Comment on Defending Gabe Newell, Doom and Quake veteran Sandy Petersen says "with Steam he is literally guarding the gates of Hell" and protecting us from "parasites" like Disney, EA, and Microsoft
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
I never said this. I listed the points many times before. Looks like you don’t even read my replies. Again: Monopoly is not just about market share. Also how do you determine how much market share Valve has? No one was even talking about percentage here. Read my comments again carefully. I said Valve has market dominance. But that is not all it takes to have a monopoly. And I listed many reasons in my replies.
If you are not willing to read, then this discussion ends here.
“A real monopoly looks like one where there is no alternative like Apple Store, or one where games like Fortnite can’t exist if its not on the Google Playstore. That is how a real monopoly looks like.”
I read what you wrote an hour ago and need you to address it like you meant it. Otherwish this is a Gish gallop.
I need to know you’re capable of acknowledging when a claim was mistaken, before I bother writing a wall of text dealing with every other claim. Is insisting you never said it the same as saying you no longer believe it?
Then what do you mean by “can’t exist?”
What are we doing here?
Edit: Because it seems unclear: Google and Apple control the operating system, mechanics how to install alternative software and stores and control the only relevant market where games are sold on Android and iOS. That is not the case how it works on PC and Steam.
“The only relevant market” is the argument in miniature. The case on PC is that there’s Steam, and other. It’s not quite as dire as Play versus F-Droid, but it doesn’t have to be, for one company to decide how the market works.
Steam didn’t allow NFTs, thankfully, and that just about single-handedly killed the concept. But they sure allowed lootboxes. And unless I missed something, they haven’t allowed resale. All of these decisions shape how the overwhelming majority of users experience PC gaming. That’s just what PC gaming is, to most PC gamers. You can get a couple modern games on GOG. You can get more on Epic… but realistically, you won’t. There’s only one store that matters. We have a word for that.
I’m trying to figure out what you think you’re saying when I say monopoly doesn’t mean there’s no competition and you say “Wrong.”
Mutual understanding of this fairly simple topic will not be reached through verbose exchanges of nitpicky lists. Nor through quoting one word as if that clarifies how Apple’s absolute control and Google’s very Steam-like supermajority are both monopolies, but Steam somehow isn’t.
Google Play has competitors. They don’t matter. Is that a monopoly, yes or no?
In what manner can Fortnite ‘not exist’ on Android, if you’re not just saying they’d struggle to find customers outside the big store everybody chooses to rely on?
Sign in to comment. Sign in