Comment on Defending Gabe Newell, Doom and Quake veteran Sandy Petersen says "with Steam he is literally guarding the gates of Hell" and protecting us from "parasites" like Disney, EA, and Microsoft
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
IMO, you weaken your argument against Valve by making it about capitalism. “Don’t hate the player, hate the game.”
I think that Valve is doing alright, all things considered. They aren’t a soulless publicly traded company, that puts maximizing profits over everything. They contribute to gaming on Linux and sell hackable gaming hardware. They managed to give that enough impulse, that many people could get rid of their Windows systems, or at least open that option to many.
On the other hand, they force game updates, not allowing the user to choose the version of the game they want to play. They are a closed platform, where their workshop content is more of less gated by owning the game on steam, not elsewhere. They are anti-competitive by setting this stuff up that way structurally. Their hardware only fully functions with Steam running, e.g. they don’t offer separate open source applications, and the community need to implement them, when they want to use their hardware without Steam. Etc.
However, being anticompetitive is what the market-leader under this system usually does. And the US isn’t really going after anticompetitive business practices, for as long as I lived. At least it they are US companies.
You can also raise the concern about what happens when Gabe passes, like who takes over? Do they share the same ideals? Will it get publicly traded?
you can download old versions of games from steam, its just that theres no gui for it
Yes. I know. And that is the reason the argument for forcing everyone to update on game launch, or not being able to select a version in the UI, cannot be ‘because that saves storage’, or something. There is no technical reason, just that they enforce control.
Sign in to comment. Sign in