Skip to content

Comment on I'll never forget how badly the term "AI" nosedived into being uncool

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • Except LLMs aren’t AI. There’s zero intelligence. We should normalize not calling things that lack intelligence AI.

    22
    • You may be using a different definition of “intelligence” than artificial intelligence researchers do

      38
    • There is intelligence though, just not most of the pieces we associate with human like intelligence.

      As a precursor: a simple air conditioner has enough capability to fit most criteria. A basic history and a clock makes is fit a lot more.
      I’m not arguing that LLM are more than they are, rather that the floor is lower than most people think.

      The air conditioner can measure the value of a probe, compare it to a set point, and control a compressor with the result. Give it a basic memory and a clock and it can start making changes before the difference grows. A little more and we can make it improve the quality of that correction over time.
      This is a smart system. It acts intelligently. It has no sapience, reasoning, or any qualities we would associate with a smart creature.

      Intelligence in the context of AI purely means that the system handles tasks previously relegated to intelligent beings, not that the system is itself a being of any sort.
      Things like spell check are early AI. Measuring a set of values, comparing to a table of knowns and picking a weighted blend is another, like you find in rice cookers and washing machines.
      You don’t have to think as hard because it’s taking care of it for you.

      The LLM is predicting the next symbol in a sequence. It’s able to feed that back into itself to produce longer sequences, and can use that sequence to save portions of the sequence to propagate to later inputs to better adapt the next sequence of generated content.
      It’s not reasoning, or feeling, or even thinking. But none of those are required for a system to be intelligent.

      13
      • Exactly. Even OCR used to be AI many decades ago. Nowadays, you can grab text from a photo using OCR, but this isn’t the kind of AI people love to complain about. When the camera finds a face and automatically focuses on it, that’s AI again.

        The floor is very low indeed. A thermostat isn’t intelligent, but many features in a modern one are.

        6
    • Yeah, but none of it is intelligence. It’s an approximation of artificial intelligence.

      11
    • Except LLMs aren’t AI. There’s zero intelligence.

      Almost as if the “intelligence” is “artificial”

      2
      • Artificial intelligence would still be intelligence. LLMs aren’t (and it’s arguable to what extent they’re artificial, given that the models aren’t built or designed, but trained on stolen pre-existing data).

        0
    • I agree with your semantic technicality. AI is properly a human study in the vein of parapsychology and metaphysics in that it doesn’t exist. However in common usage AI is the broadest term encompassing ml llms and other functions.

      2
    • AI is a weird term. It is historically used to refer even to the most basic algorithms, as long as they’re imitating any kind of behavioral patterns.

      Even then, i’d argue that LLMs have at least some intelligence (by which i mean it can solve algorithmic tasks), even if they don’t have conscience, or despite the fact that this intelligence is derived purely from imitation. After all, lots of human behavioral patterns are also derived from pure imitation without understanding (see traditions, cargo cult, religions, etc.).

      2

Sign in to comment. Sign in