Skip to content

Comment on Defending Gabe Newell, Doom and Quake veteran Sandy Petersen says "with Steam he is literally guarding the gates of Hell" and protecting us from "parasites" like Disney, EA, and Microsoft

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • 2, that’s not part of the definition at all.

    It is. All the alternative stores are viable options. That is the opposite of monopoly.

    3, you have to be as big as fucking Fortnite not to lose 90% of your customers.

    I don’t know if its true that the game needs to be this big to not lose 90% of the customers. But that is not the definition we are trying to find. You just gave me right that there are games out there that can happily exist without Steam, because Steam is not a monopoly.

    A real monopoly looks like one where there is no alternative like Apple Store, or one where games like Fortnite can’t exist if its not on the Google Playstore. That is how a real monopoly looks like.

    4, that’s just 2 again?

    Point 4 was more about that you can decide to buy elsewhere. Not that the option just exist, but its you, to decide.

    5, that’s technically also 2 again; exclusivity is not what defines a monopoly.

    No we talk about exclusivity. No 2 again. Exclusivity of games is a different topic than having alternative stores at your disposal.

    6 is 5 is 2.

    No. I am talking about the entire system, not just about the stores. I am talking about the hardware that Valve does not control, the operating system.

    Steam has super-duper-majority market share.

    What does that mean? Where can we look at market share numbers?

    That’s the only factor.

    That’s what the word means.

    No. See my previous reply. Monopoly is not just having huge market share.

    Monopoly doesn’t mean there’s no competition

    Monopoly literally means there is no competition. Otherwise it would be competition and not a monopoly.

    Not even Epic can get a foot in the door.

    Epic literally has Fortnite, and an entire store with many games and millions of users. And that is only one of the competitors on PC which the user can freely choose, because its not forced to use Steam only. Which invalidates any reasoning about why Steam would be a monopoly. How does GOG and itchio exist? They would be bankrupt by now, if everyone was using only one platform and never buy anything else from their “competitors”.

    Same reason Twitter still exists. The bulk of customers will not check other stores unless they are forced to. To them, for whatever reason, Steam is PC gaming.

    That’s irrelevant and not how monopoly is defined.

    1
    • Monopoly does not mean there’s no competition. Not even Standard Oil ever owned all of the oil.

      Monopoly is in fact just having a huge market share, to the point you are the market. Other competitors are irrelevant. Being on Epic will not save your game if you need ten times as many customers to break even. The vast majority of customers are just using Steam. If you want to reach them, you have to go through the one store that matters. One as in mono, store as in poly.

      -1
      • Wrong. According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly :

        A monopoly (from Greek μόνος, mónos, ‘single, alone’ and πωλεῖν, pōleîn, ‘to sell’) is a market in which one person or company is the only supplier of a particular good or service.[1] A monopoly is characterized by a lack of economic competition to produce a particular thing, a lack of viable substitute goods, and the possibility of a high monopoly price well above the seller’s marginal cost that leads to a high monopoly profit.[2] The verb monopolise or monopolize refers to the process by which a company gains the ability to raise prices or exclude competitors. In economics, a monopoly is a single seller. In law, a monopoly is a business entity that has significant market power, that is, the power to charge overly high prices, which is associated with unfair price raises.

        A monopoly may also have monopsony control of a sector of a market. A monopsony is a market situation in which there is only one buyer.

        The article continues with following points, which I will add a comment to each of them:

        A monopoly has at least one of these five characteristics:

        Profit maximizer: monopolists will choose the price or output to maximise profits at where MC=MR. This output will be somewhere over the price range, where demand is price elastic. If the total revenue is higher than total costs, the monopolists will make abnormal profits.

        Does not apply to Valve, as Valve and Steam does not control the price of the games.

        Price maker: Decides the price of the good or product to be sold, but does so by determining the quantity in order to demand the price desired by the firm.

        Valve does not control the market price, not in Steam, not elsewhere on the market on PC.

        High barriers to entry: Other sellers are unable to enter the market of the monopoly.

        No one prevents from entering the market on PC and create an alternative. In fact there are some other stores.

        Single seller: In a monopoly, there is one seller of the good, who produces all the output.[6] Therefore, the whole market is being served by a single company, and for practical purposes, the company is the same as the industry.

        Valve and Steam is not the single seller on the PC market. And therefore is not controlled by a single company.

        Price discrimination: A monopolist can change the price or quantity of the product. They sell higher quantities at a lower price in a very elastic market, and sell lower quantities at a higher price in a less elastic market.

        Using Steam is free of charge. For publishers, its basically negligible price to sell their products. Valve also does not discriminate price of other stores.


        Monopoly is not just the same same as dominating the market with a big market share (we don’t even have numbers for market share).

        1

Sign in to comment. Sign in