If America were to get Medicare for All, what happens to all the people in the insurance industry?
I read enough about politics that I should know something about this, but I’m drawing a blank.
Nobody cares what happens to the executives, but there are 700,000 to 900,000 people who would be out of a job. Overnight? And no, they can’t all go to work for the government. The transition period would be longer than most could afford and the government won’t need to replicate redundant roles from X number of companies. Am I wrong? Could Medicare absorb all these people?
Medical coding seems like it would survive mostly intact, but the rest? A few people could hang on at private companies if they evolve to be useful, additional insurance. Doesn’t the UK have private insurers like that?
Has this ever been addressed? Am I just dumb and completely missed any talk on the subject? Got to thinking about it because Medicare for All finally has a shot.
Comments
they get healthcare?
Don’t know but they’ll have healthcare.
They deal or get Luigi’d
They’ll just get different packages to pitch and different policies to enforce.
Italy, where I’m originally from, has an excellent public system, but there is still private insurance and private providers, it’s just something boutique used sometimes by rich people, or elderly middle class people who have conditions that need special care more often than the state can reliably provide (due to supply of specialized staff/infrastructure/what have you).
As long as you’re not creating a monopoly, the system at large, too, benefits from a public option (private insurance still makes plenty of money in Italy) it just shrinks market control, which means effort, which companies in an oligopoly don’t like.
The can finally go fuck themselves.
They never cared about me or my dying family members.
They can give BJs to hobos down at the train yard.
They get better than they deserve.
Nobody cares. If your job is to promote human suffering and death you find a different job. We need a revolution
The people who own everything are just going to make their own Sallie Mae where the biggest healthcare insurance provider(s) (they probably all merge for this to form a monopoly backed by the government, but for “efficiency” reasons) are the sole middlemen for a single payer system.
It’ll be fucking stupid, inefficient by design despite probably being branded as “private-public partnership efficiency” or some similar crock of horseshit. Insurers will continue to be parasites leeching off the middle, except now they have a monopoly and government mandate.
Thats what those vermin will do if they know they’re getting regulated. They just capture the regulations. Federal student loans work the same way with Sallie Mae issuing them, and the government enforcing their profitability. The government gets to say they provide access to education to anyone, and Sallie Mae gets to collect government protected rents their borrowers can’t ever get rid of unless they pay them back with interest.
Won’t someone think of the people who live off of exploiting the sick and the dying?
Private healthcare still exists in countries with national service, we have the choice of waiting and getting for free or paying and getting instant access.
Bernie Sanders’ current Medicare for All bill doesn’t deal with workers, bailouts would be a separate bill. He has a 4 year transitional period so the layoffs would take some time. Medical coding wouldn’t survive because hospitals won’t have per procedure billing, Medicare for All pays the hospital’s overall operating budget which is negotiated once a year and doesn’t involve itemizing each Tylenol.
Pramila Jayapal’s House bill does have a built-in bailout, and only a 2 year transition period. They would be able to spend about 30k a year on each of those 900k people for job training and preferential hiring for them at Medicare and at hospitals etc., and that worker transition period lasts 5 years.
Wow! Best answer in here and what I was asking!
Realistically universal healthcare doesn’t mean all healthcare is free. Some things will still need to go through insurance. For example, many countries don’t have social coverage for things like glasses or dental care or therapy. Maybe some kinds of drugs are covered but you want/need a variant that isn’t covered. So insurance doesn’t totally go away.
There would still be a reduction, of course. But at least hospital staff and family doctors won’t need to take time away from their patients to argue with insurance companies on the phone. And people working for insurance companies will at least have their health needs covered if they lose their jobs.
The health sector should also see an influx of new jobs available once more people go in for treatments and checkups.
Plus I think the job loss from insurance companies will be a drop in the bucket compared to what we’re seeing from AI implementation.
They’d have to find real jobs
They get decent health care.
Yes! Because it would no longer be tied to their employment! I’m certain that, as in many industries, some of them are doing soul-sucking work they hate just because they need the insurance coverage for themselves or a family member.
It’s been done before elsewhere and can do it again. Add up all the jobs lost in forgotten industries or due to automation, etc., it’s not new and they need to find other work over time. Some will retire, some will start new business, some will become artists and follow passions, which is somewhat more possible with the freedom of universal healthcare, so they benefit that way too!
Edit: Q: How have countries handled the decline of industries, like private insurance due to policy changes, ensuring workers transitioned to new jobs? This isn’t new, manufacturing, banking, and retail have faced similar disruptions, yet workers adapted with retraining and new economic opportunities.
I would imagine a percentage go work for the new unified provider.
It doesn’t have to be one provider. In Germany we have sozial health insurance, but several competing providers. In addition, private health insurance.
Competing providers is a good thing!
Rant about Germany specifically:
Mixed system of required and private health insurance is not the best example.
People with more money get private insurance instead of required, pay less and get better treatment. That shouldn’t be the case — treatment, queues, doctors shouldn’t depend on type of insurance you have.
Competition should be good, but the usa refuses to regulate in a way that allows the majority of people to benefit. I’ll accept some bureaucracy if the overall costs are cut by half.
One of the biggest issues with American healthcare is the inefficiency
A well run public healthcare system would require only a fraction of the people involved, at most levels
The average American physician spends the majority of their time doing paperwork. Private insurance is a nightmare
Many could be absorbed into Medicare which would need to expand staff. Many others could be absorbed into clinic/hospital staff, since more people would be seeing doctors and doctors would have more time for patients. Other can find similar bullshit jobs to what they were working. Maybe the rest can form a Robin Hood type organization who savagely beats everyone who profited under privatized healthcare until they give their money to charity. Billionaires too.
Most likely a lot of them would be laid off by their employers. My understanding is that private insurance wouldn’t go away, just people wouldn’t have to have it or die in poverty from a splinter. Some doctors may choose not to even accept single payer insurance and instead only treat people with private insurance.
It’s a sacrifice I’m willing to make.
In all seriousness though, it would be a good problem to have. Why is our healthcare money paying for all those middlemen? It’s a parasite industry that just needs to go.
I also don’t think there would be a huge problem. As you said, some of the same work would need to be done, but also the insurance industry is huge so perhaps some can move there
They will have to get jobs helping people instead of ripping off sick people
I grew up in coal/steel country and I knew more than a few older guys who were paid for job retraining when the steel mills closed. I’m not saying it’s the best idea but I think you couple that with paying to retrain people to work in the new system because it will still need people to administer the system.
Maybe, I’m no expert but it is something important to think about.
My dad took advantage if that when his tool and die shop closed down. He got a degree in social work and worked with mentally handicapped adults and loved it until he retired.
The work they are doing is not useful. They will have to learn how to do a useful thing. This is good because the world does not need people who operate a useless bureaucracy, but the world does need a lot of help in other ways.
They can go fuck themselves, genuinely.
I left healthcare. When j was looking to transition out I joined some forums and Facebook groups for people looking to get away from patient care. A lot of people were aiming for a specific type to insurance position (utilization reviewer) but I could never understand moving into that position because I never wanted to be part of that specific problem.
Sign in to comment. Sign in