So a person has been brutally murdered in a bloody horrible way.
Ask that person if they give a crap if the person who killed them did it because their invisible sky daddy told them to, or because they were just pissed off because someone cut them off in traffic, or because they were off their meds.
I’m pretty sure the person who died in bloody, horrible agony isn’t going to give a shit.
You only think religious is murder is bad because you hate religion. Which means it’s more about you than it is about the murder. And I think that says more about you than the person doing the killing.
I’m not religious. Not even in the slightest. Couldn’t pick a church out of a line-up.
I just loathe people who want to blame religion for everything and don’t see the irony of saying “I think people who push their beliefs on others are shitty human beings SO I AM GOING TO FORCE MY BELIEFS ON YOU” and don’t realise how exactly like the people they purport to hate they are.
I am very tired of people equivocating all “beliefs”. Plus you won’t hear this “pushing beliefs” criticism of religion from me. I don’t think it’s a good criticism of religion in the first place. I actually would strongly advocate for “pushing” (i.e. making known, advocating for, and justifying through reason) ideas that one believes are correct, important, and just. It’s pretty essential to democracy that we do this, and it’s the only way we’ll ever change anything. “Live and let live” cannot be taken to infinity.
I entirely agree - standing up for your beliefs is always a good thing.
But I think there’s a difference between standing up for your belief that everyone should be treated equally if they are black, or gay, or trans, or a woman, and standing up for your belief that you can tell someone their invisible friend in the sky doesn’t exist and you can tell them they are a stupid prick for believing that.
In addition we get told that controlling what people think is wrong (we get told this a lot) but when it comes to telling people their faith is wrong a large amount of people on the left have no issue with doing that? They have no problem with saying “your god doesn’t exist and you’re a moron for thinking he does”?
I’m not condoning people who use their faith to persecute, or who advocate violence or being crappy to other people, but the atheists who go out of their way to crap on people of faith just because they are people of faith are really are no better
I truly think this should not need to be so explicitly said, but if I’m brutally murdered in a bloody horrible way, I do want people to find out why it happened so that future murders can be prevented. I think this should be done regardless of the nature of the murderous motivations. It does matter to me that society is improved, actually, even once I’m gone.
I think we should improve society. And that we should (try to) prevent future murders, in so far as it is possible (though - let’s be honest - history doesn’t set much of a precedent for that!).
But I think improving society by telling people that something that gives them comfort in dark times is stupid, dumb and idiotic and shitty is not the best way to make society better. I think that - perhaps - fostering understand between people and not crapping on their beliefs, and just letting people live the lives they want to live might, just perhaps, be a better way.
I think improving society by telling people that something that gives them comfort in dark times is stupid, dumb and idiotic and shitty is not the best way to make society better.
Lol, good thing this isn’t the only argument against religion, then.
Comments
So a person has been brutally murdered in a bloody horrible way.
Ask that person if they give a crap if the person who killed them did it because their invisible sky daddy told them to, or because they were just pissed off because someone cut them off in traffic, or because they were off their meds.
I’m pretty sure the person who died in bloody, horrible agony isn’t going to give a shit.
You only think religious is murder is bad because you hate religion. Which means it’s more about you than it is about the murder. And I think that says more about you than the person doing the killing.
ok buddy
That’s gotta be the funniest shit I’ve seen a reactionary say in a while
Yeah its a pretty clear indicator that this conversation is no longer worth having.
Do you want to know the funniest part?
I’m not religious. Not even in the slightest. Couldn’t pick a church out of a line-up.
I just loathe people who want to blame religion for everything and don’t see the irony of saying “I think people who push their beliefs on others are shitty human beings SO I AM GOING TO FORCE MY BELIEFS ON YOU” and don’t realise how exactly like the people they purport to hate they are.
I am very tired of people equivocating all “beliefs”. Plus you won’t hear this “pushing beliefs” criticism of religion from me. I don’t think it’s a good criticism of religion in the first place. I actually would strongly advocate for “pushing” (i.e. making known, advocating for, and justifying through reason) ideas that one believes are correct, important, and just. It’s pretty essential to democracy that we do this, and it’s the only way we’ll ever change anything. “Live and let live” cannot be taken to infinity.
I entirely agree - standing up for your beliefs is always a good thing.
But I think there’s a difference between standing up for your belief that everyone should be treated equally if they are black, or gay, or trans, or a woman, and standing up for your belief that you can tell someone their invisible friend in the sky doesn’t exist and you can tell them they are a stupid prick for believing that.
In addition we get told that controlling what people think is wrong (we get told this a lot) but when it comes to telling people their faith is wrong a large amount of people on the left have no issue with doing that? They have no problem with saying “your god doesn’t exist and you’re a moron for thinking he does”?
I’m not condoning people who use their faith to persecute, or who advocate violence or being crappy to other people, but the atheists who go out of their way to crap on people of faith just because they are people of faith are really are no better
I truly think this should not need to be so explicitly said, but if I’m brutally murdered in a bloody horrible way, I do want people to find out why it happened so that future murders can be prevented. I think this should be done regardless of the nature of the murderous motivations. It does matter to me that society is improved, actually, even once I’m gone.
I think we should improve society. And that we should (try to) prevent future murders, in so far as it is possible (though - let’s be honest - history doesn’t set much of a precedent for that!).
But I think improving society by telling people that something that gives them comfort in dark times is stupid, dumb and idiotic and shitty is not the best way to make society better. I think that - perhaps - fostering understand between people and not crapping on their beliefs, and just letting people live the lives they want to live might, just perhaps, be a better way.
Lol, good thing this isn’t the only argument against religion, then.
Every argument against religion is the same as every argument against being gay.
It ends up as Person A arguing against Person B’s personal choice. Which makes Person A a shitty human being.
neither belief nor sexual orientation is a choice
Removing a comfortable lie is a crucial step to improving society. Once you realize that this life is it you’re far more motivated to improve things.
Absolutely. Marx called it the opiate of the people for a reason.
Sign in to comment. Sign in