I… don’t think scalpers are the biggest problem tbh. They have to first make sure they don’t just massively hemorrhage money from the get-go
The problem is that grocery chains already run on razor-thin margins. So if a government want to run something that is comparable or even cheaper than private grocery stores, they have to 1) make their operations extremely efficient, and on top of it 2) they have to heavily subsidize it somehow. And if subsidies are part of the equation… governmental subsidies have to come from somewhere. Putting $100 towards grocery stores could mean putting $100 less towards say homeless shelters or unemployment benefits or sth, even if the latter is more effective at helping the poor than the former
However… I did see some online discussion saying that maybe they want to operate in “food deserts” without real supermarkets, and the 30% discount may be against convenience stores. Their document seem to hint at the keyword “access to grocery stores” too. If that’s the case it should be doable, apparently Atlanta pulled off such a deal after their local Walgreens closed (it’s a public-private partnership though, not 100% public). And if that’s the case, massive subsidies would be justified as you’d be helping residents with otherwise no fresh produce access
The scalper issue also happens with Goodwill, no? Methinks it’s more of a logistics issue that only matters once they actually start the thing…
Last I read, they were only opening 5, one in each borough. Not impactful any way you look at it.
But yes, margins are paper thin and I wish people understood this about some businesses. I want higher wages across the board, but in some cases it’s not as simple as taking the CEO’s pay, which is in almost all cases a microscopic percent of profit.
According to the 2025 financial report of Ahold Delhaize, a parent company who owns a whole bunch of grocery stores in the US and Europe (like Giant, Food Lion), the company increased profits from 1.8billion in 2024 to 2.3billion in 2025. That does not sound like razor thin margins to me. Source: Ahold Delhaize financial report
The $2.3 billion in 2025 net income was off net sales of $92.4 billion, so approximately 2.5%. 2024 net income was $1.8B from $89.4B net sales, about 2%.
That’s quite a thin margin, though they increased it by 25% in one year, and in line with the grocer average of 1-3%. Compare this to your average American mechanic at about 6.5%, florists at 10%, Nvidia, recently with an astounding 56.39%, or Whole Foods at about 35%.
Their point is that even if you were to remove the entirety of the profit margin, this amounts to a low percentage decrease in prices, in this retailer’s case about 2.5% on average.
Right, but the city-owned grocery stores don’t even need to make that 2.5%. In theory, they should operate as a non-profit at best.
If you take the view that food is a public good and lack thereof has downstream costs, I suspect that selling food at a loss might reduce education costs (since hungry kids probably need more remedial help). If the city-owned grocery stores are more willing to let some shoplifting slide, it probably reduces both insurance costs (that a regular grocery store would need to pay) and policing costs (that a regular grocery store would get “for free”, but the city would otherwise be paying for). Then there’s the whole “desperate people turn to crime” angle that might further reduce the policing budget if food is more affordable.
How much of this is true? I don’t know. I don’t work on the NYC budget. I’m just tired of people evaluating public services like businesses, ignoring how interconnected public services are and how much businesses get “for free” from public services.
Comments
I… don’t think scalpers are the biggest problem tbh. They have to first make sure they don’t just massively hemorrhage money from the get-go
The problem is that grocery chains already run on razor-thin margins. So if a government want to run something that is comparable or even cheaper than private grocery stores, they have to 1) make their operations extremely efficient, and on top of it 2) they have to heavily subsidize it somehow. And if subsidies are part of the equation… governmental subsidies have to come from somewhere. Putting $100 towards grocery stores could mean putting $100 less towards say homeless shelters or unemployment benefits or sth, even if the latter is more effective at helping the poor than the former
However… I did see some online discussion saying that maybe they want to operate in “food deserts” without real supermarkets, and the 30% discount may be against convenience stores. Their document seem to hint at the keyword “access to grocery stores” too. If that’s the case it should be doable, apparently Atlanta pulled off such a deal after their local Walgreens closed (it’s a public-private partnership though, not 100% public). And if that’s the case, massive subsidies would be justified as you’d be helping residents with otherwise no fresh produce access
The scalper issue also happens with Goodwill, no? Methinks it’s more of a logistics issue that only matters once they actually start the thing…
Last I read, they were only opening 5, one in each borough. Not impactful any way you look at it.
But yes, margins are paper thin and I wish people understood this about some businesses. I want higher wages across the board, but in some cases it’s not as simple as taking the CEO’s pay, which is in almost all cases a microscopic percent of profit.
According to the 2025 financial report of Ahold Delhaize, a parent company who owns a whole bunch of grocery stores in the US and Europe (like Giant, Food Lion), the company increased profits from 1.8billion in 2024 to 2.3billion in 2025. That does not sound like razor thin margins to me. Source: Ahold Delhaize financial report
That’s because you aren’t including any context.
The $2.3 billion in 2025 net income was off net sales of $92.4 billion, so approximately 2.5%. 2024 net income was $1.8B from $89.4B net sales, about 2%.
That’s quite a thin margin, though they increased it by 25% in one year, and in line with the grocer average of 1-3%. Compare this to your average American mechanic at about 6.5%, florists at 10%, Nvidia, recently with an astounding 56.39%, or Whole Foods at about 35%.
Their point is that even if you were to remove the entirety of the profit margin, this amounts to a low percentage decrease in prices, in this retailer’s case about 2.5% on average.
Right, but the city-owned grocery stores don’t even need to make that 2.5%. In theory, they should operate as a non-profit at best.
If you take the view that food is a public good and lack thereof has downstream costs, I suspect that selling food at a loss might reduce education costs (since hungry kids probably need more remedial help). If the city-owned grocery stores are more willing to let some shoplifting slide, it probably reduces both insurance costs (that a regular grocery store would need to pay) and policing costs (that a regular grocery store would get “for free”, but the city would otherwise be paying for). Then there’s the whole “desperate people turn to crime” angle that might further reduce the policing budget if food is more affordable.
How much of this is true? I don’t know. I don’t work on the NYC budget. I’m just tired of people evaluating public services like businesses, ignoring how interconnected public services are and how much businesses get “for free” from public services.
Profit margins under 5% are considered pretty low. Google has like a 50% profit margin.
Sign in to comment. Sign in