I reject the books of traditions and think most of them were manipulated during the Umayyad and Abbasid eras and copied from Christianity and Judaism. I think there is ample evidence for the alteration of the religion following the death of Muhammad and think it’s a very different, more open and progressive religion when you reject the books of traditions. When you take the Quran alone you realize that the only important metric is belief in God and doing good deeds. Everything else is extraneous. The Quran repeatedly states that everyone is rewarded and can get to heaven, no matter what their religion is, as long as they do good deeds. But the mainstream traditionalists reject that on a very flimsy basis. The only thing that matters is good deeds, and one of the most commonly repeated phrases in the Quran is “those who believe and do good deeds”. The book exhorts us repeatedly to do good deeds and to ignore unbelievers, but this is the opposite of how traditional Islam has developed
Selam brother. What about daily praying and many other things not in the Quran but in those books you reject? I understand the suspicion but I think we should try to understand a Hadith before dismissing it. If an Hadith does not contradict Quran, fits into Islamic principles and also passes our own logical intuition then it should be safe to say that it’s right.
Would this be considered Shia or Sunni (or neither)? My understanding is that schism relates to the lineages of Imams and teachers that came after Mohammed, so do you just not care about any of that?
Sunnis generally believe that access to the word of Allah must come through an intermediary, an immam. Shias generally believe that each individual can be in direct contact with Allah. At least, this is my non-muslim white boy recollections of mainstream education on the subject. Kinda similar to the schism between Catholic and Protestant.
The Bible says something like “Wherever two or three individuals gather to speak of me, there I am among you.” Which seems reasonable too. I find it hard to believe an omniscient being would choose to be locked behind a paywall. That seems like a uniquely human invention.
Churches tend not to like the idea that a person can have god without having a church, for some reason…
Sunnis generally believe that access to the word of Allah must come through an intermediary, an immam. Shias generally believe that each individual can be in direct contact with Allah.
I do not think this is true. I think both have Imams/teachers. I was under the impression that the schism was political at the time, particularly having to do with which of the main teachers at the time was actually in Mohammad’s lineage.
If I’m remembering correctly, Shias don’t have a problem with Imams, they just believe they should be direct descendants of Mohammad.
It was more about who was taking over the religion after Mohammad’s death.
There’s also Sufism which includes mysticism and dancing and shit. Sufis, I believe, are the ones who believe in personal worship and direct communication with Allah (could be wrong about this). That worship often takes the form of singing and dancing.
Comments
I’m a Quranist Muslim, or Quran-only Muslim.
I reject the books of traditions and think most of them were manipulated during the Umayyad and Abbasid eras and copied from Christianity and Judaism. I think there is ample evidence for the alteration of the religion following the death of Muhammad and think it’s a very different, more open and progressive religion when you reject the books of traditions. When you take the Quran alone you realize that the only important metric is belief in God and doing good deeds. Everything else is extraneous. The Quran repeatedly states that everyone is rewarded and can get to heaven, no matter what their religion is, as long as they do good deeds. But the mainstream traditionalists reject that on a very flimsy basis. The only thing that matters is good deeds, and one of the most commonly repeated phrases in the Quran is “those who believe and do good deeds”. The book exhorts us repeatedly to do good deeds and to ignore unbelievers, but this is the opposite of how traditional Islam has developed
Selam brother. What about daily praying and many other things not in the Quran but in those books you reject? I understand the suspicion but I think we should try to understand a Hadith before dismissing it. If an Hadith does not contradict Quran, fits into Islamic principles and also passes our own logical intuition then it should be safe to say that it’s right.
Would this be considered Shia or Sunni (or neither)? My understanding is that schism relates to the lineages of Imams and teachers that came after Mohammed, so do you just not care about any of that?
Sunnis generally believe that access to the word of Allah must come through an intermediary, an immam. Shias generally believe that each individual can be in direct contact with Allah. At least, this is my non-muslim white boy recollections of mainstream education on the subject. Kinda similar to the schism between Catholic and Protestant.
The Bible says something like “Wherever two or three individuals gather to speak of me, there I am among you.” Which seems reasonable too. I find it hard to believe an omniscient being would choose to be locked behind a paywall. That seems like a uniquely human invention.
Churches tend not to like the idea that a person can have god without having a church, for some reason…
I do not think this is true. I think both have Imams/teachers. I was under the impression that the schism was political at the time, particularly having to do with which of the main teachers at the time was actually in Mohammad’s lineage.
If I’m remembering correctly, Shias don’t have a problem with Imams, they just believe they should be direct descendants of Mohammad.
It was more about who was taking over the religion after Mohammad’s death.
There’s also Sufism which includes mysticism and dancing and shit. Sufis, I believe, are the ones who believe in personal worship and direct communication with Allah (could be wrong about this). That worship often takes the form of singing and dancing.
Sign in to comment. Sign in