Comment on Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular financing deals, report claims
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
Look up the term channel stuffing. That’s the part that can be accused of fraud under certain conditions and is related but separate from the circular financing situation. There was a better article around here a few days ago that outlined it a bit more than this one.
The former CEO basically admitted to channel stuffingI misremembered but whether this scenario meets the bar for fraud is up to the courts. (More supporting details in my reply below)Investing in your future customers isn’t what channel stuffing is. Channel stuffing would be like if Microsoft ordered 200 GPUs, and Nvidia generated an invoice for and sent them 400 GPUs instead, inflating its sales.
Fraud is totally possible, but there is no evidence of it mentioned anywhere in this article or any others, just a lot of vague gesticulating to information that’s been common knowledge for a long time and pretending it’s new.
Here is a video of the Plain Bagel, a popular finance YouTuber, talking about all of this a year ago: https://youtu.be/fIcWfHikAOo?si=7L62fxNXOcvQaNlM
Note that he also agrees that the investing patterns are unsustainable, but there’s been no evidence so far of fraud, or that the bubble is gonna pop any day now. I really think these articles are just preying on people who want to hope things will return to normal soon.
To be clear, I’m not talking about investing in your customers, which was the circular financing connection.
You asked why people were talking about fraud all of a sudden and I am suggesting it’s due to channel stuffing accusations. I don’t know that these agreements necessarily meet the bar for fraud, but Ed Zitron threw it out there so people talk.
Also this one which points to Ed Zitron’s post here (as the analyst referenced)
You’ll see channel stuffing referenced in both.
Ohhhhhh, okay. Thank you.
The way this is described, I’d be really comfortable saying there’s not evidence of fraud yet. Ed Zitron claims that Nvidia forced $20 billion GPUs onto customers that did not order them, without saying where that figure comes from. Meanwhile the primary users of these GPUs, like Amazon and Google, are talking about buying GPUs they cannot yet use due to grid capacity. There’s not really evidence that Google et al. didn’t actually buy these GPUs.
The blog post suggests that Amazon is, like, being threatened by Nvidia claiming that Amazon won’t have access to the GPUs in the future if they don’t buy them right now, but that’s more like a high pressure sales tactic. It’s not channel stuffing.
But at least now I know where the accusation is coming from.
Isn’t that the same as what Valve reported regarding buying Ram for the Steam Machine? You get a call with an offer, you can either take it or they won’t call anymore.
Edit: found the part: https://www.theverge.com/games/953945/valve-steam-machine-memory-component-crisis
This is very much blackmail, especially if the prices are inflated because of NVidia ordering so much silicon that they have to finance the sale of this very silicon by giving their clients money.
I dunno! It would make a lot of sense in the current environment. There’s definitely a lot of “if I don’t buy it now, it’ll be gone” or “if I don’t buy it now, it’ll cost $100 more next week” going on.
Sign in to comment. Sign in