87
What would it realistically take for you to trust the government again?
For me, it would be consistency. Consistency in being transparent about what’s going on. Holding itself accountable. Actually holding people messing with numerous lives accountable.
It’d be a big ask.
Comments
My own quote, but I’m sure others have had similar epiphanies:
"Anybody who actively seeks to assume a position of power is precisely the sort of person who shouldn’t be let anywhere even remotely near it."
Why?
An old saying goes “heavy is the head that wears the crown.” Power is a Huge responsibility and quite often a burden, bordering on a curse. If you want to, willingly, be in that position then either you are seeking it for your own ends, or you are actually insane. In either case, such a mindset is rather disqualifying, IMHO.
Right, right, right… “my point,” as to answer the question:
Faith has been barred from interacting with government (separation of church and state) as codified in the U.S. Constitution. I would like to see a similar amendment doing the same for corporate businesses, for exactly the same reason.
Faith is a monied interest that holds out sized sway in people’s judgements and concerns. A reasoned and civil discourse is impossible with such an odious thumb on the scales of debate. Corporations are no different and, in fact, are trying to position themselves as modern-day Aristocracy, which, I will remind you, America was founded to be rid of.
Ranked Choice Voting + Ending Citizens United
No matter what your personal political leaning is, policy will be corralled by special interests with deep pockets until these things are changed.
citezens united has some benefits for non campaign purposes (making is so companies are as protected as citizens while trolling online), and wouldn’t be overturned with this supreme court anyways.
Trump tried for treason, convicted, and sentenced and the sentence carried out.
There is no point at which you should ever trust government. We give it power to progress as a society. That comes with the price of constant vigilance. Because at least we know the government has that power, and not some random executive or warlord, who might destroy everything for their own ego.
Friend growing up had a bumper sticker on her car that read, “Patriot’s Question Authority”
Always stuck with me. Later in life I added saying, the intelligent question everything whenever I thought about that sticker.
That’s fine if you know what you’re talking about.
One thing recent experience has taught me is that there’s a lot of people who should just shut up and do what they’re told.
If the authority is some asshat who thinks it’s ok to eat roadkill, question that piece of shit.
If the authority is the combined knowledge and consensus of the majority of all the experts in a field, just shut up and do what you’re told.
In general I can agree, but only from a practical standpoint, since you should be questioning the consensus, but you are incapable of querying enough things to be able to form your own opinion. I find all too often that people who subscribe to the blanket statement of trust the experts are incapable of judging who is in fact an expert.
A good starting point is putting all focus on serving the people and not corporations or donors. Overturning Citizens United is the first step. Anyone who works against this is thrown out. I don’t care if that sounds bad. I’m tired of politicians, no matter the letter they put next to their name, prioritizing companies and other countries over us. You either help us or get fucked.
US defaultism
The US, famous for being the only place with a government.
And you can see Americans replying to this post talking about “democrats” and “republicans” as opposed groups (normally these are synonymous—most republics are democracies?) so clearly they have decided which government “the government” refers to without any specification in the OP lol.
Anyone is free to come in here and talk about their own government.
Of course. That’s not my point. My point is that there is no actual context in the title or body text that says that this is about the US. That’s just implied. The title should probably have started with “Americans: …” or should have specified “the US government”.
To fulfil the promises they kept in the last 25 years.
I can go on.
There needs to be accountability for failure. Without that the government will never reform and no one will be motivated to do good work.
What’s this “again” shit? Don’t trust the government.
I don’t trust you though, so…
Eh, seems perfectly rational to me. But yeah, I’ve never trusted the government.
If it’s available through foia request then it should be freely available without having to request it
Damn straight. Shouldn’t need to trust the government, because it should be so fucking transparent that there’s nothing about it you can’t easily verify yourself.
Someone mentioned government transparency being a rare good application for blockchain technology. Not sure exactly how that would play out but I think it would be awesome. Maybe you’d be able to decentralize trust in the case of something like an expense sheet.
While I agree with the spirit of your message, this is not a realistic expectation. FOIA requests can get extremely granular including pulling related emails and text messages.
Consequences. Remove all financial motivation (for all the high seats and seats of influence). Take responsibility for your actions.
I assume “The Government” means the US? I mean, there is another country or two in the world.
At any rate, here are some guidelines.
“The government” isn’t a monolith.
OPs probably talking about the federal level. State and local governments can be pretty solid.
There’s countries other than America.
That shouldve been specified in the title.
And my comment can apply to about any country. The Philippines have a federal government, along with local and state governments. I wondered if OP left it open on purpose.
Full transparency. I want to be able to see all their bank accounts, see what they spend and what they get. And If they get a new car that’s off the books, that’s jail time.
Accountability, first and foremost. Limit political donations to private donors only, with an upper limit per person and year, to a party only, and through a neutral clearing house that anonymizes all donations. Perfect location for that would be the IRS: Add a donation statement to your tax forms, they put the amount on your tab, and hand the lump sum over to the parties. Any other form of contribution should be considered a bribe and made illegal, with heavy fines attached. And yes, dinners with your representative that you pay for would fall right under this.
Any kind of contribution or donation to public servants and other official should be made illegal. There is no need for supreme court members to get expensive trips or RVs from interested parties.
Epstein trials, end citizens united, ranked choice voting, end lobbying, ice agents in jail. For starters.
I’m down for all that, but lobbying is a sticking point.
1st Amendment: “…and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”
Killing Citizens United and tightening up lobbying rules would probably fix your concerns. And keep in mind, there are good lobbyists out there fighting for us. For example, if you put together a citizen group to address your legislators, you are now a lobbyist.
But the rest is the bare minimum.
You’re right, I should have said corporate lobbying. The citizens should be lobbying.
Lots of hangings. Lots.
Technically that’s the one thing we’ve had. We’ve consistently covered everything up and never held anyone accountable.
We can’t say we’ve ever been transparent or held people accountable, but we have consistantly been the opposite.
Some of us were brought up in a fictional USA where we weren’t told about any of the bad stuff and people just pretended none of it ever happened and that the “appearance of impropriety” was enough to oust someone from their position. Which it was, to a certain extent. The main reason being that if you were dumb enough to get caught, you didn’t deserve your position. But that’s not what we were told. We were told that everyone was honorable except the communists.
Trusting the government is part of the problem. We shouldn’t trust the state, its only motivation will be to preserve and expand its power at the expense of the working class.
To start; reallocating billionare wealth to the people and closing tax loopholes for billionares and companies. Then implementing total transparency in goverment. If you are a goverment official, you shall have no privacy.
Again? I never trusted them to begin with.
Yeah your never supposed to trust the government there need to be a watchful eye on them making sure they are working for you.
“With the first link, the chain is forged. The first speech censured, the first thought forbidden, the first freedom denied, chains us all irrevocably.” The first time any man’s freedom is trodden on, we’re all damaged." - some bald guy
Reallocating national resources toward improving people’s lives rather than accumulating profit.
Okay hot take: “I do trust the government” (followed by an infinite series of asterisks). But if I was told of an impending disaster, my first thought wouldn’t be to go back to bed and namecall the people who heed the warnings as sheep.
Trust but verify. Governments are corrupt and act against the interests of their citizens more often than not. They need to be checked and held accountable. Ultimately, the government is merely just another organization of deeply flawed humans; tho, one with a lot of power and that is heavily mired with perverse incentives.
Basically? A new government.
All republicans out. Most democrats, too. (The moderate ones.)
And that new government is going to have to have transparency and accountability and demonstrate that it can be trusted.
I imagine people in other countries might see a similar change.
As others said, I don’t think so.
I am American, and we have never truly grasped the idea of inalienable rights in the first place.
I am greatly optimistic about our chances of wrangling government back for the people, but that’s because I choose to remain optimistic rather than be a pessimist.
But trust the government? It’s like trusting a corporation. They are malleable entities with unspoken agendas who can never truly be trusted.
Sign in to comment. Sign in