Because there will always be more people on the main repo.
For example, KDE recently complained about the number of bugs slipping through the beta versions, caught only when it went to the public.
Manjaro capitalizes on that by waiting this “public discovery” phase out, and, in theory - shipping very stable builds tested not only by those in the testing repos, but by the larger Arch community.
To me, it’s a cool proposition. I can wait two weeks before getting the newest and shiniest things to get more stability and have major bugs caught by a huge community before it even lands to me.
Historically Manjaro delays basically ALL updates which includes security and bug fixes aswell
sometimes newer security and bugfix updates get fast tracked but typically only for popular software
That’s why I said “in theory”. In practice…eh, it’s poorly managed.
All in all, it takes a lot of organized maintainer effort to ship security patches ahead of full updates.
And Manjaro team is very ambitious doing it on Arch base.
Still, I like the premise of “bleeding edge, but not too much” and I do run OpenSUSE Slowroll (a distro with a similar idea, but more sensible update schedule, made by a trustworthy team) on one of my machines.
Comments
I don’t hate Manjaro (in spite of my bad personal experience), but I wish their manpower/attention went to upstream Arch instead.
If the pitch is further testing of packages for stability… why not just do it in Arch’s testing repos?
Because there will always be more people on the main repo.
For example, KDE recently complained about the number of bugs slipping through the beta versions, caught only when it went to the public.
Manjaro capitalizes on that by waiting this “public discovery” phase out, and, in theory - shipping very stable builds tested not only by those in the testing repos, but by the larger Arch community.
To me, it’s a cool proposition. I can wait two weeks before getting the newest and shiniest things to get more stability and have major bugs caught by a huge community before it even lands to me.
Historically Manjaro delays basically ALL updates which includes security and bug fixes aswell
sometimes newer security and bugfix updates get fast tracked but typically only for popular software
That’s why I said “in theory”. In practice…eh, it’s poorly managed.
All in all, it takes a lot of organized maintainer effort to ship security patches ahead of full updates.
And Manjaro team is very ambitious doing it on Arch base.
Still, I like the premise of “bleeding edge, but not too much” and I do run OpenSUSE Slowroll (a distro with a similar idea, but more sensible update schedule, made by a trustworthy team) on one of my machines.
Sign in to comment. Sign in