Skip to content

Comment on Defending Gabe Newell, Doom and Quake veteran Sandy Petersen says "with Steam he is literally guarding the gates of Hell" and protecting us from "parasites" like Disney, EA, and Microsoft

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Nothing and he still won

    -1
    • Tbf he has made long term investments in open source software that could decrease their company’s (and gamers’) reliance on Microsoft, that was pretty cool.

      11
    • There’s a massive uptick in Gaben glazing last few weeks, spanning different platforms (including literal fucking YouTube yachting channels talking about how good he is for eating with the crew). He must be anticipating some sort of PR crisis that he’s trying to get ahead of.

      As for “nothing”, the “nothing” he did to get where he is includes:

      • the original “tie physical copy of your game to an online store” controversy. The very same thing Sony and R* are catching flak for right now, Valve did in 2004. You couldn’t run HL2 without Steam. They managed to make physical copies of a game exclusive to an online store, so honestly I’d consider that almost worse than the EGS exclusive deals that Epic got a lot of hate for.

      • the smol issue of digital gambling for children

      • strongarming publishers (and indie devs) into ensuring Steam is the cheapest platform to buy their games on, while EGS takes less than half as much of a cut compared to Steam, which indie devs at least would probably like to translate into lower prices.

      And even some of the things they’ve done, they were litigated or legislated into doing. The major one being their return policy.

      Valve’s done a lot of good, too, but it’s essentially the same as when a billionaire gives a bunch of money to charity. Nice that they give some scraps away, but billionaires (and abusive companies) shouldn’t have been possible in the first place.

      6
        • strongarming publishers (and indie devs) into ensuring Steam is the cheapest platform to buy their games on, while EGS takes less than half as much of a cut compared to Steam, which indie devs at least would probably like to translate into lower prices.

        This is a misinterpretation of Steam’s rules, the only rule related to this is that you’re not allowed to sell Steam keys of your game on other platforms, for a lower price. You’re free to publish it outside of Steam for any price you’d like, provided that other platform also manages their own keys + distribution. And that’s a pretty generous deal already, since Steam does not get the 30% commission for Steam key sales on 3rd party platforms (they distribute Steam keys to the developer for free).

        So if you’re already getting basically free distribution from Steam (which is pretty huge tbf), it stands to reason that Valve doesn’t want you to then also undercut their store while still using their distribution platform.

        It’s perfectly allowed to say ask 60 euros on Steam but only 50 on EGS for example, since EGS does the distribution for those sales. But you can’t sell a Steam key on GOG for that price, you have to match Steam in that case.

        4
        • I’m not talking about the rules that us plebs see, I’m talking about the reports that Valve has been telling publishers to fix their prices or gtfo. Rainbow Six Siege was the famous case from this year, they were given one day to fix their prices. But there have been reports of it for years now, they’re part of the ongoing class action against Valve. Shadow of War also got delisted because it was cheaper elsewhere.

          This isn’t an official rule because that would be kinda illegal. But there are many reports of it being enforced by Valve.

          1
          • No, those cases are actually about the exact same rules. But gaming journalism is generally shit so most articles omit the critical info.

            In the R6S case, Ubisoft tried to pull a very scummy move. R6S is a free game, for exactly nothing you can get a Steam key granting “free access”, which doesn’t let you do all that much. On Steam, you could also purchase “DLC” allowing you to upgrade to the Standard/Elite/Ultimate editions, which grant more access to the actual game. On Uplay however, Ubisoft offered a special “starter” package for a much cheaper price, that granted access quite similar to the Standard edition.

            This meant that the actual Steam key for the game is free, the DLC prices are equal, there’s just one DLC you couldn’t technically get on Steam. But in reality, free access offers you fairly little, and “upgrading” to a “normal” game was half the price in Uplay. It’s like offering a free car in two different stores, one of which provides all the service/maintenance/etc… where you can only buy a bejazzled car key, but over at the other store you can get a regular car key for half the price (which would still entitle you to all the service from the “expensive” store). This was simply a blatantly scummy move from Ubisoft and broke Valve’s ToS.

            For Middle-Earth Shadow of War, the case was simpler. They offered pre-orders to the game, which would provide a Steam key, for much cheaper on an external retailer than they did on Steam itself, which also was just a blatant ToS violation.

            The entire ToS can be found online on Steam’s partner pages and is quite clear in its language. It’s a clearly stated official rule, and it’s not illegal either. Ultimately Valve provides these keys for free to partners, even allowing developers to bypass commissions while still incurring all the hosting costs. This rule only applying to Steam keys is also evidenced by all the free games that EGS gives away, which aren’t free on Steam at the same time either: EGS supplies their own keys and does its own distribution, so Valve’s policy doesn’t apply and they don’t send in the lawyers.

            The alternative to this policy is making Steam keys only purchaseable for some given price set by Valve, which would be an infinitely worse deal especially for indie devs.

            1
      • Pretty sure the “nothing” refers to “what has he done lately to make the news” part. He just quietly sat there watching everyone else loudly upsetting their consumers.

        Sweeney spewing out rubbish unprovoked, Sony making unpopular announcements, Nintendo sending cease and desist letters.

        While Gabe said… exactly nothing. Valve released things that gamers want, while continuing doing the more questionable stuff in silence. They run a tight PR ship.

        1

Sign in to comment. Sign in