It falsely portrays Palestinian resistance and probably the conflicts between Israel and Iran, Israel and Lebanon, and Israel and Yemen as “religious violence”, falsely characterizes increased anti-zionism as “a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews” when these reported increases have come from sources that include pro-Palestine and anti-genocide protests as hate crimes. I don’t know as much about the other things, but I certainly can’t just take their word for it when they’ve shown themselves to be so dishonest and compromised on the Palestine colonial conflict.
And for what it’s worth, their main source for the claim about increased religious conflict is also Pew Research (lol), an American capitalist think tank. And they didn’t even link to the correct article that they seemingly meant to cite.
It literally says “In the United States and Europe”… “and Muslims” - "In the United States and Europe, a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews and Muslims… " - why would you truncate something, take it out of context, to fit only the narrative that you’re interested in??
Anyway, their point is that not having state-religion separation will lead to religious violence. For example, a Jewish state is a problem.
It literally says “According to the Pew Research Center, about one-quarter of countries worldwide exhibit “high” or “very high” levels of social hostilities involving religion, including violent religion-related attacks. We’re seeing this play out globally. A new wave of religious violence across the Middle East commenced with the devastating attack by Hamas against Israel on October 7, 2023. Sectarian conflicts continue to simmer in countries as diverse as India, Indonesia, Nigeria, and Vietnam. In the United States and Europe, a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews and Muslims shows that religious violence is by no means limited to the developing world. As of 2025, possible genocides against communities of faith are unfolding in China and in Myanmar. In many ways, religious violence is surging alongside a broader global resurgence of religion itself.” - why would you truncate something, take it out of context, to fit only the narrative that you’re interested in??
Those parts aren’t relevant to the issue, which was answering your question about the elements of the first paragraph of the article that would tarnish the credibility of the authors and publishers. I didn’t say that every single statement in the paragraph is problematic. I had particular criticisms of particular points. I did not take anything out of any relevant context. It is normal to quote only the relevant part for the sake of clarity and sentence structure. My point stands about the supposed “rising tide of hate crimes against Jews” (in the place where it’s purported to be happening, the United States and Europe, as opposed to some other place where it’s not, if it’s so important to you that I specify this). The increase in hate crimes against Muslims in the West, on the other hand, is much more strongly evidenced.
Anyway, their point is that not having state-religion separation will lead to religious violence. For example, a Jewish state is a problem.
I don’t disagree. The rest of the article is a decent analysis of the harms of state religion, using examples that I guess they aren’t averse to acknowledging. My original statement was (emphasis added):
Wow, that first paragraph really tarnishes the credibility of the MIT Press, its editor, and the authors Nilay Saiya and Stuti Manchanda.
But your example of a Jewish state is yours, and not theirs. Their intentional erasure of the ethnoreligious supremacist nature of the state of Israel and its crimes is especially incredible given it’s followed by an entire article about the harms of state religion.
They were just citing rising religious violence studied in some parts of the world. Everyone mentioning that doesn’t have to explain or condemn the genocidal war. You’re being very west-centric.
Comments
I do hope this is already very apparent, but:
It falsely portrays Palestinian resistance and probably the conflicts between Israel and Iran, Israel and Lebanon, and Israel and Yemen as “religious violence”, falsely characterizes increased anti-zionism as “a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews” when these reported increases have come from sources that include pro-Palestine and anti-genocide protests as hate crimes. I don’t know as much about the other things, but I certainly can’t just take their word for it when they’ve shown themselves to be so dishonest and compromised on the Palestine colonial conflict.
And for what it’s worth, their main source for the claim about increased religious conflict is also Pew Research (lol), an American capitalist think tank. And they didn’t even link to the correct article that they seemingly meant to cite.
It literally says “In the United States and Europe”… “and Muslims” - "In the United States and Europe, a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews and Muslims… " - why would you truncate something, take it out of context, to fit only the narrative that you’re interested in??
Anyway, their point is that not having state-religion separation will lead to religious violence. For example, a Jewish state is a problem.
It literally says “According to the Pew Research Center, about one-quarter of countries worldwide exhibit “high” or “very high” levels of social hostilities involving religion, including violent religion-related attacks. We’re seeing this play out globally. A new wave of religious violence across the Middle East commenced with the devastating attack by Hamas against Israel on October 7, 2023. Sectarian conflicts continue to simmer in countries as diverse as India, Indonesia, Nigeria, and Vietnam. In the United States and Europe, a rising tide of hate crimes against Jews and Muslims shows that religious violence is by no means limited to the developing world. As of 2025, possible genocides against communities of faith are unfolding in China and in Myanmar. In many ways, religious violence is surging alongside a broader global resurgence of religion itself.” - why would you truncate something, take it out of context, to fit only the narrative that you’re interested in??
Those parts aren’t relevant to the issue, which was answering your question about the elements of the first paragraph of the article that would tarnish the credibility of the authors and publishers. I didn’t say that every single statement in the paragraph is problematic. I had particular criticisms of particular points. I did not take anything out of any relevant context. It is normal to quote only the relevant part for the sake of clarity and sentence structure. My point stands about the supposed “rising tide of hate crimes against Jews” (in the place where it’s purported to be happening, the United States and Europe, as opposed to some other place where it’s not, if it’s so important to you that I specify this). The increase in hate crimes against Muslims in the West, on the other hand, is much more strongly evidenced.
I don’t disagree. The rest of the article is a decent analysis of the harms of state religion, using examples that I guess they aren’t averse to acknowledging. My original statement was (emphasis added):
But your example of a Jewish state is yours, and not theirs. Their intentional erasure of the ethnoreligious supremacist nature of the state of Israel and its crimes is especially incredible given it’s followed by an entire article about the harms of state religion.
They were just citing rising religious violence studied in some parts of the world. Everyone mentioning that doesn’t have to explain or condemn the genocidal war. You’re being very west-centric.
They explicitly brought up and lied about Palestine.
At this point it seems like you’re just being intentionally dishonest.Fair enough, the way they put it feels contrived
Sign in to comment. Sign in