Skip to content

Comment on Is GenAI the Problem I dont like to work anymore?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • The philosophical problem of what purpose we might have once liberated from toil is old af. It’s no secret that wealthy people are often unhappy, or decadent, or sociopathic, or whatever. I suspect that attaining such liberation is unhealthy for the individual within an evolutionary/cultural context of people defined by their toil. We don’t have any cultural legacy to lean on here because we always lived in cultures of toil, but probably (assuming material concerns are largely met by the Ai shift) we would need to rethink our cultural values - status is at the heart of it, it’s actually what motivates us. For now, status is derived primarily from wealth, but in a world of free time and abundance, the persuit of wealth becomes a shallow vanity. New cultural values are required. Perhaps expertise, social contribution, artistic contribution. Who knows?

    Im not hugely optimistic for our collective ability to choose that. I think rather they will emerge after a few generations of fighting over what scraps of toil remain.

    For you, as an individual, probably you are experiencing some sort of awakening to the absurdity of existence, a philosophical crisis. Are you around 40?😂 I propose engaging with the part of yourself that appreciates novelty, it’s fun and never a negative. But for the future it may be wise to consider who you are when you can no longer define a large part of yourself by the toil.

    These are strange times.

    35
    • Thank you a lot for your comment! I could not agree more with what you say about the general problem of abundance.

      In my specific case though, I might have to add the context, that I consciously chose to work as a Researcher in a University, in a field with societal impact, to not fall into the trap you describe. Its truly rewarding work, especially when I can supervise students.

      Maybe the the main problem for me is, how LLM-use seems to have changed how I approach chunks of my work. And I am wondering if there is something I can do about it.

      (I am 32, 3rd year of postdoc, so while not 40 it still feels some kind of philosophical crisis because most of the scientific content I see feels like low-quality, pushed-out-to-fast bullshit)

      0
    • You’ve articulated what I had been trying to hammer on way better than I ever could. A decade ago I was asking people online “What is the value of a man who does not work?”

      I was trying to get people to think about the structure of society and the hierarchy of labor, the social mores, and how we can prepare for the future without it catching us with our pants down. I was, and am still, excited about the potential of the human race unshackled from the resource acquisition drive which has dominated our entire history. But it is also a powder keg if not handled with some forethought.

      And this didn’t require any particular prescience on my part; automation of labor was an increasingly frequent theme both in near sci-fi and real world.

      I never got anyone to engage in the topic with me about it. I thought it was extremely important to start putting our heads together about it now but… I guess it seemed too abstract or fantastical to really grab people. I also struggle to communicate clearly so that doesn’t help. I gave up after a while.

      Anyway, look at us now. LLMs might not be the AI it’s marketed to be but it’s already hitting society and the real thing will be here soon.

      4

Sign in to comment. Sign in