Skip to content

Comment on Defending Gabe Newell, Doom and Quake veteran Sandy Petersen says "with Steam he is literally guarding the gates of Hell" and protecting us from "parasites" like Disney, EA, and Microsoft

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Wrong analogy. Because cold and ebola have only negative impact. But we are talking about a human and a company, that is complex of good and bad. It’s not just “bad” vs “worse”.

    0
    • Market dominance and extracting rents is parasitic. That’s why I chose two viruses. He’s the lesser parasite protecting you from a bigger parasite in the original article’s argument. Is he offering a tool that is beneficial and doing some things you want with the money he extracts from that market position? Yeah sure. It doesn’t justify the system as it exists however. I could give a shit about lionizing the guy over it. Be like the early arguments about musk from the guys keen on space exploration and wanting electric cars. Doesn’t change base facts.

      0
      • You don’t choose to get a virus in exchange for something else. There is no contract with a virus. On Steam, you consciously choose to use it, to give money, because you get something back. It’s a decision you willingly made before you purchased it.

        I still think your comparison to explain or proof a point doesn’t hold here. Because with game stores and your personal choice is not like choosing between cold and ebola, because no one wants to have cold or ebola, as they offer nothing good in exchange for what you give. That’s why the analogy is out of place and misleading.

        -2
        • What pants on head liberal shit is this? The whole point of rent seeking though market dominance is maintaining a system where you don’t have choices. And that’s what valve does. They develop anticompetitive agreements and set market access and you’ve got no choice in the matter at all. Does that mean someone else wouldn’t come along and do the same exact things if they weren’t there? Absolutely not, they would because that’s what capitalism defaults to. But that doesn’t mean it’s somehow equitable because you’ve entered a free choice contract where you have exactly zero power. Steam isn’t your fucking collective bargaining agreement with the games industry lol.

          0
          • market dominance is maintaining a system where you don’t have choices. And that’s what valve does.

            Wrong. There are alternative stores where you can buy the game instead, you are not locked to Steam because Valve locks you down. You have a choice, it’s not a monopoly.

            They develop anticompetitive agreements and set market access

            They do not anti-competitive agreements or set market access.

            you’ve got no choice in the matter at all

            Yo got a choice. You can play videogames without Steam, by using Epic Games, GOG, itchio, League of Legends, Minecraft or Roblox in example. It’s an open platform where you can choose what to play and where.

            -1
            • If you fundamentally believe that they’re outcompeting in an open and functional capitalist market then there’s not anything I could say that would change your mind. The evidence that they’re not is trivial to discover and their pains to maintain that position are obvious.

              0
              Continue this thread 4 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in