Now I understand why everyone wants “physical games”. They think that means a fucking box and not the actual full content of an application. So Its a “physical copy” if you pay for a plastic case that holds a card with a number on it.
That to say, we will never see a “physical copy” anymore with any AAA titles since they’re too big to store on any consumer grade optical media.
they’re too big to store on any consumer grade optical media.
This is just a bullshit excuse - we had tons of 4-disc games back in the day. And these days consumer grade bdxls can store up to 50-100gb. They just gain a lot by not selling physical, that’s it.
There is also an issue that playing a game from 5 disks was always a fucking hell of an experience, and the situation that one of the 5 disks stopped working randomly rendering the whole array a nice kilo of plastic waste. This can, obviously, fixed by removing DRM restrictions, but if we’re capable of that, what are we even doing then
Yeah, it was not without its drawbacks, but it’s still a feasible option ( if the goal was to provide something physical that’s not a goddamn code in a box ).
Feasible option to do what? I have kilos of plastic laying around somewhere, that used to be physical media containing games, but now it’s unplayable because either DRM doesn’t work anymore (hello, Denuvo), or the disk has deteriorated due to time or use, and it’s totally unusable despite me legally still “owning” a copy. Meanwhile, there are games that I bought digitally from GoG that I will be able to play as long as computers exist.
Owning a game has nothing to do with how did it get to you
we will never see a “physical copy” anymore with any AAA titles since they’re too big to store on any consumer grade optical media
That’s only because the people researching optical discs are part of the same massive tentacled corporation that ran the numbers and realized they’d make more money total by killing physical media.
There is also, you know, the limitation of the physical world. Whatever technology we have right now is such a marvel of science and engineering, it’s unbelievable how did we ever achieved this affront to nature. I don’t think we can expect that this can continue. Not that it can’t, humans are amazing at bending the reality, but we can’t expect it.
With aggregation-induced emission dye-doped photoresist, 1.25TB can fit on each layer of a disk, and 100 layers have been demonstrated on an actual disk. If, for some unfathomable reason, your game doesn’t fit into 125TB of storage, there are researchers working on a 200TB disk.
I know this is still expensive, and not mass-market, but… we have room before we run out of “the best that physics can possibly do”.
Like at the barest minimum even if we accept your argument, there’s still nothing stopping them just making laserdisc sized UHDs, there’s an instant 700Gb right there
They really are these days. On my xbox ive got halo MCC and Forza. Theyre both like 110+GB. The games I enjoy most are 4GB tops though. Massive files are pretty much a turn off for me. Its too much of a commitment.
I think its because high resolution textures and other graphics and sound samples. People game on 4k screens now so I guess all that takes up a lot of space.
I’ll defend the technicality that most games aren’t playable solely off of disk these days, but yeah having a physical token of the ownership of a licence is fuckin invaluable apparently.
As far as I can tell Sony deliberately stopped research into optical discs ten years ago. UHD was launched in 2016 and can store 100Gb. GTA6 could have been a two-discer with a bit of judicious compression and trimming.
The disc itself is functionally useless. But the physical ownership aspect is easily replaced.
Just use a USB drive as the physical license token instead of the disc. No need to store the full game on it, just use a few MB of cheap Read-Only Memory.
Every game requires Day 1 patches to be playable anyway, so the disc never let you play the game on its own anyway, and after the install is only ever used as a license already. Why even pretend the game is actually there and useable?
Ok kid, let me tell you a story of how things used to be: we had disks, that contained everything the game needed to run. They even had drm, where the game would check if the disk is authentic or a copy. none of that required any additional download or online connection. If there was an update or patch, you would go to the developers website, download the installer for that patch and run it. as long as you kept that installer somewhere, you still didn’t need an online connection to install and play your game.
That’s what us old people want from a physical copy: some data storage device, that contains everything you need, even if you’re in some hut in the woods with no internet. something that you can just hand to someone else and then they can play (and you can’t) without any account shenanigans required.
And don’t believe the propaganda telling you it ain’t possible, because it already existed.
The condescension isn’t necessary. I grew up with cartridge based systems. We’re not in that time anymore, haven’t been for over a decade, and it will not come back no matter how loudly you yell at the clouds.
I stopped buying physical pc games as this was what was happening. I guess at least steam games came with a copy of the initial files so you didn’t have to download them.
Aren’t Switch cartridges basically memory cards? It’s nice because the games I have on cartridge don’t take much space on the console itself. Also, if it’s not read-only it means you can update it too
Imagine a multi disc AAA game now. Kinda makes me wonder what it even means to be AAA anymore, and what the future of that level of premium may be.
Like, is a linear story single player even capable of being considered a AAA game now? Does AAA just mean basically plus-ultra quality and features? Maybe it has to be multiplayer now. Or does it need to have a certain level of innovation, too?
AAA refers to the game’s budget, not necessarily its quality or type. And these days it looks like half that budget is marketing, so we could really do away with AAA altogether
Comments
Now I understand why everyone wants “physical games”. They think that means a fucking box and not the actual full content of an application. So Its a “physical copy” if you pay for a plastic case that holds a card with a number on it.
That to say, we will never see a “physical copy” anymore with any AAA titles since they’re too big to store on any consumer grade optical media.
This is just a bullshit excuse - we had tons of 4-disc games back in the day. And these days consumer grade bdxls can store up to 50-100gb. They just gain a lot by not selling physical, that’s it.
GTA 5 came on 7 DVDs for PC.
That’s absurd. Blueray was around for GTA5.
There is also an issue that playing a game from 5 disks was always a fucking hell of an experience, and the situation that one of the 5 disks stopped working randomly rendering the whole array a nice kilo of plastic waste. This can, obviously, fixed by removing DRM restrictions, but if we’re capable of that, what are we even doing then
Yeah, it was not without its drawbacks, but it’s still a feasible option ( if the goal was to provide something physical that’s not a goddamn code in a box ).
Feasible option to do what? I have kilos of plastic laying around somewhere, that used to be physical media containing games, but now it’s unplayable because either DRM doesn’t work anymore (hello, Denuvo), or the disk has deteriorated due to time or use, and it’s totally unusable despite me legally still “owning” a copy. Meanwhile, there are games that I bought digitally from GoG that I will be able to play as long as computers exist.
Owning a game has nothing to do with how did it get to you
That’s only because the people researching optical discs are part of the same massive tentacled corporation that ran the numbers and realized they’d make more money total by killing physical media.
There is also, you know, the limitation of the physical world. Whatever technology we have right now is such a marvel of science and engineering, it’s unbelievable how did we ever achieved this affront to nature. I don’t think we can expect that this can continue. Not that it can’t, humans are amazing at bending the reality, but we can’t expect it.
With aggregation-induced emission dye-doped photoresist, 1.25TB can fit on each layer of a disk, and 100 layers have been demonstrated on an actual disk. If, for some unfathomable reason, your game doesn’t fit into 125TB of storage, there are researchers working on a 200TB disk.
I know this is still expensive, and not mass-market, but… we have room before we run out of “the best that physics can possibly do”.
Like at the barest minimum even if we accept your argument, there’s still nothing stopping them just making laserdisc sized UHDs, there’s an instant 700Gb right there
Except for how utterly, criminally wasteful that would be.
careful, that high horse looks awfully precarious
I’m sorry. if a game can’t fit on a 50gb disc, I don’t want it.
K. Too bad a lot of games are bigger than that.
they are?
the biggest game I’ve got installed is like 12gb. guess I don’t play AAA games.
Or RPGs apparently.
Those easily go above 60 GB because of all the content and assets.
They really are these days. On my xbox ive got halo MCC and Forza. Theyre both like 110+GB. The games I enjoy most are 4GB tops though. Massive files are pretty much a turn off for me. Its too much of a commitment.
I think its because high resolution textures and other graphics and sound samples. People game on 4k screens now so I guess all that takes up a lot of space.
The actual game code must be tiny in comparison.
I’ll defend the technicality that most games aren’t playable solely off of disk these days, but yeah having a physical token of the ownership of a licence is fuckin invaluable apparently.
“Please swap to disk 44”
As far as I can tell Sony deliberately stopped research into optical discs ten years ago. UHD was launched in 2016 and can store 100Gb. GTA6 could have been a two-discer with a bit of judicious compression and trimming.
I miss installing most wanted off of 4 cds. Those were the days.
I got you beat… windows 98r2 was 30 floppies iirc
Damn, I was around for those days but never did it myself.
The disc itself is functionally useless. But the physical ownership aspect is easily replaced.
Just use a USB drive as the physical license token instead of the disc. No need to store the full game on it, just use a few MB of cheap Read-Only Memory.
Every game requires Day 1 patches to be playable anyway, so the disc never let you play the game on its own anyway, and after the install is only ever used as a license already. Why even pretend the game is actually there and useable?
Ok kid, let me tell you a story of how things used to be: we had disks, that contained everything the game needed to run. They even had drm, where the game would check if the disk is authentic or a copy. none of that required any additional download or online connection. If there was an update or patch, you would go to the developers website, download the installer for that patch and run it. as long as you kept that installer somewhere, you still didn’t need an online connection to install and play your game.
That’s what us old people want from a physical copy: some data storage device, that contains everything you need, even if you’re in some hut in the woods with no internet. something that you can just hand to someone else and then they can play (and you can’t) without any account shenanigans required.
And don’t believe the propaganda telling you it ain’t possible, because it already existed.
The condescension isn’t necessary. I grew up with cartridge based systems. We’re not in that time anymore, haven’t been for over a decade, and it will not come back no matter how loudly you yell at the clouds.
I stopped buying physical pc games as this was what was happening. I guess at least steam games came with a copy of the initial files so you didn’t have to download them.
It doesn’t have to be optical media. They could do like Nintendo and bring the cartridge back.
Aren’t Switch cartridges basically memory cards? It’s nice because the games I have on cartridge don’t take much space on the console itself. Also, if it’s not read-only it means you can update it too
They could put their games on SD cards.
Doubt there is a single game of more than a terabyte.
SD card is also quite expensive comparatively.
X-Plane with all DLC and the photorealistic textures is 1.2TB.
Just sell them on hard drives, easy.
Imagine a multi disc AAA game now. Kinda makes me wonder what it even means to be AAA anymore, and what the future of that level of premium may be.
Like, is a linear story single player even capable of being considered a AAA game now? Does AAA just mean basically plus-ultra quality and features? Maybe it has to be multiplayer now. Or does it need to have a certain level of innovation, too?
AAA refers to the game’s budget, not necessarily its quality or type. And these days it looks like half that budget is marketing, so we could really do away with AAA altogether
Sign in to comment. Sign in