Skip to content

Comment on Where do you think humanity would be today if its technology had been used for the common good, rather than to create the neo-feudalism that U.S. capitalism inevitably leads to?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • I wouldn’t call it “US specific” in particular. Euro-colonial-capitalism led in many ways directly to the formation of the USA, which had a lot of ulterior motives relating nothing to the stated aims of ‘throwing off tyranny,’ ‘no taxation without representation’ and similar stuff.

    And much of Euro-colonial-capitalism (powered by Renaissance tech in many ways) can trace its roots to much older kingdom and empire-building, which can trace themselves directly to the Neolithic and Agricultural Revolutions, 12Kyrs ago.

    IMO you kind of have to rely on fantasy and sci-fi to imagine a picture of humanity that oddly didn’t behave like typical sapiens when it comes to such fantasy capitalism scenarios.

    24
    • @DandomRude@lemmy.worldOP· · edited

      I was referring to U.S. capitalism, since it is responsible for the vast majority of problems today: If not in the personified form of organized crime, as represented in all its depravity by the current U.S. regime, then certainly through the profiteers of this system in other countries, who are undermining democracy in order to create the same inhumane conditions as in the U.S. - one example of this would be Friedrich Merz, the Chancellor of Germany.

      Edit: What I mean by “U.S. capitalism” is the unregulated, unbridled capitalism in the tradition of the Chicago School, which is perhaps most prominently represented by neoliberal theorists such as Milton Friedman. It is precisely this anti-social tradition that has put forward the thesis -which has been disproved for decades - that there was such a thing as a “trickle-down economics” that would in any way be beneficial to the people.

      1
      • Well… I think you have some points there, but I also think you’re pushing way too hard to say that the U.S. is personally responsible for the root problems you speak of. In reality these are ancient problems, post-Ren problems and global problems, as I’ve already talked about.

        I will say this, though-- in modern history, specifically the past 200-250yrs, there is hardly any other situation in which you had a vast track of land such as the future USA, chock full of resources, which was so ripe for exploitation by a single nation, even if it was a toddler nation at first. I suppose Australia, Canada & parts of S.America probably come closest, but the USA out-lapped them easily, becoming the world’s GDP leader by the mid-to-late 1800’s IIRC.

        And for sure, all that land & resources more or less got treated by the local white capitalists as up for grabs, and not surprising that the nation’s history is so brutal and disastrous in so many ways. And of course, went on to become a local bully & meddler in countless other country’s affairs starting around the time of the Cuban War.

        Thing is, you could have sliced up N.America very differently, and I feel like globally, things would have gone much the same. All the things you complain about would still be in play, and the tyranny of neoliberal late-stage capitalism would still be an inevitability.

        1

Sign in to comment. Sign in