degree to make many things possible. But, one of Kippings lead in points about limitations and the time to do it brought up the many times life has been brought close to being wiped out. Still stable conditions compared to many hostile places, but life just bounces back eventually. It “finds a way” and is very persistence, through impacts, volcanic upheavals, poisoned atmosphere, and snowball planets.
The jury is out on exoplanets still (the jury is still out for other planets here!). We’re starting to find ways to measure their details, but not enough to say whether or not life as we know it might have started there, or byproducts in their atmosphere that suggest biological activity. We just know there’s a LOT of them in just the small sections we’ve looked. And the “life as we know it” carries a lot of weight, as some of the exotherms we have on Earth we never imagined existing, and they still were evolved in familiar environments.
G stars are pretty stable overall, but they also aren’t the only ones. F through M can have conditions that may work, and getting back to Kipping’s point on the time window, K stars have a constant luminosity and are more long-lived than G, so that opens op more and/or longer chances to evolve something.
Didnt Kipping have a piece come out that suggested only really G stars may have the conditions and G stars are rarer and have a tighter window of time for formation? I forget exactly but he seemed to dismiss the conditions of other star types. Still, amazing points and exchange. Kipping and his team has not ruled out life, but they are increasingly grappling with the possibility of rare earth hypothesis the more their models and observations come in which is interesting.
Comments
If I recall correctly, he’s talking about just advanced life. Habitable planets is its own category, and honestly tends to be squeezed into assumed parameters for what we know is possible, aka Earth. We’ve had those lines pushed before, when we found life in ocean trenches that we didn’t think would be “habitable”.
But his theory on the (small) window of time for life to evolve to advanced forms and intelligence for most stars was mind blowing to me. The only counter that works against it for all places is the number of chances it has to happen in different varieties in just this galaxy, not to mention the millions of others out there. We may never contact anyone else, but to think that with an average star’s life and a number of steps back we still got to where we are and yet it never happened anywhere else is very egocentric, almost as much as the old models where everything goes around the Earth.
Did it happen in this section of the galaxy? He may be right enough that no, it’s only a few in this galaxy, somewhere. And there’s the problem of distance again. So we might as well be along, without some new discovery to get past the speed of light.
Agreed. Professor Kipper talks about cosmic ooze being probable but the probability of advanced life keeps falling with every new model or discovery, is his point lately.
Right. The argument against abiogenesis (outside of the religious take) has always been how it’s too complex or the odds are against it, but there’s a good breakdown on the very old TalkOrigins archive taken from Usenet that shows from an odds pov, there’s not an astronomical amount of chemical combinations to make simple chemical replicators such a rare thing, indeed it’s a small number, and it’s more just having the conditions right long enough and enough tries. Well, we had that with early Earth. Once it cooled down enough, we had most of the planet’s surface running experiments over millions of years. Several different combinations were probably found and took off, and competition ended up with the few that were left. It’s certainly happened elsewhere too, there is nothing special about Earth outside of the parameters needed (which we’re not sure on which are absolutely needed).
I think recent research might even suggest that not only is it possible for life to begin with the right conditions, but that it’s almost a given something starts brewing the minute things get “right”.
Ooze may be everywhere, but leaps like towards multicellular complexity, seem to require an abundantly rare set of cosmic conditions that Earth seemed to give us by sheer, abundant luck. Plate tectonics lasting this long, a peculiarly stable G-type star, just enough meteorite impacts but not too much, stable temperatures that lasted billions of years. It took like 1.4 billion years to develop into complex forms. And from what we can see about the galaxy and universe, these conditions seem hard to find. We have a painful statistical case of one despite millions of planets now well within our gaze and measurement.
Like before, borrowing heavily from Cool Worlds Labs (Colombia University) calculations and peer reviewed models for my above reflections.
Yes, I think there’s merit to the Rare Earth Hypothesis, where a lot of things we have may be needed to some degree to make many things possible. But, one of Kippings lead in points about limitations and the time to do it brought up the many times life has been brought close to being wiped out. Still stable conditions compared to many hostile places, but life just bounces back eventually. It “finds a way” and is very persistence, through impacts, volcanic upheavals, poisoned atmosphere, and snowball planets.
The jury is out on exoplanets still (the jury is still out for other planets here!). We’re starting to find ways to measure their details, but not enough to say whether or not life as we know it might have started there, or byproducts in their atmosphere that suggest biological activity. We just know there’s a LOT of them in just the small sections we’ve looked. And the “life as we know it” carries a lot of weight, as some of the exotherms we have on Earth we never imagined existing, and they still were evolved in familiar environments.
G stars are pretty stable overall, but they also aren’t the only ones. F through M can have conditions that may work, and getting back to Kipping’s point on the time window, K stars have a constant luminosity and are more long-lived than G, so that opens op more and/or longer chances to evolve something.
Still a lot to figure out.
Didnt Kipping have a piece come out that suggested only really G stars may have the conditions and G stars are rarer and have a tighter window of time for formation? I forget exactly but he seemed to dismiss the conditions of other star types. Still, amazing points and exchange. Kipping and his team has not ruled out life, but they are increasingly grappling with the possibility of rare earth hypothesis the more their models and observations come in which is interesting.
Sign in to comment. Sign in