Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular financing deals, report claims
cross-posted from: https://lemmy.world/post/54411557
A chip oversupply may have pushed Nvidia to manufacture its own demand
The AI boom has been widely blamed for GPU prices spinning out of control over the past year. Following Jensen Huang’s resignation from Nvidia, new information suggests that this was the goal of the former CEO’s business strategy, which has long drawn accusations of circular financing.
A recent Wall Street Journal profile of Nvidia interim CEO Colette Kress has shed more light on how Nvidia controversially financed its own customers to drive the AI boom. According to the report, the company pushed for more deals in mid-to-late 2026 to keep its GPU prices high amid an oversupply of TSMC wafers.
Since at least last year, Nvidia has been accused of prolonging the AI boom by supporting the companies that buy its chips. Founder and former CEO Jensen Huang, along with then-CFO Kress, even went so far as to defend the company against comparisons to Enron, which used similar tactics to illegally obscure its debt before its 2001 collapse.
Comments
Circular financing can support GPU prices, but it doesn’t by itself prove fraud or deliberate price manipulation.
The mechanism is:
The key test is whether those buyers can eventually pay their bills from independent customer revenue, rather than repeated financing. Useful evidence would include financing terms, purchase commitments, related-party disclosures and cash collection—not just announced deal sizes.
There’s also a source-verification issue here: the excerpt asserts Huang’s resignation, an interim CEO and deals in “mid-to-late 2026.” I wouldn’t treat those claims as established without checking the original report and publication date. The Enron comparison isn’t evidence of equivalent accounting misconduct.
Haven’t we known this for years? How is this news?
What you reckon, and what’s been confirmed are not the same.
It was fact based before, these deals with AI companies and data centers have not been in secret. We may not have known absolutely every little nitty gritty detail, but we’ve known about them. It’s the main reason the theory of us being in an ai bubble and that it will pop any minute now has been so prevalent, cause we know it would only take one of these companies in the chain to start fucking up to get the ball rolling.
Suspected before, confirmed now.
Fraud, call it what it is. Its fraud.
Please let it collapse.
Also, please let him get punished in Singapore the way they punish drug smugglers. Public floggings and whatnot.
Singapore and punishing the wealthy? Good joke.
Singapore doesn’t punish the wealthy lol
Did you know that a lot of the Nvidia consumer cards are artificiality throttled for AI use? A hacker unlocked it without overclocking or anything like that.
Artikel from Tom’s Hardware
Nvidia was always anti-consumer, and I’m not surprised that they kept the prices artificially high. I’m just surprised that AMD didn’t step in to take over the ailing PC market.
AMD? You mean the AMD whose CEO is Lisa Su, Jensen Huangs first cousin? Huh… I couldn’t imagine why that AMD wouldn’t want to mess with Nvidias circular financing scheme
*first cousin once removed
Huang’s uncle is Su’s grandfather.
This is probably a tin foil hat moment, but AMD is run by the same family.
There was also an article about possible sanctions circumvention scheme, so the part with being able to unlock more real RAM in it might be not only due to legitimate practices of locking modules that failed some tests and selling in products of another line (that everybody does with CPUs and GPUs and what not for many years), and might be because those who buy them unknowingly are in fact paying more for the same compute than those who buy them knowingly, subsidizing the latter.
First time I’m reading the article. It sounds great. Does anyone have personal experience trying it out?
Well, thank goodness we can finally lower those prices now that all the bullshit is over. Right?
Right?!
Don’t worry, it’ll still be all the right people buying stuff before you get a chance. Like after the dotcom bubble crash when somehow a certain bunch of companies, including certain Google and Facebook, got ahold of crapissimoloads of Sun hardware that they then put to good use providing for free services that people needed, effectively oligopolizing the Web as a result, and honestly much of tech.
I hear that story and feel like the reason each consumer could.only buy one, was if one person bought them all, he couldn’t maintain a consumer base and would be at the whim of his big buyers demands…
The lesson should have been to prioritize amount of customers over a few large contracts that could disappear overnight.
this has a name
Yep what a sociopath. Soup vendor priced things well and put limits so more people would get an opportunity to try the soup.
But the billionaires take away was I should make things super expensive so only wealthy people can afford things.
Prison
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/6361ec50-efbc-409b-8de8-b5f61f5e8fd8.jpeg
Also for boards of financial institutions lending to this without doing due diligence. Arguably they’re worse because they should bear responsibility for investors savings, and also to avoid bank runs and triggering financial panic. Hopefully it’s mostly equity financing and the investors will get nowt; but banking systems are so complex I think it’s quite hard to follow the source of funds.
I feel like we already kinda knew this.
I mean, at this point of the enshittification of capitalism (an inherently shitty system to begin with), it’s safe to assume that a billionaire CEO is a corrupt, evil asshole.
Why not, right! Like pass the buck back to the real ppl (eg gamers) If it wasn’t for game developers pushing thier own boundaries, there woul have been no way he could have pushed for large language model shift.
Wait. So this is why I can’t afford a new gaming GPU?
… Duh. Nvidia has financed all the AI Enterprise, which in turn kept their prices high by buying all the stock with the money Nvidia invested in them.
This has been known for like 2 years.
Meaning that those companies collectively own so much that they are capable of overweighting any of “non-organized” areas of market, like, well, us normal users.
Or ram.
Gee, when I price fix a nation, I have to go to bed without supper.
And if you price fix the whole world you’re grounded for a week I suppose?
And they take away my phone, yea.
No more robux for you this week buddy
Prison for everyone involved in this.
They don’t want to, so won’t happen. Prefer tropical islands with rum and coconuts.
Of course it did. That’s what monopolies do. It’s why we call it market failure and why even in the most free market radical interpretations of capitalism it’s still the government’s one job to prevent and break up monopolies.
Great, another addition to “The Great list of rich assholes who deserve to be punched in the mouth but probably never will”, Volume 15.
https://lem.lemmy.blahaj.zone/pictrs/image/78a61b0f-6c61-4a17-bf37-47fa86b5d943.webp
I can’t wait to look back at this in 20 years, and be amazed that the bubble was popped by Jensens penis.
Story mentions internal crisis about overproduction/unsold inventory. Primary act that made GPU prices astronomical is Nvidia buying out all of TSMC/HBM memory capacity. Secondary, was the circular financing. Nvidia’s extortionism, btw, includes its customers contracts committing to purchases at whatever price Nvidia decides at time of delivery. Last quarter’s financial projections said 70% revenue growth on roughly the same volume. They were planning on extorting customers that hard.
Many of their customers are under extreme financial stress that can’t absorb Nvidia extortion. The only ones who aren’t are Hyperscallers who are designing their own chips to escape Nvidia extortion.
guess i’m switching to AMD…until whatever bullshit skeletons in their closet come to light. then i guess i’ll have to find a new pastime
Fun fact - the CEO of AMD is Jensen Huang’s first cousin.
what the fuck
https://media.tenor.com/CMsesV7bO7kAAAAC/iasip-its-always-sunny.gif
It’s all a big club.
Intel GPUs have splendid drivers under Linux!
If Intel doesn’t tickle your fancy, Vortex looks promising.
Intel GPUs are quite weak last time I checked them. AMD seems a better option if one ignores “we are a data center first” company crap.
I recently bought an Arc B580 (upgrade from 1070) and the first results where underwhelming until I learned that its 12GB VRAM were bottlenecked without a MOBO and CPU supporting Resizable BAR. Two upgrades later (Rog-Strix B-550-F and Ryzen 5700 from B-350 and Ryzen 1600) and I’m quite pleased. Stayed on AM4 as I could carry on my 32GB DDR4, as DDR5 would’ve exhausted my budget. Having a two monitor setup (3440x1440 and 1920x1080) under CachyOS/Wayland/KDE it’s very responsive and the desktop animations are super fluid. Witcher 3 Remastered is running quite nice (haven’t checked FPS) in high to ultra settings on WQHD (granted no ray or path tracing). I think I haven’t got any more demanding games in my library, so your mileage may vary with ultra demanding games and ray tracing. But the few other games I threw at it (ARC Raiders, Deus Ex Mankind divided, Dishonored 2) also ran at high to ultra settings on WQHD and broke no sweat.
All in all I paid ~700€ (carrying on my PSU, RAM and case) and I think I’m set for the next years. Less than most AMD or Nvidia GPUs alone. But the B580s are getting more expansive by the day currently.
If this demand manufactoring is enough for you to switch sides, I have a hard time seeing AMD being a better choice. 🤷♂️
Its not switching sides for the sake of switching when it comes to Linux, but quality of drivers on Linux that determines the hardware chosen. And when it comes to gaming AMD has been the better offering on Linux.
Windows is the platform where people can switch on a whim, since its the one all OEMs prioritize.
Basically, its the GrapheneOS situation. People don’t go with Pixel because they love Google, but because its the only option for GrapheneOS until Motorola’s release.
These things (whose drivers work best) do change over time. I can remember times where ATI drivers under Linux were absolute dogshit, both open and closed ones, while NVidia cards were pretty much fine. Then it changed around, and since around mid 2025 - when explicit sync was finally added and the most prominent bugs fixed - NVidia drivers under Linux work fine for most people (still a bit depending on the chosen distributions ressources and how niche your respective GPU is, as always under Linux, but any mainstream ones will do what they are supposed to with comparable performance to windows). If you want to use your GPU for inference, CUDA makes it super easy too (as in “install this flatpak and you are set”).
Nowadays there isn’t a real reason to choose between AMD and NVidia just based on driver support. And they are both morally bankrupt. Since the US government now holds Intel shares, they aren’t a much better choice morally.
Nvidia drivers on Linux have been fine for a while now (I haven’t had issues in about 2 years at least). Intel apparently is good too. The AMD advantage is no longer as great as it once was. And they’ve been winding down consumer GPU product lines. The last gen lacks high end cards because they said they only want to compete in the midrange. Which makes sense, given they wanted to focus on AI hardware. Lisa Su has been attending those Trump dinners for AI bros.
Sadly, even after Motorola releases way too pricey grapheneos compatible devices, people will be still stuck with pixels. IMO graphene should consider adaptive approach rather than all of nothing.
They (AMD**) are also involved in the same circular financing. I’m not sure what people in this comment section are talking about, and I think most of them don’t know either. None of this is new information or necessarily illegal.
It’s completely legitimate to have concerns about the circular financing, there’s been lots of talk about that for over a year now, but I’m not sure why people are saying it’s fraud suddenly
Look up the term channel stuffing. That’s the part that can be accused of fraud under certain conditions and is related but separate from the circular financing situation. There was a better article around here a few days ago that outlined it a bit more than this one.
The former CEO basically admitted to channel stuffingI misremembered but whether this scenario meets the bar for fraud is up to the courts. (More supporting details in my reply below)well it’s only luxury goods
I found an informative wiki page about this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_build-out_financing
Sounds like circular financing has similar characteristics to leveraged investing, because both the gains and losses are amplified.
Buy the new one though
The latest nvidia card driver will take your kids to school so you can keep playing Call of FIFAnight.
Sign in to comment. Sign in