I’ve tried them both along with a few different lemmy instances and found .today on lemmy is my best fit.
Since others have covered the technical angle, I’ll say I prefer lemmy from a social perspective. My instance doesn’t block other instances, banning users only for extreme cases. I prefer to choose my experience for myself without being ideologically guided by someone else’s values.
For all the criticisms of the lemmy developers, their biases don’t make it into the code. Instances are run according to the admins and user’s wishes, which allows .today to operate as openly as possible. Piefed, on the other hand, suffers from the biases of its developer, who not only blocks users but also instances of admins who don’t align with them. They have passed along their ban list to other admins as well, getting users banned for disagreeing with them. That’s not the behavior of someone I want running my platform of choice.
Along with that. I, personally, don’t like the idea of reputation, low score flags, karma or any system based on the votes of users, since they can be easily manipulated. It feels like Piefed is trying to implement a more intense karma system, which was one of my main problems with reddit. I believe each post and comment should stand on its own merit.
Good point. If there is a karma system, the main activity for a sizeable (and by definition overrepresented) chunk of the user base will just use the platform to maximize karma, whether for nefarious purposes or just because people treat gamified systems like games. Having real user registrations (so you can block individual users) as opposed to a 4chan like thing, but having no karma system or engagement optimization algorithm in the feed, are the requirements for a healthy forum.
Comments
I’ve tried them both along with a few different lemmy instances and found .today on lemmy is my best fit.
Since others have covered the technical angle, I’ll say I prefer lemmy from a social perspective. My instance doesn’t block other instances, banning users only for extreme cases. I prefer to choose my experience for myself without being ideologically guided by someone else’s values.
For all the criticisms of the lemmy developers, their biases don’t make it into the code. Instances are run according to the admins and user’s wishes, which allows .today to operate as openly as possible. Piefed, on the other hand, suffers from the biases of its developer, who not only blocks users but also instances of admins who don’t align with them. They have passed along their ban list to other admins as well, getting users banned for disagreeing with them. That’s not the behavior of someone I want running my platform of choice.
Along with that. I, personally, don’t like the idea of reputation, low score flags, karma or any system based on the votes of users, since they can be easily manipulated. It feels like Piefed is trying to implement a more intense karma system, which was one of my main problems with reddit. I believe each post and comment should stand on its own merit.
I have a hard time donating to the Lemmy developers knowing that money from it goes to run .ml.
If it went to fund a neutral test instance I’d feel much better about it.
FYI only donations via OpenCollective are used for lemmy.ml hosting (see the expenses). Other donation methods are purely to pay for development work.
Good point. If there is a karma system, the main activity for a sizeable (and by definition overrepresented) chunk of the user base will just use the platform to maximize karma, whether for nefarious purposes or just because people treat gamified systems like games. Having real user registrations (so you can block individual users) as opposed to a 4chan like thing, but having no karma system or engagement optimization algorithm in the feed, are the requirements for a healthy forum.
Sign in to comment. Sign in