Comment on Defending Gabe Newell, Doom and Quake veteran Sandy Petersen says "with Steam he is literally guarding the gates of Hell" and protecting us from "parasites" like Disney, EA, and Microsoft
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
DRM disclosure is a dev tied thing. Steam doesn’t inherently know what DRM is being used, and they don’t know that Steam DRM is tied into. I wouldn’t even call “Steam DRM” true DRM but I admit that’s a subjective interpretation on my part and others will obviously think differently.
That said, the AI disclosure is something the vast majority of users care about, whereas “does this check my steam account” isn’t something most would even think of.
Three points:
Again, you’re just engaging in Stockholm Syndrome kind of excuses for those who took away your freedom: “it would be too hard for them to do otherwise”, “it’s not really a big reduction of our rights, it’s small, minuscule even”, “most people wouldn’t even think about it” and so on.
Excuses, excuses, excuses and all just so that you can lionize a billionaire and the brand name he owns.
Unless steam runs every game that is uploaded and checks the local api access, no they aren’t going to be able to automatically disclose wether or not the game is DRMd to a steam api call. Those calls are 100% local, and do not require any sort of developer request. They can also be wholly ignored by the game if that call fails. Meaning steam legitimately doesn’t have a way to know if steam based DRm is being used.
Now, could they require the developer disclose that? Absolutely, and I agree they should. But to pretend it would be possible for them to auto disclose is silly.
Steam also didn’t care about AI use disclosure until the community made a big deal out of it, so they added it. If most users don’t care about steam DRM being used, like it or not, it’s likely not being added to their interface. It isn’t Stockholm Syndrome to point out why something is the way that it is, and why it’s not likely to be added.
You literally have no clue about how phone-home DRM works (hint: Steam API DRM calls the Steam servers) or the kind of contract developers and publishers have to sign to have their software listed in a major store (hint: the store will de-list your application and possibly withhold payments if you break that contract, so the contract just has to specify no DRM) and are just making shit up.
If GOG - a much smaller company - can manage it, Steam can too. It’s a problem of will, not a technical problem.
/sigh i was trying to be cordial.
Please explain how said steam DRM works on a fully offline machine if it needs to phone home to their servers in order to work. I’ll wait.
In reality, the client has a full list of games that the logged in account owns, and the “DRM” simply checks if the account logged in owns the game. It’s why the most common bypass for steam DRM with games that require steam for online play is to simply proxy the call and change the game ID to one that all accounts have access to. (Yes I am aware the other way is a full steam less DLL)
Cool, that has nothing to do with the original conversation, and feels like you just want to complain about the fact that Steam gives developers the ability to add DRM. Which is your prerogative, but has no bearing on the original discussion.
GOG’s whole thing is “no DRM”, steams is not. If you count, you’ll notice that GOG has a fraction of the games Steam has. And yes, so a certain extent that is market capture, but in many, many cases we are explicitly told it’s because of the fact that they would have to remove DRM.
You already have a solution to your problem, use GOG. If your issue is that a game isn’t on GOG, it’s likely because they want DRM. Go vote for the game you want on GOGs site.
Sign in to comment. Sign in