157
Anybody else hate musicals as a kid?
Like, Scar, my dude, you could have just taken 15 seconds to tell the hyenas your evil plan instead of wasting 4 minutes of everyone’s time singing about it.
Like, Scar, my dude, you could have just taken 15 seconds to tell the hyenas your evil plan instead of wasting 4 minutes of everyone’s time singing about it.
Comments
My only memory of musicals as a child was disgust at my brother he’d start howling in protest every time characters broke into song & dance. When my brother was no longer in my life I could finally start to enjoy musicals. I like musicals. They are awesome.
Still do
Disagree. West Side Story, An American in Paris, Singing in The Rain, Stormy Weather, Yellow Submarine, The Jungle Book, The Music Man, Hair, Camelot, Rocky Horror, Jesus Christ Superstar, Willy Wonka, All That Jazz, Hairspray, School Daze, Mamma Mia and so many Muppet Movies just to name a few.
I like some musicals, but I can’t stand the generic musical which has the same musical type song that show tunes lovers will sing at the drop of the hat that all sounds the same. All the Broadway style songs where you have the We Are Enthusiastically Introducing The Setting Song, then the Oh There’s Some Confident About Ourselves Song, then the We’re In Love song, then the Oh No A Problem song, then the Very Sad Solo Song That Is Sad song, then the Fast Paced Conflict song, then the Same Song As The Beginning But It’s The End song.
You would probably love Schmigadoon, which is basically a series about a couple getting trapped in a world where everyone is always breaking into song like a musical.
It’s quite entertaining https://youtu.be/yKG0RodrzVo?is=4BOtgsbBmbTj69zB
Also, the tv show My crazy ex girlfriend. It’s a comedy show that uses songs to pretty great effect, they parody lots of styles commonly seen in musicals but the topics are hilarious and not at all what you’d expect.
It ranges from “It was a shitshow” https://youtu.be/b-tAiOVMYFY?is=_BMyb39Vd_JDa8Ik
To “You ruined everything” https://youtu.be/zgUKQCVieWM?is=n2kEF_TKzkHPNcAP
To “heavy boobs” https://youtu.be/aZx5zfkG6oU?is=cbXHcXA8-CnsI4f5
Oh shit thanks for the recommendations!
Also the Buffy episode “Once more with feeling”
There are several musicals that I love. But I hate the often mega-popular ones which feature what I call The New Disney Soprano. The type that tries to sing like Jodi Benson, but they just sound very whiny.
I still hate musicals. I get Disney+ for “free” (With my overpriced Spectrum sub). I started to watch the live-action Aladin and Will Smith started singing, I noped the fuck out of that. Same thing when I thought I’d watch Frozen. I definitely let that shit go.
That’s not a musical, that a movie with singing
Try the filmed live on broadway of Hamilton on there. (Disney+)
I think all of the Disney princess movies have musical numbers
“Hate” is too strong, but I don’t watch them. I don’t care for singing in movies as a rule, unless the movie is about a singer. Even then, I don’t want multiple full music videos embedded in the movie. Just not my thing.
We’re not alone:
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/1d4bf9fb-678c-4d09-9959-ca4cf8e82648.jpeg
Beware the changing y-axis.
this is correct, but it does say that the genres are compared by year to themselves, not to other genres.
:(
This is so bad lol, they change the Y axis constantly, yes they did write about it but it just begs to be read wrong
This graph shows the percentage of different movies being released… not whether those movies were popular…
What’s with the bump in the popularity of Westerns in the 60s and 70s? All I remember is that bit in Toy Story 2 where Stinky Pete complains about the launch of Sputnik.
Clint Eastwood and spaghetti western era?
I’m guessing it was harkening back to the not so distant past. Like WW2 movies and games not so long ago.
I think it might not be featuring Bollywood.
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1187043/
Always mostly hated all Disney musicals in the 90s because all the other kids I was growing up with would sing it and for whatever reason that would trigger a negative response in my brain.
Yes. At 50, I still do. They are tacky, kitschy and written for either kids or kidults.
Yep, my powers of suspension of disbelief could not handle characters singing about stuff instead of talking
Is that my problem?! I always found musicals ridiculous and I think you’ve put your finger on it.
Imagine yourself in the scene. You’re part of a group listening to someone talk about something difficult and then they (and possibly others) break out into song and dance. Maybe even music plays out of nowhere. You’d think the person/situation is insane. I mean I watch other movies with more unrealistic things but the musicals never sat with me for the suspension of disbelief reason
Why stop as a kid? I can’t really enjoy myself when watching a musical played out on stage, and I saw some epic spectacles. (Les Miserables, Sissy, Soldaat van Oranje). It’s just not for me.
When it’s cartoons, it’s not so bad for me. The silliness of breaking out into songs fits that world better for me. But make it a live action movie and please let me leave the theater.
I don’t know why, but I become irrationally angry when there is some musical where the actors do that fucking moronic thing where they look up wistfully and sing REAL LOUD. What are they looking at? Why are they fanning their arms out in that big slow arc? Who does that?! Why is that supposed to be entertaining?
That and the “really excited” sing that people do, big corny smile, they’re all jazzed up about going out to buy a new hat or something for no good reason. “Hey, let’s go downtown and buy a HAT!!!”. JFC. Do audiences really demand this sort of nonsense?
All art has its unrealistic conventions. Video Game characters can die and come back to life, architecture has stone columns chiseled to look like wood, souped-up cars have additions that don’t actually make them go faster or make them artificially loud for no benefit, sports has people faking injuries, wrestling has kayfabe… we are ritualistic beings who engage in social displays.
In live action, it always feels like a format that is more for the actors than the audience. I do sing for hobby myself and I try to be technically really good, practice over and over, and aim for a performance I would be proud of, So i have some experience with this myself (what you would do to enjoy yourself during singing, vs what would be actually fun to listen to). All those dumb moves you describe somehow just naturally come out of me while singing. Playacting out the song as a real story in my head makes me able to put more emotion in the song, and doing that will immediately summon my inner ‘musical actor/performer’ so to speak. So now it kind of looks like a guitarist bobbing along to the song to me. You don’t NEED to do that, but most musicians will enjoy doing it. I just sing Toni Braxton - Un-break my heart flatout better, if I can sometimes make my hand into a fist and dramatically and powerfully move it down.
So again, those are the exact same things that annoy me, and it just looks like what the performer themselves would most enjoy doing at that time, seemingly without caring about the actual final product (a horrible live action musical)
I have and still do. Cannot stand them. Cannot even stand musical episodes of shows.
The only exception is Cannibal! The Musical.
Edit2: This is also why I can’t get into Bollywood.
Edit9001: Okay, there’s actually a few musicals I do like. RHPS, Rent, Chicago, Cannibal, Frozen.
Have you seen Spamalot? Never mind, don’t go, its a silly musical.
Its actually quite good if you like Monty Python.
Nope, I loved them and still sing the songs from classic musicals like My Fair Lady and Sound of Music on a regular basis. Also a huge fan of Gilbert and Sullivan and and also most every recent Broadway music that has been nationally popular.
Noting that I do not consider cartoons, like Disnay cartoons, musicals. I only think of musicals as being live action from the start (not live action from a cartoon) or as plays.
As a kid I felt socially obligated to groan loudly and complain whenever somebody would burst into song, but secretly I really liked it when that happened, at least with some songs. Obviously some of them are just stupid.
I didn’t hate musicals on the surface but I sure hated “Paint Your Wagons” because I thought it was going to be a Clint Eastwood western shoot 'em up.
I also saw that episode of The Simpsons.
I didn’t. I saw it on CBC television in the 1970’s. Now I’m curious about the Simpson’s episode though.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fEknbyA5raM
Nope. I love musicals and always have.
I love that someone downvoted you for that. Total Lemmy right there.
WHAT?! Different?! They enjoy things I do not?! I must downvote them for their enjoyment of the thing I do not enjoy!
Take an upvote friend.
Thanks kind lemming! I just don’t see what’s not to love. Little Shop of Horrors, Rocky Horror Picture Show, every Muppets movie, Labyrinth, Grease, Fiddler on the Roof, Sound of Music…
Oh that’s funny you named like everyone I haven’t seen!
Rent, wicked, book of Mormon (which everyone here would love but are too afraid to try), lion king, merrily we toll along, and spacing on a couple others.
as a kid and an adult. funny because like does not bother me in the wizard of oz but some disney films. ugh.
Yes. I’m a life long hater of musicals.
I thought I hated musicals. But Phantom, Jersey Boys, Hamilton, Moana, Encanto, Coco, and others have convinced me otherwise.
I still don’t like musicals for being musical. For example I hate Cats and Le Miz and Wicked — they all have like one song that hits and everything else is meh, and I need most of the songs to hit in a musical.
But music can engage you and speak on an emotional level that words and speech struggle to (not always, though. Kirk’s speech at Spock’s funeral and the Presidents speech in Independence Day are good melodrama.) Sometimes words that would be completely trite if spoken take on an authenticity when sang to music. I give you Meatloaf’s entire oeuvre.
I don’t have rules for what works and what doesn’t, and certainly there wouldn’t be universal agreement. But I have a deep appreciation of really good musicals.
I was willing to hear you out but Les Miserables is full of amazing songs. It’s basically only amazing songs. Hell the opening song “Look Down” beats most other musicals best songs. Then you’ve got the standard best song of “I Dreamed a Dream”, or my personal favorite “On My Own”. Plus let’s not forget the anthem “Do You Hear the People Sing”. Or how about “Master of the House”? Let’s even look at the lesser known songs, “Empty Chairs and Empty Tables”, beautiful. Or “Back and Red”, inspiring! Or even just quick songs like the “Confrontation”.
Genuinely. Take another look at Les Miserables. It’s really amazing.
(Cats also has lots of fun songs, but Memory is the clear standout. The film is garbage, but if you can see it live it’s a more enjoyable experience. The trick is to treat it as more of a talent show versus a story.)
(Wicked also has at least two standout songs. Also by comparison Wicked is more story focused. So if you don’t like the story that’s fair. I enjoyed it, but that’s ok if it’s not for you.)
I’ve only seen Les Mis once, and that was the movie. Maybe the songs grow in you over time. But for whatever reason the songs didn’t hit for me. I didn’t mean to impugn it as a work of art, clearly it is beloved by many, many people. I love Anne Hathaway as an actress, and I Dreamed A Dream was a great song, but I can’t recall liking another song.
Not to pile on ya regarding your les mis stance, but I feel like your own point about how music can amplify the emotional weight of otherwise spoken words really really applies to les mis, and simultaneously doesn’t violate ops original complaint of it being a space filler.
Les mis generally clips at the same pace regardless of a musical or otherwise (Liam neeson and uma Thurman did a non musical movie, fantastic, and makes a great baseline comparison for pacing purposes)
Tons of it is straight dialogue set to music. Some are straight solos, but they’re all characters wrestling with some heavy shit. Who am I? I dreamed a dream. Stars.
One for sure can’t switch off their “people are saying critical things which advance the plot” ears. So many musicals, the musical numbers are fanfare and as a result a lot of people have been trained to kinda tune out a Lil’ bit. Fatal mistake for les mis.
Anyways, you don’t HAVE to like it, you’re allowed to not. Just surprised it made the “do not like” given your earlier explanation.
Edit: also I never saw the one with Hathaway. I saw a snippet and I could see Jackman and crowe just wouldn’t be able to nail the valjean javert and that’s CRITICAL.
I’ve only given it one chance and it’s fair to call me out. I’ve only given Cats one chance, as well. Phantom speaks to me on a level. As a young man, the idea that if I could just love someone hard enough they would love me back, was intensely appealing. Which is just to say that the first time I heard those songs I felt them in my core. Les Mis doesn’t have any story I can relate to not having seen it.
Also, I have to say that a huge chunk of the magic of Hamilton was just seeing the story come to life on stage. And I said I hate Wicked, but I don’t. I appreciate the story and seeing it on stage. But it’s about the stage rather than the music, although Popular is catchy as fuck. Defying Gravity is nothing without seeing it on stage.
It seems likely that if I ever gave Les Mis a fair shake, I would probably come to love it, once the story has taken root. But I can’t even speak the language for 1/3 of Moana songs and I find it beautiful.
Art is subjective.
It IS subjective, and I think you’re bang on about sometimes you really just vibe with some element of a story it just gets you.
And I’m super guilty of that (I say as if it’s a crime) so I’m sure my view of Les Mis is probably super biased. The central theme that a man isn’t defined by his past, but by his active commitments to his values… A full throated rejection of utilitarianism (which of course runs counter to peak 16 year old conception of philosophy)… God it hits. As hard when I was 16 as it does now.
The few lines as Valjean weighs intervening to protect a man on trial (for a crime Valjean himself committed decades earlier):
“How can I ever face my fellow men?”
slightly quieter
“How can I ever face myself again?”
Wilkinson NNAAIILLSS it.
So yah, some stuff’ll just vibe with you.
Cats is dogshit though. Just a parade of random cats. I don’t get it.
That’s your problem right there; most musical fans will agree with you that the movie sucks. Try seeing a live stage performance with real singers and see if it changes your opinion.
Yes and you nailed the reason. A very short list of exceptions:
I don’t think of that movie as a musical, but I guess it would count technically. But it’s more diegetic than usual.
It isn’t “a” musical. It is the perfect musical. We can stop making them now.
The Blues Brothers was the best musical ever made.
Didn’t hurt that the Blues Bros band was outstanding
Love kids ones, can’t stand others
Evita. Ruined musicals. Dragged to it as a kid. Never recovered
… Don’t keep your distance.
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/ffe48e4c-2090-4761-bd25-555eaf3ad168.gif
tbh i still don’t like them. wouldn’t say hate though but it just kinda feels boring and slightly annoying.
Fuck musicals. Also, fuck comedy songs too.
It’s very, very rare to be able to get decent music AND a decent story/joke to be told at the same time. I’ve got like 3 examples :
[deleted]
Um. Frank zappa is amazing.
Yes He is.
I don’t particularly find “Jazz from Hell” or anything else particularly funny though.
I mean, his music was full of humor though. Iirc he made a song and also spoke about music containing humor and that being a good thing.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying he didn’t make jokes in his music, I just didn’t find it particularly funny.
That’s the problem. It’s very, very hard to get the balance right between the two, and also, hit the correct audience at the same time with music and comedy. Different people can like different things for different genres.
I like weird al because I enjoy fast paced, complex music, and a down to earth sense of humour that isn’t too base, but kinda within your classical comedy. Zappa’s stuff is too dry or too base. I like the dry stuff in measured quantities, and I like the base stuff to be in the right context.
Musically, Zappa is amazing. But the comedy, doesn’t hit the mark. And that’s ok. That’s why I love Jazz from Hell.
That’s a take. Dry and base? We’re talking sex, dick, and piss jokes most of the time… now I have “Why Does it Hurt When I Pee?” In my head.
It’s fine if you don’t like Zappa’s humor, I’m just genuinely curious what you’ve heard to describe it that way. I’ve listened to all of his eras if not all his albums. A lot of it is pretty silly and crude, but I like that even the dumbest songs exist.
Loved Weird Al as a kid, I guess I still do. UHF was great.
Nightmare Before Christmas gets a pass because I love stop motion more than I hate musicals.
Moulin Rouge I probably would dislike immensely if I were forced to watch it.
I thought so too. It’s a lot more silly and a lot less sappy than you’d imagine. It’s more of a farce than a rom-com.
What if the music is part of the story, like Phantom of the Opera?
taps sign again
Wait shit, the thing is further down the thread.
I like musicals but don’t care for Phantom of The Opera.
Come up to the lab…
No tank you Mrs Doyle
Are Disney movies like that considered musicals? I guess I never thought of them like that.
I consider the movies from the Disney renaissance, starting with The Little Mermaid and maybe ending with Tarzan, to be musicals. These also happen to be the movies I grew up with, so grain of salt I guess.
I still liked the movies as a whole. I just got annoyed when they started singing. Now that I’m older I can say I simply don’t like musicals rather than outright hating them. Kids sometimes have a hard time sorting out their feelings and attitudes. I certainly did.
Do they sing about their feelings, and not just as an aside in the shower or something, as in, a full song is sung?
Then yes, it’s a musical.
Sign in to comment. Sign in