Skip to content

Comment on Is it possible to build "City-Owned Grocery Stores" that prevents scalpers while not requiring ID Checks?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • It wouldn’t affect it at all. Go buy cheap groceries and resell them. It’s not less than wholesale, so they’d lose money if they had access to the wholesale market.

    This is bullshit. Some scaredy cat grocery store owner that can’t gouge prices anymore is scared and generating bullshit to cast shade on a good thing.

    “But how will I buy another mansion this year?” - CEO of grocery store chain. Though in reality, it’s “How do I buy 4 more mansions, afford my trip to New Epstein-Trump island, and spend $10M on buying an election to outlaw cheap food?!?!?”

    21
    • I’m so confused by people who think grocery stores are the evil profiteers.

      The grocery store is the last line in a chain of profit that stretches across dozens of companies on some items.

      Even a Banana has:

      1. Farm
      2. Farm Suppliers (fertilizer, pesticides, tools and equipment)
      3. Bulk packaging (boxes usually)
      4. Local transportation
      5. Warehousing and Docks
      6. Ocean Shipping
      7. Docks and Warehousing again
      8. More transport companies
      9. Grocery Store

      That’s ignoring secondary effects like landlords renting the land/buildings to the companies that operate these businesses.

      While some of the links in this chain may be owned by a single company, each step in the chain makes a profit.

      So while yes, grocery stores are profit driven… the whole fucking economy is profit driven. How is a public grocery store going to magically make things significantly cheaper when grocery store profit margins are like 3-6% of the retail price.

      Now, if we’re talking about running the entire food chain without profit… well then we can have a conversation.

      4
      • @jerkface@lemmy.ca· · edited

        You’re ignoring that every supermarket is radically vertically integrated and owns most of the chain. They don’t use that integration to lower prices, they use it as leverage to apply more pressure on consumers than they otherwise could.

        -1
        • And a public grocery store would also vertically integrate? I haven’t heard that being suggested at all.

          0
      • If we’re talking about running the entire food chain without profit… well, in such regimes, the conversations like this are usually forbiden by law and punished harshly.

        2
      • I mean sure but grocery price gouging is a very real thing.

        7
        • And how exactly will starting their own grocery store prevent that?

          The store will still need to buy shit from PepsiCo because people want their products. PepsiCo can still rig prices without the retailers support. Plenty of examples of competitors rigging prices together out there.

          1
          • And how exactly will starting their own grocery store prevent that?

            It won’t; this is a task for anti-trust law. However, it illustrates how grocery stores can price gouge.

            -1
      • And then you learn about big grocery store companys making sure, that all the profits from dairy products land with them or the factories handling them (which belong to.the same owners), and nearly none with the farms. That was and is a big issue here in germany

        3
        • And you think that a publically owned grocery store chain would somehow prevent those same factories from doing this? The grocery store will be forced to buy from the existing production sources.

          Which was entirely my point, why only the grocery store.

          0
      • Out of all the possible produce, you chose bananas? The farm is not making any profits there. I’m fairly certain that the process up until international transport is covered under one company who minimizes costs as much as possible including using what is effectively slave labor, if memory serves

        3
        • Yes… So why are we focusing on the grocery stores?

          1
          • Oh I’m with you somewhat there. I’m just saying that if you wanted to highlight a product that had many layers of overcharge capabilities from seed to store shelf beyond that of any the grocery store would charge, bananas might be the worst possible option.

            Corn on the other hand is a great option. From the legally distinct seeds with heavy litigation for anyone who tries to use seeds from previous years that forces farmers to buy new seeds every season to each processing step during and after they’re grown, to becoming a primary food additive or a somewhat biodegradable toy, there’s a lot of changing of hands with chances at gouging at every turn.

            0
      Continue this thread 6 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in