Isn’t generalizing the entirety of Buddhism based on the actions of one or two extremist factions, kind of exactly the same thing as generalizing the entirety of Islam based on the actions of one or two extremist factions?
Looking forward to seeing the mental gymnastics that it will take to claim those two things are in any way different
OP’s post is a reaction to people who react to people who say “all religions are bad” by saying “nuh uh, Buddhists never did anything wrong”. Your experience or lack thereof with such people will dictate whether this feels like a strawman or not.
It is most definitely not a “Buddhism is bad because some Buddhists are bad” argument.
I guess the flaw is already in the wording: (from the post) “Buddhism never did anything problematic”, Buddhism cannot do anything, people can (in the name of Buddhism)
Yeah, it seems any doctrine can be malappropriated by people who never tried to understand it and twisted toward some diabolical purpose. That doesn’t mean the doctrine at its core is flawed.
I’m against religious extremism as much as anyone else. But I’m also against generalizing entire cultures based on the actions of extremist factions. There’s no way to convince me that could be based in anything other than ignorance.
True Believer fundamentalists depend on the moderates to exist.
I’m not an expert on Buddhism, but I know with Abrahamics the moderates finance and enable the fundies (often without knowing), and provide them with a veneer of respectability.
Fundies are by nature parasitic. You can see this with sects of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, all depend on more “practical” donors for financing and support why they do more esoteric things.
If you’re trying to fit eastern religions into a western-religion-shaped shoebox, you’re going to have a very hard time defending your thesis to anyone who’s even modestly informed on the topic.
Comments
Isn’t generalizing the entirety of Buddhism based on the actions of one or two extremist factions, kind of exactly the same thing as generalizing the entirety of Islam based on the actions of one or two extremist factions?
Looking forward to seeing the mental gymnastics that it will take to claim those two things are in any way different
They aren’t? That’s why we don’t say all Muslims are the same as the Taliban or all Christians the same as MAGA.
OP’s post is a reaction to people who react to people who say “all religions are bad” by saying “nuh uh, Buddhists never did anything wrong”. Your experience or lack thereof with such people will dictate whether this feels like a strawman or not.
It is most definitely not a “Buddhism is bad because some Buddhists are bad” argument.
I guess the flaw is already in the wording: (from the post) “Buddhism never did anything problematic”, Buddhism cannot do anything, people can (in the name of Buddhism)
Yeah, it seems any doctrine can be malappropriated by people who never tried to understand it and twisted toward some diabolical purpose. That doesn’t mean the doctrine at its core is flawed.
I’m against religious extremism as much as anyone else. But I’m also against generalizing entire cultures based on the actions of extremist factions. There’s no way to convince me that could be based in anything other than ignorance.
"https://feddit.uk/pictrs/image/14544eca-96c2-4a50-99a7-748837259904.webp
Not really.
True Believer fundamentalists depend on the moderates to exist.
I’m not an expert on Buddhism, but I know with Abrahamics the moderates finance and enable the fundies (often without knowing), and provide them with a veneer of respectability.
Fundies are by nature parasitic. You can see this with sects of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, all depend on more “practical” donors for financing and support why they do more esoteric things.
If you’re trying to fit eastern religions into a western-religion-shaped shoebox, you’re going to have a very hard time defending your thesis to anyone who’s even modestly informed on the topic.
Sign in to comment. Sign in