Defending Gabe Newell, Doom and Quake veteran Sandy Petersen says "with Steam he is literally guarding the gates of Hell" and protecting us from "parasites" like Disney, EA, and Microsoft
Tbf he has made long term investments in open source software that could decrease their company’s (and gamers’) reliance on Microsoft, that was pretty cool.
There’s a massive uptick in Gaben glazing last few weeks, spanning different platforms (including literal fucking YouTube yachting channels talking about how good he is for eating with the crew). He must be anticipating some sort of PR crisis that he’s trying to get ahead of.
As for “nothing”, the “nothing” he did to get where he is includes:
the original “tie physical copy of your game to an online store” controversy. The very same thing Sony and R* are catching flak for right now, Valve did in 2004. You couldn’t run HL2 without Steam. They managed to make physical copies of a game exclusive to an online store, so honestly I’d consider that almost worse than the EGS exclusive deals that Epic got a lot of hate for.
the smol issue of digital gambling for children
strongarming publishers (and indie devs) into ensuring Steam is the cheapest platform to buy their games on, while EGS takes less than half as much of a cut compared to Steam, which indie devs at least would probably like to translate into lower prices.
And even some of the things they’ve done, they were litigated or legislated into doing. The major one being their return policy.
Valve’s done a lot of good, too, but it’s essentially the same as when a billionaire gives a bunch of money to charity. Nice that they give some scraps away, but billionaires (and abusive companies) shouldn’t have been possible in the first place.
strongarming publishers (and indie devs) into ensuring Steam is the cheapest platform to buy their games on, while EGS takes less than half as much of a cut compared to Steam, which indie devs at least would probably like to translate into lower prices.
This is a misinterpretation of Steam’s rules, the only rule related to this is that you’re not allowed to sell Steam keys of your game on other platforms, for a lower price. You’re free to publish it outside of Steam for any price you’d like, provided that other platform also manages their own keys + distribution. And that’s a pretty generous deal already, since Steam does not get the 30% commission for Steam key sales on 3rd party platforms (they distribute Steam keys to the developer for free).
So if you’re already getting basically free distribution from Steam (which is pretty huge tbf), it stands to reason that Valve doesn’t want you to then also undercut their store while still using their distribution platform.
It’s perfectly allowed to say ask 60 euros on Steam but only 50 on EGS for example, since EGS does the distribution for those sales. But you can’t sell a Steam key on GOG for that price, you have to match Steam in that case.
I’m not talking about the rules that us plebs see, I’m talking about the reports that Valve has been telling publishers to fix their prices or gtfo. Rainbow Six Siege was the famous case from this year, they were given one day to fix their prices. But there have been reports of it for years now, they’re part of the ongoing class action against Valve. Shadow of War also got delisted because it was cheaper elsewhere.
This isn’t an official rule because that would be kinda illegal. But there are many reports of it being enforced by Valve.
No, those cases are actually about the exact same rules. But gaming journalism is generally shit so most articles omit the critical info.
In the R6S case, Ubisoft tried to pull a very scummy move. R6S is a free game, for exactly nothing you can get a Steam key granting “free access”, which doesn’t let you do all that much. On Steam, you could also purchase “DLC” allowing you to upgrade to the Standard/Elite/Ultimate editions, which grant more access to the actual game. On Uplay however, Ubisoft offered a special “starter” package for a much cheaper price, that granted access quite similar to the Standard edition.
This meant that the actual Steam key for the game is free, the DLC prices are equal, there’s just one DLC you couldn’t technically get on Steam. But in reality, free access offers you fairly little, and “upgrading” to a “normal” game was half the price in Uplay. It’s like offering a free car in two different stores, one of which provides all the service/maintenance/etc… where you can only buy a bejazzled car key, but over at the other store you can get a regular car key for half the price (which would still entitle you to all the service from the “expensive” store). This was simply a blatantly scummy move from Ubisoft and broke Valve’s ToS.
For Middle-Earth Shadow of War, the case was simpler. They offered pre-orders to the game, which would provide a Steam key, for much cheaper on an external retailer than they did on Steam itself, which also was just a blatant ToS violation.
The entire ToS can be found online on Steam’s partner pages and is quite clear in its language. It’s a clearly stated official rule, and it’s not illegal either. Ultimately Valve provides these keys for free to partners, even allowing developers to bypass commissions while still incurring all the hosting costs. This rule only applying to Steam keys is also evidenced by all the free games that EGS gives away, which aren’t free on Steam at the same time either: EGS supplies their own keys and does its own distribution, so Valve’s policy doesn’t apply and they don’t send in the lawyers.
The alternative to this policy is making Steam keys only purchaseable for some given price set by Valve, which would be an infinitely worse deal especially for indie devs.
Pretty sure the “nothing” refers to “what has he done lately to make the news” part. He just quietly sat there watching everyone else loudly upsetting their consumers.
Sweeney spewing out rubbish unprovoked, Sony making unpopular announcements, Nintendo sending cease and desist letters.
While Gabe said… exactly nothing. Valve released things that gamers want, while continuing doing the more questionable stuff in silence. They run a tight PR ship.
Look, nothing is perfect, but Steam being a private company run by a man who wants to offer a service instead of squeeze the quarterlies is the only thing keeping the entire storefront from shitting the bed into every deplorable practice we can imagine, and the only reason Tim Sweeny is so pissed off at Steam is because they can’t turn the screws on users on their own platform unless Steam plays ball and ALSO enshittifies. Valve and Steam and the restraint they exercise are LITERALLY the only thing keeping the barbarians outside the gates.
Runs a Rental Store (you may not own most games you purchase on Steam, or take those games elsewhere like offline)
No hard stances on AI or AI driven development (and I’m pro LLMs)
Steam has a good product and cornered a market that prior, didn’t even really exist. That’s it. They’re nonetheless a for profit business in a capitalistic society - money is still their bottom line.
Get the games you want to own through GoG or a platform in which you own your games and can take them offline. Steam cannot stay crisp forever and we shouldn’t be looking at any company through rose tinted glasses - let’s be real here.
I’d argue that this is an improvement over publicly traded ones, since it at least offers a chance of the owners caring about things other than just profit, as opposed to public companies that are obliged to generate “shareholder value” at any cost.
Of course, “potentially better than the most exploitative form of holding productive capacity hostage” isn’t exactly high praise. Valve does seem to be less actively hostile to its workers and customers than its biggest competitors, but that bar isn’t hard to clear, nor is it guaranteed to last.
The only thing I’ll actually credit them with is their contributions to gaming on Linux. Even if not every compatibility solution strictly leans on Proton, they’ve given the topic a measure of visibility that has eased a lot of players into the space.
But that still doesn’t make them saints. Don’t worship companies or executives, folks.
IMO, you weaken your argument against Valve by making it about capitalism. “Don’t hate the player, hate the game.”
I think that Valve is doing alright, all things considered. They aren’t a soulless publicly traded company, that puts maximizing profits over everything. They contribute to gaming on Linux and sell hackable gaming hardware. They managed to give that enough impulse, that many people could get rid of their Windows systems, or at least open that option to many.
On the other hand, they force game updates, not allowing the user to choose the version of the game they want to play. They are a closed platform, where their workshop content is more of less gated by owning the game on steam, not elsewhere. They are anti-competitive by setting this stuff up that way structurally. Their hardware only fully functions with Steam running, e.g. they don’t offer separate open source applications, and the community need to implement them, when they want to use their hardware without Steam. Etc.
However, being anticompetitive is what the market-leader under this system usually does. And the US isn’t really going after anticompetitive business practices, for as long as I lived. At least it they are US companies.
You can also raise the concern about what happens when Gabe passes, like who takes over? Do they share the same ideals? Will it get publicly traded?
Yes. I know. And that is the reason the argument for forcing everyone to update on game launch, or not being able to select a version in the UI, cannot be ‘because that saves storage’, or something. There is no technical reason, just that they enforce control.
It is purely an alignment issue. Steam is owned by those who work there. All those other companies are owned by shareholders whose goal is to extract as much value out of their shares as possible.
Credit where credit is due, Steam is the best platform and the sales have saved me all sorts of money. But
He’s still a billionaire and billionaires destabilize the economy for the rest of us. And many of them buy and dictate the legislation we live under.
He still abandoned the series that allowed him to create his empire and left his loyal fans on a massive cliffhanger that will never have a resolution. I know a lot of people on social media are young enough that the Half-Life series isn’t in their lexicon, so they don’t care, but us oldies still care and are still sore about it.
Valve famously has a flat management structure. Of course he has final say as the owner, but I guarantee he’s not preventing anyone from making HL3. If they wanted to make it, they would.
Essentially, what is the value of GabeN’s non-Valve-equity holdings? I don’t know the answer, but cash ≠ liquid. It wouldn’t surprise me if GabeN’s non-Valve holdings are worth more than a billion, but idk.
But the existence of billionaires are a taxation and regulation problem, imho, not so much up to individual billionaires to fix themselves. The problem is that unregulated capitalism is anathema to the fair distribution of wealth, and political corruption has allowed capitalists to successively remove regulations and taxes to enrich themselves at the expense of literally everyone else on the planet.
It’s hardly GabeN’s fault that he’s a billionaire. At least he treats his employees and customers well, by most accounts.
What do you expect him to do? Just pay more taxes for funsies?
So, what’s worse then: no new version or a new crappy version that destroys everything good about the originals?
Would you want a mobile Half-Life game with several in-game currencies and real money buyable loot boxes? There will be a golden crowbar that only starts dropping after you’ve spent $1000.
So, what’s worse then: no new version or a new crappy version that destroys everything good about the originals?
Why does it have to be no version or a crappy version? Why can’t it be a good version? And why would a new crappy version destroy everything good that already exists? It’s not like I’m going to uninstall HL or HL2 after having them on my hard drives for decades if HL3 sucked.
Literally today we got a series revamped after 13 years and early reviews are praising it as being one of the greatest games ever made.
This guy just added another yacht to his collection, bringing his total to seven, with one being a helipad yacht, and another being a dedicated medical yacht. He intends to ride out the Revolution at sea.
Counterargument: Nah nah he is a cool guy relatable gamer just like you and me! Isn’t that so nice? Shhhhhh we don’t need to bring up the whole “seven yachts” thing.
I’ll defend good business practices and attack bad ones.
Promoting gambling bad.
Investing in open source good.
Price of steam machine bad.
Regionalized pricing for the sake of poorer countries good.
On the low end for a billionaire. And he got that way because he has a good product and delivers on promises. Sure Steam has slop, but that’s unavoidable. It’s like expecting your Cadillac to stay pristine while you simultaneously use it as a daily driver. The road is dirty and so is the games business.
Half Life 3 not coming out is the prime example of a broader trend of Valve going from a company that made pretty innovative games to being a company that manages Steam.
It’s not that Steam is bad, specifically, but it’s an undeniable shame they stopped making games. We all gotta pay bills, I understand that sometimes you have to focus on what’s profitable. But it seems like Valve has plenty of money now, and could get back into making games on the side if the institutional will was there. That it isn’t is just… a little sad.
While there is no ethical way to obtain or poses a billion dollars in personal wealth, some billionaires have come to their wealth more honestly than most. Gabe N. is one of those billionaires. I hope when the guillotine does come out him and the other lesser billionaires voluntarily give up their hoards so we don’t have to take their heads.
Steam could be absolutely awful and it almost definitely will be as soon as Newell dies.
At the moment its just a store front that takes a bit too much money from the reseller, doesn’t give you a method of backing up games and the owner is some sort of libertarian billionaire.
I’m not one to attach the death of physical discs or the second hand market or the always-online and other shitty DRMs that came alongside steams rise. I personally believe those would have been there no matter what.
As I get older, I’ve gotten more and more anti-tech (or, at least, what tech has become). The capitalists can rip my analog collection and digital backups from my cold, dead hands.
Why do we just assume that everyone will go along with it though? Like, will you? I won’t. I’ll be going to shopfronts that respect me, or just supporting devs directly.
Sunk costs imho. Like I still have a PSN account for the games I’ve “purchased” on there, because I might want to download and spin them up again.
But I’m not buying anything new from them digitally anymore, because I know that Sony doesn’t respect me as a customer. I’m not going to feed that platform anymore than I must.
there’s no reason to assume it goes to shit when he dies, by all accounts valve has essentially been run by the chosen successors anyway for decades now. (gabe too busy yachting around ocean)
There’s a list of billionaires in order of who is most deserving. I regard him on the bottom tier of the list. If push comes to shove he’d probably liquidate his fortune. Same with the Laika Studios owner.
Or he could just… You know… Do it right now. But he won’t do that because despite all the positive emotional gerrymandering going on right now, he is still a capitalist.
Actually, I’d say he’s a better capitalist than all the other capitalists. And I don’t mean that as “he’s nicer”. No, as in, he’s better at capitalism.
He does the thing that capitalism always promises it’s supposed to tbe to the world, and surprise surprise it works better than that crap with investment and stock markets.
Yeah, you nailed it. The others are all about the idea of getting rich by IPO’ing, but he’s had the sense to look at his position, and go, why the fuck would I want to subject myself to that kind of oversight when I’ve already got this giant machine that directly feeds me 20-30% of all the money that gets spent on 75% of all PC games worldwide. And people are calling him a saint for it.
How solid are worker-owned co-ops legally? Can they be written so the co-op can’t be sold off?
According to Wikipedia, Valve has 336 employees. Let’s say Valve becomes a worker-owned co-op. But then let’s say Disney comes along and offers to give every last member of this worker-owned co-op $10 million if the co-op is sold. Can the co-op members vote to sell it, even if say a 2/3 majority is required?
I’m generally in favor of worker-owned co-ops. But with something like Steam, there are shareholders involved beyond just the corporate employees. Steam is almost a utility or a necessary public good. The video game market tends towards consolidation, and the general public has an interest in not seeing it enshittified.
I’m generally in favor of worker-owned co-ops. But I would only support switching Steam over now if it could somehow be written into the structure of the co-op that it cannot be sold. I’m fine with a worker-owned Steam running indefinitely. But I’m just as worried about a collective group of people selling out as one billionaire owner.
Let’s say you’re working at Valve. You’re looking at enough money for you and your children to never have to work again. Or look at in terms of time. Let’s say you’re 35 with two kids. Think of what time and attention you’ll be able to shift to your kids without the need to work anymore. Sure, not selling out for the good of a nation’s entertainment may have some noble virtue to it. But at the same time, your kids are only young once. And, for all the pride someone can take at working at a place like Valve, at the end of the day, it’s still a job. Employees still have to go in, do their jobs, answer to the demands of management, meet performance targets, etc. Imagine $10 million, and you can just walk away from all of that forever.
There is nobility in not selling out. But that is still one hell of a sacrifice to ask someone to make, all for the sake of our collective quality entertainment. I would be just as worried as a worker-owned co-op selling out by popular vote as I would a single billionaire selling out. Even if you think you would be the noble one to resist temptation…would your co-workers make the same choice?
In Poland we had a famous bottled water producer coop. “Muszynianka” pretty much the most popular brand, by all accounts a successful business. The workers decided to privatise it.
Steam is almost a utility or a necessary public good.
No, it’s not, and that’s part of the reason why it’s so hard to take people who are mad at Gabe seriously. He got rich off something that is an entirely optional part of life.
There is no scenario in which you can guarantee it won’t be sold off for the right price. Even if it were some kind of public utility, the wrong government could still choose to sell it off to the highest bidder. The best you can do is hope that the people who work there understand there’s no going back if they choose to sell and hope no one is willing to let Steam die for a quick pay-off.
In this case, “he’s still a capitalist” ultimately means something different now that he has more money than he could ever need for regular humans needs or wants for the rest of his life.
The main reason he’d want to retain control of Valve and Steam still is more to do with just that: control. He doesn’t meaningfully need more money for luxury. He only needs more money to further cement an effective domination over PC gaming. He likely views himself as a benevolent dictator (he basically is) and probably thinks if he handed over to a worker coop structure there would be a risk they’d sell or run the company in a way he disagrees with.
He means virtue-washing. You dilute a reasonable conviction (eg. There are no good Billionaires) by confusing the issue with their good decisions. Virtue and vice aren’t fungible. If you’re a good father, that doesn’t mean you’re not also a cold blooded murderer. Ask Martin Luther how he felt about paying for wicked indulgences by giving money to charity and the church.
“Emotional gerrymandering” is an awkward way to phrase it, but I can see where OP was going with it
Steam still engages in anti-competitive practices like most favored nation. Newell is still a billionaire. He deserves no worship. Is Steam better than EA? Yes. Is Steam anti-competitive? Undeniably. Support GOG when you can. Don’t suckle Newell’s ass.
The issue is that Steam, Valve, and Gabe were originally seen as evil. They have just stayed essentially the same as the world became more evil around them until they are now perceived as good.
Steam was seen as annoying and disliked because it was jank as fuck when it first rolled out. I do not remember a time Valve and Gabe Newell were ever seen as “evil”.
People reported it as “evil” for requiring an internet connection and for the DRM requirements. Additionally, similar concerns were raised regarding the requirements for steam to play half-life 2 as it was seen as menopolistic tactics.
That said, we probably frequented different online communities.
In the end, we found out just how much worse it could be from almost everyone that tried to compete with them. Though, it’s a bit sad that all it took was caring about your customers slightly more than just seeing them as recalcitrant piggy banks.
It makes me sad that we have other clearly superior platforms like GoG and Itch and others, that obviously aren’t as slick as Steam is currently, that get passed on by your average gamer because they aren’t the most dominant option.
My hope is that gamers realise that which platforms they support matters, and so they should always try to go for the option that respects them and gamedevs the most before any of the others.
I’m talking about the perception of Valve when I was 16. I’m 40 now. I fully support the work they put into Linux, and I have seen it. I fully support Steam and Valve. Humorously, I never had an issue with there practices because I wanted them to become more prominent out of fear of Microsoft when I was a script kiddie rascal.
How is valve being anti-competitive by providing better service? Is your argument going to be like Sweeney, that devs cant sell cheaper outside of steam? Valve doesn’t have to tolerate that imo. If people knew prices are always cheaper outside of steam this would hurt their platform. The hardware they sell pretty much allows users to run any program. I don’t think its fair to call them anti-competitive. Ofc GOG is better when it comes to DRM and ownership
How is Valve being anti-competitive by providing better service?
Whether Valve provides a better service is irrelevant to why they are anti-competitive.
Valve is anti-competitive because of its most favored nation clause.
Is your argument going to be … that devs can’t sell cheaper outside of Steam?
Humor me, and please read this.
Let’s take the example of Amazon, the delivery service.
Amazon has a most favored nation clause.
Amazon also takes a cut of vendor profits.
We’ll say, hypothetically, that the cut is ten percent.
Let’s say a vendor sells their product on Amazon.
They have to raise prices on Amazon to account for the cut of the profits.
Because their product has to be cheapest on Amazon, prices on every platform where they sell their product increase.
That is the first problem: most favored nation clauses are inflationary and cause price increases.
There is another, worse problem, however:
Amazon no longer has to compete with other businesses and prices on those platforms, because they are always cheapest.
Vendors flock to Amazon because they get more access to customers there.
So do consumers.
As more people move to Amazon because there is no longer a monetary benefit to using a different service, fewer services exist.
When fewer services exist, Amazon no longer has competition.
Amazon has created a monopoly.
Without competition, Amazon is free to raise its cut of the vendor profits.
As it does, neither vendors nor consumers have an alternative.
This causes an increase in prices and inflation.
Monopolies and anti-competitive practices like most favored nation are always worse for the consumer in the long run.
The hardware they sell pretty much allows users to run any program.
This is not relevant.
I don’t think it’s fair to call them anti-competitive.
Most favored nation clauses are a type of anti-competitive practice.
Valve, through Steam’s most favored nation clause, engages in anti-competitive practices.
Therefore, Valve is anti-competitive.
Ofc GOG is better when it comes to DRM and ownership.
You can sell games for less, you only can’t sell steam keys for less than you sell them for on steam. You can sell your game on gog or epic for $7 and for $10 on steam if you want to, you just can’t sell a steam key for $7, at least in theory. In practice, indie devs notoriously sell steam keys cheaper off of steam via bundles, forever discounts, bulk discounts and special deals with large key resellers on sites like g2a or kinguin. If this rule didn’t exist almost nobody would be buying games on the steam store and valve would still have to cover all the costs.
What’s funny is, Gaben isn’t some saint. He’s automatically one of the best billionaires* by just being normal and and not some morally bankrupt greed demon, because pretty much all the others are trying as hard as they can to run thenselves and the rest of the world into the ground for 0.1% higher profits.
* Don’t even bother commenting it, I know what you’re thinking. Best is relative.
It’s (often) measurable, but I would still call it subjective, since you can pick the criteria freely, which typically depends highly on the viewpoint. The best result for me might not be the best result for you and both might not be the best result for society, or the planet, and so on.
He is arguably what a normal gamer who genuinely cares about video games would be if they were suddenly a billionaire running the biggest PC gaming store front. Not a sociopath, but maintains typical levels of human greed.
Valve is great. They have made Linux a viable gaming option. This alone is huge as it gives gamers with choice for gaming options not riddled with ads and telemetry. Valve is active in the Linux kernel, KDE and Flatpak projects. They’re also making hardware, which is super cool.
Companies like EA, Activision, and Microsoft left the Valve store only to come crawling back. Besides these companies just want you to pay a monthly game pass or streaming fee.
GOG are good. FINALLY going to support Linux. But they’re just not the juggernaut that Valve is, that can force the hand of these other companies.
Will it all go to shit once Gabe Newell steps down as president of Valve? Perhaps. But they’ve pushed for some good stuff, like setting the standard for refunding of digital games and of course gaming on Linux, and lately sponsoring FEX bringing x86 gaming to ARM.
That said I buy my games on GOG whenever possible.
EDIT: Also, I can’t believe they made a movie about Facebook, “The Social Network” and even a sequel when Gaben’s story is much cooler. He was the Microsoft employee that lead the DOOM port to Windows 95 practically bringing about the DirectX dominance, death of OpenGL, which he later kind of have reversed what with the sponsoring of Khronos Group getting Vulkan off the ground.
Edit: they didn’t fuck around after though, like how after apple lost the 3rd party payment processor case, say okay you can use 3rd party but still have to pay us, resulting in going to court again. They actually made a reasonable policy.
Oh yeah, the work they’ve done to make games run on Linux is incredible. Of course they were motivated by the Steam Deck but still, Linux gaming is actually viable now because of them
I usually get games on steam when they’re available, then down the road I buy then on sale on gog to properly own them. The compatibility with steam is just so good
The steam workshop is pretty much undefeated for many games. It is nice being able to patch the DRM free binary for a game when needed which is a lot easier using the GOG version of course. Something which many script extenders for Bethesda games rely on to give an example.
Not really. Usually requires mucking about, also no cloud save sync, no one click install from Linux or steam deck or steam machine. Some games still require tweaks to make them work properly, sometimes issues with inputs and other things.
Saying this as someone who owns hundreds of games on gog and primarily games on Linux desktop and steam deck. Steam typically has a “just works” kinda deal
I’m using hardware from 2019. It’s not typically a hardware issue. I forget the last game I had an issue with but it really was “just works” via steam and a bunch of dicking around from gog. I ended up buying it also on steam because eit was 2$, and saved me effort.
It’s not always about compatibility, but the effort valve puts in to make things click and run and cloud save.
Nah, this is just what young-ones believe because they were born and became gamers already at a time when most ownership rights of gamers had been stripped away, mainly with the cooperation of Steam.
Back in the day you bought your game on a CD which had no phone-home DRM because the Internet wasn’t yet a thing and at most had DRM that locked it to the CD itself (so you could only play it with the CD on your machine’s CD drive), so you could install it in whenever and wherever you wanted, freely share playing it with your siblings, lending it to friends, sell it second-hand when you didn’t want to play it anymore, in some places you could even go to a library and loan a game and play it and then return it, and all of that was normal.
Before Steam PC games were like books, actual physical books.
When Steam came, it normalized phone-home control for games. To install the game from Steam you need to be on a machine connected to the Internet, running software from Steam and logged-in in to a specific account. Games were now linked to a specific person, many won’t run offline even though that’s not needed, most will only run offline for a while and then refuse to start because you’ve been offline too long and it can’t “validate your account”. You can’t lend a game you got from Steam, nor can you sell it second-hand once you’re not playing it anymore. With great hypocrisy Steam did “gave us” Family share, as if it’s some great favor and they hadn’t been the ones taking it away in the first place and the ability to return purchased games which we already had in places like Europe by law anyway.
As it rose and became established as a store Steam normalized a severe reduction of purchasing rights for gamers
Games with Steam are like Amazon DRM-wrapped eBooks.
Sure, Gabe did what Gabe had to do to become a billionaire, but lets not confuse it with him having decided that Steam would be as Steam is with all the tracking and stripping away of ownership rights of gamers because he had no other choice - he did it to make money for himself, same as every other grifter out there.
As GOG shows, it’s perfectly possible to have an online digital games store were you get most of the ownership rights that gamers had back in the 90s, the company that Gabe owns and fully controls doesn’t do offline installer downloads or even just have games without Phone Home DRM prominently labeled as such on their store (which isn’t even going as far as GOG) is because he does not want them to do it.
Only the profoundly ignorant would now lionize Gabe for screwing every PC gamer by taking away most of their ownership rights, many even before they were born.
Developers by no means have to bundle their steam games with their DRM, and even if they do it’s piss easy to break. Sure you can argue it shouldn’t be there, but by no means does it even come close to the god awful stuff like denuvo. Playing steam games offline is, 90% of the time, as easy as replacing a single dll and even then there’s programs that automate that process.
Sure mate, like Amazon eBooks with DRM, you can hack it easily enough and if you’re literally lucky with a purchase (as the Steam store most certainly does NOT inform you upfront about which have it and which don’t so you can’t make an informed purchasing decision, so its down to luck) it might even not have DRM at all.
Actually thinking about it, Amazon are less shitty with their eBooks because they’ll actually tell you upfront if you can get the eBook in an open format.
That “it’s not so bad: sometimes they don’t hold us as tight as they could” Stockholm Syndrome talk stands in stark contrast with what GOG shows us is possible for digital game sales to be and which is something Steam refuses to do.
What do you mean lucky? If it has something like Denuvo, it IS explicitly disclosed on the steam page. If it’s just steam DRM, it’s not about luck. It’s easy to break every time. With the same method. It’s just replacing a dll that makes it think Steam is open. And like I said, Steam doesn’t even require it. It’s a developer’s choice to include it.
They do that because it would be fundamentally impossible for them to get every PC game if they mandated it be DRM free, and that is basically the goal of Steam, be a storefront for every game. Its a big reason they’re having major issues with AI slop now.
They never would have gotten off the ground as an omni game store if they had mandated no-DRM. And if they decided to enforce such a rule now, a huge number of major developers would likely pull out of Steam in unison.
Maybe you think that’d be fine, but Valve wouldn’t and there are games with DRM that personally I’d like to play. Would I rather DRM not be there in the first place? Sure. But not having the ability to access the game at all or specifically not being able to access it via Steam, the undoubtedly best game service on earth is just a straight up negative.
There are games I’ve gotten for free that I ended up buying the steam copy on sale anyway just for the Steam features.
Think a bit of both, steam was REQUIRED to play half-life 2, which was one of the most anticipated releases that year, it secured a lot of people installed and registered to steam.
And also a bit of both, steam is the first layer of DRM, and game studios can have their own launchers, like total war series does, which acts as a second layer of DRM. Steam there to ensure your account has a valid licens for whatever your trying to launch
And yet Steam doesn’t tell you upfront before you buy which are which, so you cannot make an informed purchasing decision on the basis of how far your ownership rights of a game you’re thinking of buying go.
As shown when they added made with AI info, Steam could easily have that info in the game page if they wanted, they chose not to.
The most logical explanation for such a choice from Steam is that they do not want to lose sales because of some people refusing to buy DRM-wrapped games - in other words, they’re choosing profit maximization over treating gamers fairly, even the kind of gamer that comes here and harps all about how Steam isn’t all that bad because they don’t tighten the screws as much as they could.
DRM disclosure is a dev tied thing. Steam doesn’t inherently know what DRM is being used, and they don’t know that Steam DRM is tied into. I wouldn’t even call “Steam DRM” true DRM but I admit that’s a subjective interpretation on my part and others will obviously think differently.
That said, the AI disclosure is something the vast majority of users care about, whereas “does this check my steam account” isn’t something most would even think of.
Half-life 2 was huge, but they released it with Team Fortress 2 and Portal all in one bundle. People were really against the idea of steam, but all that for the price of one game was too much to turn down.
Whatever they lost in unrealized profits, selling 3 stand alone games for 1, has paid off bigger than any loss leader, get em in the door, in history.
If I remember it correctly, Steam was the first game store with their own app which gamers have to use to install the games they buy there (before that you could just download the game installer, and still today many indies selling directly just let you do it that way) and which provided themselves to developers in an easy to integrate API, phone-home DRM that controls if a gamer is authorized to start a game or no and refuses to start the game if they don’t.
As they grew and became the most successful PC digital game store, these practices became standard.
If a game uses Steam’s phone-home DRM then it’s Steam that enforces it via their own servers.
Games sold via Steam do not have to have that DRM, but Steam incentivizes developers to use the Steam API (which includes the DRM) plus it does NOT show in the game page in their store if a game has or not phone-home DRM so buyers can’t make informed purchasing decisions on that.
Note that games can still have their own DRM, with or without the Steam DRM in addition to it, something you sometimes see in AAA games.
forcing you choose, preventing you from running your own games on two separate machines … It’s a cold realization how much of a hold valve has on our games.
(100% agree with Gabe being the last bastion against the enshitification wave, the goodness given back to Linux, and how much worse it could be.)
Yep. PC and deck, perfect use case. Maybe I’m waiting for a load screen and want to try our a quick platformer. Or perhaps I am ‘double dipping’ when my kid wants to play spyro in the living room while I’m on Elite Dangerous.
The fact is, we used to be able to do this. Games were like books. You could lend them, swap them, rent them.
Steam is a wonderful convenience, but I’ve already almost forgotten what we used to have.
When that happens, I set one of my systems to “offline” mode, and keep playing. But I also rarely buy from Steam anymore because of shitty behaviour like this.
Comments
Why is the word “parasites” in quotes? Those companies are indeed parasites.
Thank you.
I want to run my business just like Gabe is running Steam!
From a yacht?
I would love to have the funds to run a business from a yacht
I wouldnt. This would for sure change me in a way that current me wouldnt like.
Why is there so much Gabe Newell hagiography right now? What did this guy do
Billionaires can buy their public perception. For example, people honestly think Bill Gates is a philanthropist.
Nothing and he still won
Tbf he has made long term investments in open source software that could decrease their company’s (and gamers’) reliance on Microsoft, that was pretty cool.
There’s a massive uptick in Gaben glazing last few weeks, spanning different platforms (including literal fucking YouTube yachting channels talking about how good he is for eating with the crew). He must be anticipating some sort of PR crisis that he’s trying to get ahead of.
As for “nothing”, the “nothing” he did to get where he is includes:
the original “tie physical copy of your game to an online store” controversy. The very same thing Sony and R* are catching flak for right now, Valve did in 2004. You couldn’t run HL2 without Steam. They managed to make physical copies of a game exclusive to an online store, so honestly I’d consider that almost worse than the EGS exclusive deals that Epic got a lot of hate for.
the smol issue of digital gambling for children
strongarming publishers (and indie devs) into ensuring Steam is the cheapest platform to buy their games on, while EGS takes less than half as much of a cut compared to Steam, which indie devs at least would probably like to translate into lower prices.
And even some of the things they’ve done, they were litigated or legislated into doing. The major one being their return policy.
Valve’s done a lot of good, too, but it’s essentially the same as when a billionaire gives a bunch of money to charity. Nice that they give some scraps away, but billionaires (and abusive companies) shouldn’t have been possible in the first place.
This is a misinterpretation of Steam’s rules, the only rule related to this is that you’re not allowed to sell Steam keys of your game on other platforms, for a lower price. You’re free to publish it outside of Steam for any price you’d like, provided that other platform also manages their own keys + distribution. And that’s a pretty generous deal already, since Steam does not get the 30% commission for Steam key sales on 3rd party platforms (they distribute Steam keys to the developer for free).
So if you’re already getting basically free distribution from Steam (which is pretty huge tbf), it stands to reason that Valve doesn’t want you to then also undercut their store while still using their distribution platform.
It’s perfectly allowed to say ask 60 euros on Steam but only 50 on EGS for example, since EGS does the distribution for those sales. But you can’t sell a Steam key on GOG for that price, you have to match Steam in that case.
I’m not talking about the rules that us plebs see, I’m talking about the reports that Valve has been telling publishers to fix their prices or gtfo. Rainbow Six Siege was the famous case from this year, they were given one day to fix their prices. But there have been reports of it for years now, they’re part of the ongoing class action against Valve. Shadow of War also got delisted because it was cheaper elsewhere.
This isn’t an official rule because that would be kinda illegal. But there are many reports of it being enforced by Valve.
No, those cases are actually about the exact same rules. But gaming journalism is generally shit so most articles omit the critical info.
In the R6S case, Ubisoft tried to pull a very scummy move. R6S is a free game, for exactly nothing you can get a Steam key granting “free access”, which doesn’t let you do all that much. On Steam, you could also purchase “DLC” allowing you to upgrade to the Standard/Elite/Ultimate editions, which grant more access to the actual game. On Uplay however, Ubisoft offered a special “starter” package for a much cheaper price, that granted access quite similar to the Standard edition.
This meant that the actual Steam key for the game is free, the DLC prices are equal, there’s just one DLC you couldn’t technically get on Steam. But in reality, free access offers you fairly little, and “upgrading” to a “normal” game was half the price in Uplay. It’s like offering a free car in two different stores, one of which provides all the service/maintenance/etc… where you can only buy a bejazzled car key, but over at the other store you can get a regular car key for half the price (which would still entitle you to all the service from the “expensive” store). This was simply a blatantly scummy move from Ubisoft and broke Valve’s ToS.
For Middle-Earth Shadow of War, the case was simpler. They offered pre-orders to the game, which would provide a Steam key, for much cheaper on an external retailer than they did on Steam itself, which also was just a blatant ToS violation.
The entire ToS can be found online on Steam’s partner pages and is quite clear in its language. It’s a clearly stated official rule, and it’s not illegal either. Ultimately Valve provides these keys for free to partners, even allowing developers to bypass commissions while still incurring all the hosting costs. This rule only applying to Steam keys is also evidenced by all the free games that EGS gives away, which aren’t free on Steam at the same time either: EGS supplies their own keys and does its own distribution, so Valve’s policy doesn’t apply and they don’t send in the lawyers.
The alternative to this policy is making Steam keys only purchaseable for some given price set by Valve, which would be an infinitely worse deal especially for indie devs.
Pretty sure the “nothing” refers to “what has he done lately to make the news” part. He just quietly sat there watching everyone else loudly upsetting their consumers.
Sweeney spewing out rubbish unprovoked, Sony making unpopular announcements, Nintendo sending cease and desist letters.
While Gabe said… exactly nothing. Valve released things that gamers want, while continuing doing the more questionable stuff in silence. They run a tight PR ship.
Means a lot, coming from a pioneer of game design like good 'ol Sandy.
Even if he did make Nirvana.
Look, nothing is perfect, but Steam being a private company run by a man who wants to offer a service instead of squeeze the quarterlies is the only thing keeping the entire storefront from shitting the bed into every deplorable practice we can imagine, and the only reason Tim Sweeny is so pissed off at Steam is because they can’t turn the screws on users on their own platform unless Steam plays ball and ALSO enshittifies. Valve and Steam and the restraint they exercise are LITERALLY the only thing keeping the barbarians outside the gates.
Until an exterminator comes along, it’s definitely good to support the roach that knows better than to let the rest of them touch the fridge or pantry
You do understand how sour you sound right?
I’ll take sour over complacent any day. All things considered, he’s as good as a tech CEO can possibly be
Steam has a good product and cornered a market that prior, didn’t even really exist. That’s it. They’re nonetheless a for profit business in a capitalistic society - money is still their bottom line.
Get the games you want to own through GoG or a platform in which you own your games and can take them offline. Steam cannot stay crisp forever and we shouldn’t be looking at any company through rose tinted glasses - let’s be real here.
Deff did not popularize child gambling, that’s been a thing for decades through things like trading cards but go off.
I’d argue that this is an improvement over publicly traded ones, since it at least offers a chance of the owners caring about things other than just profit, as opposed to public companies that are obliged to generate “shareholder value” at any cost.
Of course, “potentially better than the most exploitative form of holding productive capacity hostage” isn’t exactly high praise. Valve does seem to be less actively hostile to its workers and customers than its biggest competitors, but that bar isn’t hard to clear, nor is it guaranteed to last.
The only thing I’ll actually credit them with is their contributions to gaming on Linux. Even if not every compatibility solution strictly leans on Proton, they’ve given the topic a measure of visibility that has eased a lot of players into the space.
But that still doesn’t make them saints. Don’t worship companies or executives, folks.
Why would Steam, a game distributor, have a “hard stance” on AI?
I could switch to GOG if Steam starts to be more enshittifited (Thank god they never had a IPO)
YOU can switch, sure.
your existing games will never switch
your friends will probably never switch
Fair enough i guess
IMO, you weaken your argument against Valve by making it about capitalism. “Don’t hate the player, hate the game.”
I think that Valve is doing alright, all things considered. They aren’t a soulless publicly traded company, that puts maximizing profits over everything. They contribute to gaming on Linux and sell hackable gaming hardware. They managed to give that enough impulse, that many people could get rid of their Windows systems, or at least open that option to many.
On the other hand, they force game updates, not allowing the user to choose the version of the game they want to play. They are a closed platform, where their workshop content is more of less gated by owning the game on steam, not elsewhere. They are anti-competitive by setting this stuff up that way structurally. Their hardware only fully functions with Steam running, e.g. they don’t offer separate open source applications, and the community need to implement them, when they want to use their hardware without Steam. Etc.
However, being anticompetitive is what the market-leader under this system usually does. And the US isn’t really going after anticompetitive business practices, for as long as I lived. At least it they are US companies.
You can also raise the concern about what happens when Gabe passes, like who takes over? Do they share the same ideals? Will it get publicly traded?
you can download old versions of games from steam, its just that theres no gui for it
Yes. I know. And that is the reason the argument for forcing everyone to update on game launch, or not being able to select a version in the UI, cannot be ‘because that saves storage’, or something. There is no technical reason, just that they enforce control.
It is purely an alignment issue. Steam is owned by those who work there. All those other companies are owned by shareholders whose goal is to extract as much value out of their shares as possible.
Credit where credit is due, Steam is the best platform and the sales have saved me all sorts of money. But
He’s still a billionaire and billionaires destabilize the economy for the rest of us. And many of them buy and dictate the legislation we live under.
He still abandoned the series that allowed him to create his empire and left his loyal fans on a massive cliffhanger that will never have a resolution. I know a lot of people on social media are young enough that the Half-Life series isn’t in their lexicon, so they don’t care, but us oldies still care and are still sore about it.
He didn’t abandon the series, Valve did. It’s not like they want to make it and he’s stopping them from doing it.
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/29a6ae20-8194-46e0-8ac1-2575e1c09952.png
Valve famously has a flat management structure. Of course he has final say as the owner, but I guarantee he’s not preventing anyone from making HL3. If they wanted to make it, they would.
Is he like a billionaire on paper only though? Like he’d have to sell off part of valve/steam to actually be like a liquid billionaire.
There’s a big difference when you own something worth billions but don’t actually have it available to fuck the rest of the world
All billionaires are only billionaires on paper.
Parent poster said “liquid”, not “cash”.
Essentially, what is the value of GabeN’s non-Valve-equity holdings? I don’t know the answer, but cash ≠ liquid. It wouldn’t surprise me if GabeN’s non-Valve holdings are worth more than a billion, but idk.
But the existence of billionaires are a taxation and regulation problem, imho, not so much up to individual billionaires to fix themselves. The problem is that unregulated capitalism is anathema to the fair distribution of wealth, and political corruption has allowed capitalists to successively remove regulations and taxes to enrich themselves at the expense of literally everyone else on the planet.
It’s hardly GabeN’s fault that he’s a billionaire. At least he treats his employees and customers well, by most accounts.
What do you expect him to do? Just pay more taxes for funsies?
some have their assets diversified enough that they might be able to get a billion for them, others do not.
So, what’s worse then: no new version or a new crappy version that destroys everything good about the originals?
Would you want a mobile Half-Life game with several in-game currencies and real money buyable loot boxes? There will be a golden crowbar that only starts dropping after you’ve spent $1000.
Its still possible to make games without that bushit no one wants.
Why does it have to be no version or a crappy version? Why can’t it be a good version? And why would a new crappy version destroy everything good that already exists? It’s not like I’m going to uninstall HL or HL2 after having them on my hard drives for decades if HL3 sucked.
Literally today we got a series revamped after 13 years and early reviews are praising it as being one of the greatest games ever made.
The problem now is that it won’t likely reach the expectations and the longer it takes the higher those expectations could climb
Note to everyone…
Stop defending billionaires, it makes you look pathetic
This guy just added another yacht to his collection, bringing his total to seven, with one being a helipad yacht, and another being a dedicated medical yacht. He intends to ride out the Revolution at sea.
Counterargument: Nah nah he is a cool guy relatable gamer just like you and me! Isn’t that so nice? Shhhhhh we don’t need to bring up the whole “seven yachts” thing.
I’ll defend good business practices and attack bad ones. Promoting gambling bad. Investing in open source good. Price of steam machine bad. Regionalized pricing for the sake of poorer countries good.
Life is full of nuance.
Careful, some people will think your pathetic for having such options, because they’re so enlightened after all
Weird how these news stories come about what a nice guy he is and he treats his yacht crew well.
By the way, his net worth is $10 billion.
On the low end for a billionaire. And he got that way because he has a good product and delivers on promises. Sure Steam has slop, but that’s unavoidable. It’s like expecting your Cadillac to stay pristine while you simultaneously use it as a daily driver. The road is dirty and so is the games business.
[deleted]
Delivering on promises eh… half life… more than 2 ?
I know I shouldn’t judge him entirely on one piece of software that never saw daylight…but I’m feeling petty today and I will.
Half Life 3 not coming out is the prime example of a broader trend of Valve going from a company that made pretty innovative games to being a company that manages Steam.
It’s not that Steam is bad, specifically, but it’s an undeniable shame they stopped making games. We all gotta pay bills, I understand that sometimes you have to focus on what’s profitable. But it seems like Valve has plenty of money now, and could get back into making games on the side if the institutional will was there. That it isn’t is just… a little sad.
While there is no ethical way to obtain or poses a billion dollars in personal wealth, some billionaires have come to their wealth more honestly than most. Gabe N. is one of those billionaires. I hope when the guillotine does come out him and the other lesser billionaires voluntarily give up their hoards so we don’t have to take their heads.
Sir, this is America. We worship billionaires here, not chop their heads off.
Steam could be absolutely awful and it almost definitely will be as soon as Newell dies.
At the moment its just a store front that takes a bit too much money from the reseller, doesn’t give you a method of backing up games and the owner is some sort of libertarian billionaire.
I’m not one to attach the death of physical discs or the second hand market or the always-online and other shitty DRMs that came alongside steams rise. I personally believe those would have been there no matter what.
It will get so much worse.
Fuck it. I’ll go outside and touch some grass. This tech shit is starting to cause too much trouble. Like damn I can just do something else.
As I get older, I’ve gotten more and more anti-tech (or, at least, what tech has become). The capitalists can rip my analog collection and digital backups from my cold, dead hands.
Indeed. I have everything needed to self host now. Just wish I had nerd friends to play with so we could do it together.
Why do we just assume that everyone will go along with it though? Like, will you? I won’t. I’ll be going to shopfronts that respect me, or just supporting devs directly.
You don’t get to take your game library with you though, since you don’t actually own the games.
No. But it’s not hard to keep one legacy system for personal gaming use while migrating to another system.
Yep! Same as migrating from messenger to signal. Sure maybe you keep messenger for that one uncle, but you move away from it as your “main.”
Then one glorious day years hence you realise you haven’t used it in months and probably don’t even need to keep it around anymore.
Exactly.
Sunk costs imho. Like I still have a PSN account for the games I’ve “purchased” on there, because I might want to download and spin them up again.
But I’m not buying anything new from them digitally anymore, because I know that Sony doesn’t respect me as a customer. I’m not going to feed that platform anymore than I must.
That will still mean steam becomes worse
I mean it could. It could not. It probably will, you’re right. The point is it’s not ours, and the time to divest us before it enshittifies anymore.
there’s no reason to assume it goes to shit when he dies, by all accounts valve has essentially been run by the chosen successors anyway for decades now. (gabe too busy yachting around ocean)
There’s a list of billionaires in order of who is most deserving. I regard him on the bottom tier of the list. If push comes to shove he’d probably liquidate his fortune. Same with the Laika Studios owner.
Maybe Gabe Newell is less bad, but he is still a billionaire who profits from deplorable business practice (gambling/lootboxes).
I hope Gabe makes Valve a worker co-op when he passes. Its the only possibly way.
Or he could just… You know… Do it right now. But he won’t do that because despite all the positive emotional gerrymandering going on right now, he is still a capitalist.
Actually, I’d say he’s a better capitalist than all the other capitalists. And I don’t mean that as “he’s nicer”. No, as in, he’s better at capitalism.
He does the thing that capitalism always promises it’s supposed to tbe to the world, and surprise surprise it works better than that crap with investment and stock markets.
Fuck interest rates. Fuk those religions that allow it
Yeah, you nailed it. The others are all about the idea of getting rich by IPO’ing, but he’s had the sense to look at his position, and go, why the fuck would I want to subject myself to that kind of oversight when I’ve already got this giant machine that directly feeds me 20-30% of all the money that gets spent on 75% of all PC games worldwide. And people are calling him a saint for it.
Damn. I see your point and I’m astonished that I didn’t see it sooner.
How solid are worker-owned co-ops legally? Can they be written so the co-op can’t be sold off?
According to Wikipedia, Valve has 336 employees. Let’s say Valve becomes a worker-owned co-op. But then let’s say Disney comes along and offers to give every last member of this worker-owned co-op $10 million if the co-op is sold. Can the co-op members vote to sell it, even if say a 2/3 majority is required?
I’m generally in favor of worker-owned co-ops. But with something like Steam, there are shareholders involved beyond just the corporate employees. Steam is almost a utility or a necessary public good. The video game market tends towards consolidation, and the general public has an interest in not seeing it enshittified.
I’m generally in favor of worker-owned co-ops. But I would only support switching Steam over now if it could somehow be written into the structure of the co-op that it cannot be sold. I’m fine with a worker-owned Steam running indefinitely. But I’m just as worried about a collective group of people selling out as one billionaire owner.
Let’s say you’re working at Valve. You’re looking at enough money for you and your children to never have to work again. Or look at in terms of time. Let’s say you’re 35 with two kids. Think of what time and attention you’ll be able to shift to your kids without the need to work anymore. Sure, not selling out for the good of a nation’s entertainment may have some noble virtue to it. But at the same time, your kids are only young once. And, for all the pride someone can take at working at a place like Valve, at the end of the day, it’s still a job. Employees still have to go in, do their jobs, answer to the demands of management, meet performance targets, etc. Imagine $10 million, and you can just walk away from all of that forever.
There is nobility in not selling out. But that is still one hell of a sacrifice to ask someone to make, all for the sake of our collective quality entertainment. I would be just as worried as a worker-owned co-op selling out by popular vote as I would a single billionaire selling out. Even if you think you would be the noble one to resist temptation…would your co-workers make the same choice?
I worked for a company that went employee-owned when the CEO retired. They sold the company to another within a year.
I know most of them are still there five years on, so I guess it worked out for them.
In Poland we had a famous bottled water producer coop. “Muszynianka” pretty much the most popular brand, by all accounts a successful business. The workers decided to privatise it.
No, it’s not, and that’s part of the reason why it’s so hard to take people who are mad at Gabe seriously. He got rich off something that is an entirely optional part of life.
There is no scenario in which you can guarantee it won’t be sold off for the right price. Even if it were some kind of public utility, the wrong government could still choose to sell it off to the highest bidder. The best you can do is hope that the people who work there understand there’s no going back if they choose to sell and hope no one is willing to let Steam die for a quick pay-off.
There is a possibly better alternative.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bosch_Stiftung
In this case, “he’s still a capitalist” ultimately means something different now that he has more money than he could ever need for regular humans needs or wants for the rest of his life.
The main reason he’d want to retain control of Valve and Steam still is more to do with just that: control. He doesn’t meaningfully need more money for luxury. He only needs more money to further cement an effective domination over PC gaming. He likely views himself as a benevolent dictator (he basically is) and probably thinks if he handed over to a worker coop structure there would be a risk they’d sell or run the company in a way he disagrees with.
One can be a capitalist while alive, but not while dead. We’ve seen several reasonable examples.
lol, this is fascinating. how’s that work?
He means virtue-washing. You dilute a reasonable conviction (eg. There are no good Billionaires) by confusing the issue with their good decisions. Virtue and vice aren’t fungible. If you’re a good father, that doesn’t mean you’re not also a cold blooded murderer. Ask Martin Luther how he felt about paying for wicked indulgences by giving money to charity and the church.
“Emotional gerrymandering” is an awkward way to phrase it, but I can see where OP was going with it
Thank you for explaining the concept.
ty for the insight
Platform coop model makes more sense.
Sellers, consumers, and workers all get some share, with workers being the obvious majority share holders.
One person one vote on worker and consumer side. Sellers get some minority set of seats.
Steam still engages in anti-competitive practices like most favored nation. Newell is still a billionaire. He deserves no worship. Is Steam better than EA? Yes. Is Steam anti-competitive? Undeniably. Support GOG when you can. Don’t suckle Newell’s ass.
Steam could be way better, for sure.
Steam will get wayyy worse once Newell is gone, without a doubt
Who knows, maybe it will get even better and then we’ll be like wow that Gary guy sure was holding things back
The issue is that Steam, Valve, and Gabe were originally seen as evil. They have just stayed essentially the same as the world became more evil around them until they are now perceived as good.
Steam was seen as annoying and disliked because it was jank as fuck when it first rolled out. I do not remember a time Valve and Gabe Newell were ever seen as “evil”.
People reported it as “evil” for requiring an internet connection and for the DRM requirements. Additionally, similar concerns were raised regarding the requirements for steam to play half-life 2 as it was seen as menopolistic tactics.
That said, we probably frequented different online communities.
People don’t even remember that we used to have computers that weren’t hooked up to the internet.
Gaslighting or ignorance is one of the weirdest games I get the play as I get older.
Kids who don’t remember what absolutely bullshit Steam was from the start, basically.
The UX got better, but it’s still the same DRM platform bullshit that we raged against in the phpbb forums of the day.
In the end, we found out just how much worse it could be from almost everyone that tried to compete with them. Though, it’s a bit sad that all it took was caring about your customers slightly more than just seeing them as recalcitrant piggy banks.
Haha really well put.
It makes me sad that we have other clearly superior platforms like GoG and Itch and others, that obviously aren’t as slick as Steam is currently, that get passed on by your average gamer because they aren’t the most dominant option.
My hope is that gamers realise that which platforms they support matters, and so they should always try to go for the option that respects them and gamedevs the most before any of the others.
You haven’t seen the amazing amount of work they’ve put into Linux.
What a rude and arrogant thing to say…
I’m talking about the perception of Valve when I was 16. I’m 40 now. I fully support the work they put into Linux, and I have seen it. I fully support Steam and Valve. Humorously, I never had an issue with there practices because I wanted them to become more prominent out of fear of Microsoft when I was a script kiddie rascal.
How is valve being anti-competitive by providing better service? Is your argument going to be like Sweeney, that devs cant sell cheaper outside of steam? Valve doesn’t have to tolerate that imo. If people knew prices are always cheaper outside of steam this would hurt their platform. The hardware they sell pretty much allows users to run any program. I don’t think its fair to call them anti-competitive. Ofc GOG is better when it comes to DRM and ownership
Whether Valve provides a better service is irrelevant to why they are anti-competitive. Valve is anti-competitive because of its most favored nation clause.
Humor me, and please read this. Let’s take the example of Amazon, the delivery service.
Amazon has a most favored nation clause. Amazon also takes a cut of vendor profits. We’ll say, hypothetically, that the cut is ten percent.
Let’s say a vendor sells their product on Amazon. They have to raise prices on Amazon to account for the cut of the profits. Because their product has to be cheapest on Amazon, prices on every platform where they sell their product increase. That is the first problem: most favored nation clauses are inflationary and cause price increases.
There is another, worse problem, however: Amazon no longer has to compete with other businesses and prices on those platforms, because they are always cheapest. Vendors flock to Amazon because they get more access to customers there. So do consumers. As more people move to Amazon because there is no longer a monetary benefit to using a different service, fewer services exist. When fewer services exist, Amazon no longer has competition. Amazon has created a monopoly. Without competition, Amazon is free to raise its cut of the vendor profits. As it does, neither vendors nor consumers have an alternative. This causes an increase in prices and inflation.
Monopolies and anti-competitive practices like most favored nation are always worse for the consumer in the long run.
This is not relevant.
Most favored nation clauses are a type of anti-competitive practice. Valve, through Steam’s most favored nation clause, engages in anti-competitive practices. Therefore, Valve is anti-competitive.
Yes, I agree.
You can sell games for less, you only can’t sell steam keys for less than you sell them for on steam. You can sell your game on gog or epic for $7 and for $10 on steam if you want to, you just can’t sell a steam key for $7, at least in theory. In practice, indie devs notoriously sell steam keys cheaper off of steam via bundles, forever discounts, bulk discounts and special deals with large key resellers on sites like g2a or kinguin. If this rule didn’t exist almost nobody would be buying games on the steam store and valve would still have to cover all the costs.
He should start his own business school. He can call it Full Steam Ahead Academy.
What is with the sudden (past two days) of glazing astroturf about Gaben?
EA are doing a pretty decent job of protecting us from themselves by being giant shitbags and closing all of their best game studios
And selling out to Saudi Arabia
…Which the government is criticized for corruption
What’s funny is, Gaben isn’t some saint. He’s automatically one of the best billionaires* by just being normal and and not some morally bankrupt greed demon, because pretty much all the others are trying as hard as they can to run thenselves and the rest of the world into the ground for 0.1% higher profits.
* Don’t even bother commenting it, I know what you’re thinking. Best is relative.
My bar for public figures used to be you know, be a decent human, don’t do drugs publically, etc etc.
My bar is now JUST DON’T FUCK KIDS.
And yet that is often too much…
[deleted]
Next it will be: DON’T FUCK KIDS IN PUBLIC WHILE DOING DRUGS!!!
Some billionaires would see that as a challenge.
Whoa man why you gotta set the bar so high, at least be realistic
I know you said not to comment it, but clearly you knew that I was going to say that greed demon is my fetish.
Best is objective
Yeah, I was lucky enough to actually get the best friend and it’s really annoying that others try to claim they also have best friends.
It literally isn’t.
It’s (often) measurable, but I would still call it subjective, since you can pick the criteria freely, which typically depends highly on the viewpoint. The best result for me might not be the best result for you and both might not be the best result for society, or the planet, and so on.
I meant within the context of billionaires, not the definition of the word. And playing off OP’s closing sentence of best being subjective.
No it isn’t, what are you talking about?
There’s no such thing as a good billionaire, but he’s about as close as you’re gonna get.
so true
He is arguably what a normal gamer who genuinely cares about video games would be if they were suddenly a billionaire running the biggest PC gaming store front. Not a sociopath, but maintains typical levels of human greed.
Morally neutral billionaire.
Valve is great. They have made Linux a viable gaming option. This alone is huge as it gives gamers with choice for gaming options not riddled with ads and telemetry. Valve is active in the Linux kernel, KDE and Flatpak projects. They’re also making hardware, which is super cool.
Companies like EA, Activision, and Microsoft left the Valve store only to come crawling back. Besides these companies just want you to pay a monthly game pass or streaming fee.
GOG are good. FINALLY going to support Linux. But they’re just not the juggernaut that Valve is, that can force the hand of these other companies.
Will it all go to shit once Gabe Newell steps down as president of Valve? Perhaps. But they’ve pushed for some good stuff, like setting the standard for refunding of digital games and of course gaming on Linux, and lately sponsoring FEX bringing x86 gaming to ARM.
That said I buy my games on GOG whenever possible.
EDIT: Also, I can’t believe they made a movie about Facebook, “The Social Network” and even a sequel when Gaben’s story is much cooler. He was the Microsoft employee that lead the DOOM port to Windows 95 practically bringing about the DirectX dominance, death of OpenGL, which he later kind of have reversed what with the sponsoring of Khronos Group getting Vulkan off the ground.
They didn’t become the standard on refunds out of their own goodwill. They were forced by law to have a refund policy.
https://www.kitguru.net/gaming/matthew-wilson/valve-found-guilty-of-breaking-australian-law-with-old-refund-policy/
Edit: they didn’t fuck around after though, like how after apple lost the 3rd party payment processor case, say okay you can use 3rd party but still have to pay us, resulting in going to court again. They actually made a reasonable policy.
Good point, I wasn’t aware it came from an Australian law, but glad they rolled it out globally without any fuss like you said.
Oh ya and youre right they did it globally.
Apple still only gets rid of that fee where they lost the case.
Oh fuck, I didn’t realize he was a nerdy talent before he became the rich guy we know. Like if Woz got to control Apple instead of Jobs.
I wanna see that movie, lol
Oh yeah, the work they’ve done to make games run on Linux is incredible. Of course they were motivated by the Steam Deck but still, Linux gaming is actually viable now because of them
I usually get games on steam when they’re available, then down the road I buy then on sale on gog to properly own them. The compatibility with steam is just so good
The steam workshop is pretty much undefeated for many games. It is nice being able to patch the DRM free binary for a game when needed which is a lot easier using the GOG version of course. Something which many script extenders for Bethesda games rely on to give an example.
If software was well designed the store wouldn’t matter for that.
[deleted]
Not really. Usually requires mucking about, also no cloud save sync, no one click install from Linux or steam deck or steam machine. Some games still require tweaks to make them work properly, sometimes issues with inputs and other things.
Saying this as someone who owns hundreds of games on gog and primarily games on Linux desktop and steam deck. Steam typically has a “just works” kinda deal
[deleted]
I’m using hardware from 2019. It’s not typically a hardware issue. I forget the last game I had an issue with but it really was “just works” via steam and a bunch of dicking around from gog. I ended up buying it also on steam because eit was 2$, and saved me effort.
It’s not always about compatibility, but the effort valve puts in to make things click and run and cloud save.
[deleted]
Nah, this is just what young-ones believe because they were born and became gamers already at a time when most ownership rights of gamers had been stripped away, mainly with the cooperation of Steam.
Back in the day you bought your game on a CD which had no phone-home DRM because the Internet wasn’t yet a thing and at most had DRM that locked it to the CD itself (so you could only play it with the CD on your machine’s CD drive), so you could install it in whenever and wherever you wanted, freely share playing it with your siblings, lending it to friends, sell it second-hand when you didn’t want to play it anymore, in some places you could even go to a library and loan a game and play it and then return it, and all of that was normal.
Before Steam PC games were like books, actual physical books.
When Steam came, it normalized phone-home control for games. To install the game from Steam you need to be on a machine connected to the Internet, running software from Steam and logged-in in to a specific account. Games were now linked to a specific person, many won’t run offline even though that’s not needed, most will only run offline for a while and then refuse to start because you’ve been offline too long and it can’t “validate your account”. You can’t lend a game you got from Steam, nor can you sell it second-hand once you’re not playing it anymore. With great hypocrisy Steam did “gave us” Family share, as if it’s some great favor and they hadn’t been the ones taking it away in the first place and the ability to return purchased games which we already had in places like Europe by law anyway.
As it rose and became established as a store Steam normalized a severe reduction of purchasing rights for gamers
Games with Steam are like Amazon DRM-wrapped eBooks.
Sure, Gabe did what Gabe had to do to become a billionaire, but lets not confuse it with him having decided that Steam would be as Steam is with all the tracking and stripping away of ownership rights of gamers because he had no other choice - he did it to make money for himself, same as every other grifter out there.
As GOG shows, it’s perfectly possible to have an online digital games store were you get most of the ownership rights that gamers had back in the 90s, the company that Gabe owns and fully controls doesn’t do offline installer downloads or even just have games without Phone Home DRM prominently labeled as such on their store (which isn’t even going as far as GOG) is because he does not want them to do it.
Only the profoundly ignorant would now lionize Gabe for screwing every PC gamer by taking away most of their ownership rights, many even before they were born.
Developers by no means have to bundle their steam games with their DRM, and even if they do it’s piss easy to break. Sure you can argue it shouldn’t be there, but by no means does it even come close to the god awful stuff like denuvo. Playing steam games offline is, 90% of the time, as easy as replacing a single dll and even then there’s programs that automate that process.
Sure mate, like Amazon eBooks with DRM, you can hack it easily enough and if you’re literally lucky with a purchase (as the Steam store most certainly does NOT inform you upfront about which have it and which don’t so you can’t make an informed purchasing decision, so its down to luck) it might even not have DRM at all.
Actually thinking about it, Amazon are less shitty with their eBooks because they’ll actually tell you upfront if you can get the eBook in an open format.
That “it’s not so bad: sometimes they don’t hold us as tight as they could” Stockholm Syndrome talk stands in stark contrast with what GOG shows us is possible for digital game sales to be and which is something Steam refuses to do.
What do you mean lucky? If it has something like Denuvo, it IS explicitly disclosed on the steam page. If it’s just steam DRM, it’s not about luck. It’s easy to break every time. With the same method. It’s just replacing a dll that makes it think Steam is open. And like I said, Steam doesn’t even require it. It’s a developer’s choice to include it.
They do that because it would be fundamentally impossible for them to get every PC game if they mandated it be DRM free, and that is basically the goal of Steam, be a storefront for every game. Its a big reason they’re having major issues with AI slop now.
They never would have gotten off the ground as an omni game store if they had mandated no-DRM. And if they decided to enforce such a rule now, a huge number of major developers would likely pull out of Steam in unison.
Maybe you think that’d be fine, but Valve wouldn’t and there are games with DRM that personally I’d like to play. Would I rather DRM not be there in the first place? Sure. But not having the ability to access the game at all or specifically not being able to access it via Steam, the undoubtedly best game service on earth is just a straight up negative.
There are games I’ve gotten for free that I ended up buying the steam copy on sale anyway just for the Steam features.
Was steam really the first online store or were they just the first to succesfully capitalize on it?
Also, does steam enforce DRM or do game studios?
Think a bit of both, steam was REQUIRED to play half-life 2, which was one of the most anticipated releases that year, it secured a lot of people installed and registered to steam.
And also a bit of both, steam is the first layer of DRM, and game studios can have their own launchers, like total war series does, which acts as a second layer of DRM. Steam there to ensure your account has a valid licens for whatever your trying to launch
There are plenty of steam games you can just copy onto a thumb drive and play on a different PC without Steam.
And yet Steam doesn’t tell you upfront before you buy which are which, so you cannot make an informed purchasing decision on the basis of how far your ownership rights of a game you’re thinking of buying go.
As shown when they added made with AI info, Steam could easily have that info in the game page if they wanted, they chose not to.
The most logical explanation for such a choice from Steam is that they do not want to lose sales because of some people refusing to buy DRM-wrapped games - in other words, they’re choosing profit maximization over treating gamers fairly, even the kind of gamer that comes here and harps all about how Steam isn’t all that bad because they don’t tighten the screws as much as they could.
DRM disclosure is a dev tied thing. Steam doesn’t inherently know what DRM is being used, and they don’t know that Steam DRM is tied into. I wouldn’t even call “Steam DRM” true DRM but I admit that’s a subjective interpretation on my part and others will obviously think differently.
That said, the AI disclosure is something the vast majority of users care about, whereas “does this check my steam account” isn’t something most would even think of.
Half-life 2 was huge, but they released it with Team Fortress 2 and Portal all in one bundle. People were really against the idea of steam, but all that for the price of one game was too much to turn down.
Whatever they lost in unrealized profits, selling 3 stand alone games for 1, has paid off bigger than any loss leader, get em in the door, in history.
After the fact. The game was released on its own and then later included in The Orange Box with the other games.
Oh damn, thanks for the correction. It was so long ago I guess it just all ran together. It must have been that I personally held out till then.
Well, both steam and hl2 came out of valve, so it was an unsurprising dick move.
If I remember it correctly, Steam was the first game store with their own app which gamers have to use to install the games they buy there (before that you could just download the game installer, and still today many indies selling directly just let you do it that way) and which provided themselves to developers in an easy to integrate API, phone-home DRM that controls if a gamer is authorized to start a game or no and refuses to start the game if they don’t.
As they grew and became the most successful PC digital game store, these practices became standard.
If a game uses Steam’s phone-home DRM then it’s Steam that enforces it via their own servers.
Games sold via Steam do not have to have that DRM, but Steam incentivizes developers to use the Steam API (which includes the DRM) plus it does NOT show in the game page in their store if a game has or not phone-home DRM so buyers can’t make informed purchasing decisions on that.
Note that games can still have their own DRM, with or without the Steam DRM in addition to it, something you sometimes see in AAA games.
Ha… I was unaware they too DRMed stuff.
Drank the epic coolaid
The enemy you know.
Steam = old netflix
everything* else = disney+/paramount+/hbo+/hulu*etc.
*almost everything, matey
And they are in a temporary state before they go to shit also.
It’s all frictionless until you try to run two games you own at the same time. I know there is family sharing and all but when you get
This popup:
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/2af0cc6f-f4b4-479d-b31e-9ffc5e8c080e.webp
forcing you choose, preventing you from running your own games on two separate machines … It’s a cold realization how much of a hold valve has on our games.
(100% agree with Gabe being the last bastion against the enshitification wave, the goodness given back to Linux, and how much worse it could be.)
Does this happen to any other game?
I don’t get this error when I launch multiple games from the same account.
You get this error when one of the games being played has anti cheat. The anti cheat is causing this, not steam/valve.
No, this is a popup that occurs no matter what games you’re playing, speaking from experience.
I have played 2 games at 1 time on the same machine, speaking from experience.
Yeah, same machine is fine, that error occurs when you are trying to play on two different devices. My experience comes from my PC and my Deck.
Yep. PC and deck, perfect use case. Maybe I’m waiting for a load screen and want to try our a quick platformer. Or perhaps I am ‘double dipping’ when my kid wants to play spyro in the living room while I’m on Elite Dangerous.
The fact is, we used to be able to do this. Games were like books. You could lend them, swap them, rent them.
Steam is a wonderful convenience, but I’ve already almost forgotten what we used to have.
When that happens, I set one of my systems to “offline” mode, and keep playing. But I also rarely buy from Steam anymore because of shitty behaviour like this.
Sign in to comment. Sign in