Skip to content

Comment on Defending Gabe Newell, Doom and Quake veteran Sandy Petersen says "with Steam he is literally guarding the gates of Hell" and protecting us from "parasites" like Disney, EA, and Microsoft

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Was steam really the first online store or were they just the first to succesfully capitalize on it?

    Also, does steam enforce DRM or do game studios?

    7
    • Think a bit of both, steam was REQUIRED to play half-life 2, which was one of the most anticipated releases that year, it secured a lot of people installed and registered to steam.

      And also a bit of both, steam is the first layer of DRM, and game studios can have their own launchers, like total war series does, which acts as a second layer of DRM. Steam there to ensure your account has a valid licens for whatever your trying to launch

      5
      • There are plenty of steam games you can just copy onto a thumb drive and play on a different PC without Steam.

        4
        • And yet Steam doesn’t tell you upfront before you buy which are which, so you cannot make an informed purchasing decision on the basis of how far your ownership rights of a game you’re thinking of buying go.

          As shown when they added made with AI info, Steam could easily have that info in the game page if they wanted, they chose not to.

          The most logical explanation for such a choice from Steam is that they do not want to lose sales because of some people refusing to buy DRM-wrapped games - in other words, they’re choosing profit maximization over treating gamers fairly, even the kind of gamer that comes here and harps all about how Steam isn’t all that bad because they don’t tighten the screws as much as they could.

          3
          • DRM disclosure is a dev tied thing. Steam doesn’t inherently know what DRM is being used, and they don’t know that Steam DRM is tied into. I wouldn’t even call “Steam DRM” true DRM but I admit that’s a subjective interpretation on my part and others will obviously think differently.

            That said, the AI disclosure is something the vast majority of users care about, whereas “does this check my steam account” isn’t something most would even think of.

            0
            • Three points:

              • Steam knows perfectly well when a game is using phone-home functionality of the Steam API. Its disclosure is not a “dev tied thing”.
              • AI disclosure too is a dev tied thing. Steam still added it, but chose not to do DRM disclosure, which as I pointed above can even be done automatically with some games.
              • It’s not up to YOU, nor is it up to Steam to mislabel caring about game ownership rights as “does this check my steam account”, or decide for others that they don’t need it because according to you it “isn’t something most would even think of”. If such a non-issue, why is DRM disclosure not there? Your argument is circular.

              Again, you’re just engaging in Stockholm Syndrome kind of excuses for those who took away your freedom: “it would be too hard for them to do otherwise”, “it’s not really a big reduction of our rights, it’s small, minuscule even”, “most people wouldn’t even think about it” and so on.

              Excuses, excuses, excuses and all just so that you can lionize a billionaire and the brand name he owns.

              -1
              Continue this thread 3 more replies
      • Half-life 2 was huge, but they released it with Team Fortress 2 and Portal all in one bundle. People were really against the idea of steam, but all that for the price of one game was too much to turn down.

        Whatever they lost in unrealized profits, selling 3 stand alone games for 1, has paid off bigger than any loss leader, get em in the door, in history.

        1
        • Half-life 2 was huge, but they released it with Team Fortress 2 and Portal all in one bundle

          After the fact. The game was released on its own and then later included in The Orange Box with the other games.

          2
          • Oh damn, thanks for the correction. It was so long ago I guess it just all ran together. It must have been that I personally held out till then.

            2
      • Well, both steam and hl2 came out of valve, so it was an unsurprising dick move.

        0
    • If I remember it correctly, Steam was the first game store with their own app which gamers have to use to install the games they buy there (before that you could just download the game installer, and still today many indies selling directly just let you do it that way) and which provided themselves to developers in an easy to integrate API, phone-home DRM that controls if a gamer is authorized to start a game or no and refuses to start the game if they don’t.

      As they grew and became the most successful PC digital game store, these practices became standard.

      If a game uses Steam’s phone-home DRM then it’s Steam that enforces it via their own servers.

      Games sold via Steam do not have to have that DRM, but Steam incentivizes developers to use the Steam API (which includes the DRM) plus it does NOT show in the game page in their store if a game has or not phone-home DRM so buyers can’t make informed purchasing decisions on that.

      Note that games can still have their own DRM, with or without the Steam DRM in addition to it, something you sometimes see in AAA games.

      2

Sign in to comment. Sign in