889
TIL in 1995 trans woman Tyra Hunter died because firefighters stopped treatment after discovering she was trans and started to call her slurs
According to witnesses, a male firefighter helping Hunter stopped and backed away laughing upon discovering that she had a penis, and saying “this bitch ain’t no girl…it’s a n*****, he’s got a dick”.
Two other witnesses corroborated the comment, but the description of the technician varied. He continued derogatory comments and joking with other firefighters while leaving her untreated.
Bystanders requested them to resume treatment, but they did not do so until a supervisor arrived three to seven minutes later.
[…]
ER staff at subsequently "failed to diagnose Hunter’s injuries and follow nationally accepted standards of care."Hunter died about an hour after arriving, and two hours after the crash
Comments
Damn. That fucking sucks.
Firefighters murdered a girl and got away with it. Not even a warning or slap in the wrist.
I’d love some corroborating stories but it doesn’t seem like this is a common occurrence with first responders outside of the bastards we used to call the police.
Maybe things are different where you are, but where I am firefighters and EMTs are just cops without guns. The EMTs will go out of their way to misgender you and deadname you if you’re trans, and the firefighters are even more belligerently bigoted, sometimes even moreso than the cops. A lot of the issue inherent to the opioid epidemic in the American South is that if you’re not a straight white male, you can’t rely on any of the EMS to help you, at all, and so it falls to street medics to save your life.
AFAB then?
no. this is more of an outlier of a situation. as someone that’s been part of fire communities over decades l, firefighters generally drop all biases when rescuing people. even folks that say racist things will unconditionally save people no matter who it is. Please don’t lump firefighters into the same bucket as shitty cops
Nope it’s a trans woman
I think they meant “all firefighters are bastards” like ACAB rather than “assigned female at birth” but obviously in the context of the discussion, that isn’t very clear.
Wait what’s the n word here? Is it the n-word?
I always thought that word was gender-neutral?
It is the n word. Tyra was a black trans woman.
Depends in which black spaces. I remember an argument on twitter blowing up cause a white trans woman didn’t want to be called the n-word due to its male connotation in certain spaces and she got jumped by black people who used it in a gender neutral way.
Then again, twitter is the place where any nuance goes to die.
… I (a white person) have never been called the n-word so wtf?
huge problem with gen z and alpha using ni–a like it means ‘bro’ and they aren’t backing down from it. working with kids right now is killing me. I can’t tell you how often I need to tell a white kid I’m not listing to him say the n word once.
Honestly, I don’t think we have a say in this. I think the only people whose opinions are worth considering on this issue are the opinions of black teenagers.
Teenagers invent language. Teenagers are literally the primary mechanism through which human languages evolve. Teenagers experiment, inventing new words and applying old words in new ways. The vast majority of the linguistic innovations teenagers invent end up being fads quickly forgotten. But some new words or uses of words patch a hole in the language or give it new abilities. Those changes endure the test of time. It’s evolution in action. Linguistic survival of the fittest.
The soft-r “ni–a” is literally not the same word as the hard r. It’s used among the black community to mean “bro” or similar. It’s literally in the dictionary. The “bro” definition is not new or novel. That’s literally what “ni–a” means.
The only thing novel here is the fact that (I assume) the kid you’re referring to is not black. Will it ever become socially acceptable for non-black people to use the word? I honestly don’t know. Obviously it will never be acceptable for the hard-r version. But we’re talking about a completely different word here. Past generations have decided that it’s unacceptable for non-black people to use the word. But Gen Alpha could make their own call on that. Ultimately it’s up to them, not us. If they want the language to change, it will change. And I think it will ultimately be Gen Alpha black people that make that decision. If the black people of that generation collectively decide that it’s possible to use “nigga” in a positive sense, with no offense and only compliment intended? Then it will simply become the new norm.
And this really wouldn’t be the strangest outcome. It’s very rare for positive words to remain relegated to one demographic group forever. And maybe that’s not such a bad thing. In a world of perfect racial harmony, there wouldn’t be words only some people are allowed to use.
I don’t know, man, I’m not even white.
[deleted]
It pains me to think of how many stories like this there are. There are so many evil people in the world.
Pure evil.
[deleted]
They seem so obsessed in blaming gays for everything.
Its a easy sell for the most part. Back then and today.
Just one reason I fundamentally reject these ideas that we hold people on pedestals simply for their career choices. Police, military, and first responder worship. Fuck that. Shitty people exist in those jobs and they are rarely held to the scrutiny and high expectations they SHOULD be. Plus they self selected into the jobs. Yes, of course I’d thank anyone who helped me or someone I cared about, but simply blanket worshipping the jobs is fucked, and this story is one mere example why.
We also see bigotry and shitty practices out of fucking doctors too.
No idols, No gods, No masters
Astronauts. Most of them are former military
I think the previous astronaut callup two years ago was the first one where every applicant didn’t need to have 1500 hours of jet powered flight, only the pilots. The current astronaut callup I think reinstated that requirement.
The only way you get 1500 hours of jet powered flight is by being a military pilot or having several tens of millions of dollars to burn specifically on that one requirement.
You could meet that requirement being a pilot. Nearly every commercial plane is jet powered, same with private jets (which have a lower barrier to entry than commercial flights)
It would actually be harder to do it in the military. They don’t get very many hours
Yeah, until recently most commercial pilots were military too.
See other option: paying for flight hours. Couple google searches puts the cost for jets at 300-1000$ per flight hour, so if you’ve got somewhere in the 400k-1.5mil range to burn, that should cover it. I guess you could also try to open your own flight school.
Here in the US they are quite likely to be volunteers. Not even paid.
Of course not. They did nothing wrong. It was just a trans girl not a person
I’m still learning and asking genuinely: can you be trans without going through all the surgeries and hormone supplements? Like is it a thing in the community for a seemingly biological man to be considered trans through lifestyle changes?
Yes. A lot of people don’t have the option for hormones or surgery for various reasons, or choose not to use those options for various reasons. But a trans person is trans regardless.
Moreover, still a person and should be treated as such.
Thank you for clarifying!
The distinction you’re looking for is social vs medical transition; someone who transitions socially may change their name, pronouns, and how they dress, while people who medically transition take hormones and/or have gender related surgery.
Thank you. This is what I’m looking for that makes sense to me.
You can change your appearance a lot with clothes, letting your hair grow, cutting your body hair
There is also the fact that a lot of trans people are unable or choose not to medically transition because of laws, parents, society, medical issues, they dont see it necessary, are nonbinary, etc.
Yep. Like, I’m out as non-binary at work but that doesn’t mean I need to dress a certain way or take hormones or go through surgery. I’ve had this body for however long and I know how it works, no need to change that up now that I’m out. Plus if I got top surgery my clothing wouldn’t fit.
(I’m non-binary, but not dysphoric about stuff, just confused when misgendered because, like, that’s not me oh wait they’re talking about me.)
And if I don’t change my legal gender marker maybe the state won’t invalidate my identity documents on a whim.
YES
Thank you.
Would you please explain your comment?
I missed the s at the end
That’s a prime example of institutionalised racism and transphobia. Everyone in the system there saying, “I guess she just died”, with all acting in concert pretending to be oblivious.
Bless Wikipedia for not censoring anything. I thought, that N can’t mean what I think it means, how would that be a surprise? The N meant what I thought it meant. The so-called paramedic was not only surprised by her anatomy, he was surprised by her race? Bigots be stupid as fuck.
“Poole said the black technician “then got up and went over to his partner, and they were over there laughing and telling jokes about that,” the memo said. She said Hunter went two to five minutes without treatment as the rescuers laughed.”
The EMT in question was black
And black people can’t be bigoted?
and a fucking racist too!
I mean then the use of the word was at least fine
Fun Fact: All conservatives are bigots. They may not all be racist. Some are just sexist or homophobic or xenophobic. But ALL conservatives are bigots of some kind.
Conservatism is a bigotry-based ideology. They seek to ‘conserve’ a hierarchy in which they are above all others, and only below other conservatives with greater wealth or power.
I think conservatives have both a strong tribal instinct AND a fear-based outlook. Tribalism (of whatever type) is their primary strategy for minimizing danger.
And the irony of it… by believing all conservatives are bigots… one could very well argue that makes you bigoted as well!
Generally speaking I agree with you but I can’t help but point out that irony. We are all bigoted in our own ways, known and unknown, and/or caring or not caring. Some just do a lot less to self improve on it and reign themselves in.
Not a centrist btw but I see how this can look like a super centrist argument.
You can’t be bigoted against political ideologies. Bigotry applies only to traits people don’t choose for themselves, innate characteristics. Someone choosing to be a conservative is not something they were born with. And it’s something they can change.
Unlike a bigot, however, judging a conservative as harmful or “bad” is not a prejudice. It is an educated observation.
You really don’t see the hypocrisy in saying that? I’ve personally talked to racists who used nearly that exact phrasing and logic to justify why they aren’t racist. Sorry if I’m splitting hairs , but you are by definition and in the spirit of the meaning, bigoted towards conservatives. Call it an educated observation all you’d like, I don’t think slapping a new coat of paint makes it any more pretty.
If I understand correctly, you appear to be saying that every conservative is bad and/or harmful, which is casting a massive blanket on a very large group of people. Don’t get me wrong, I dislike conservative politics so much I left the US over it. It actually wouldn’t be a stretch to say I hate conservatism. But EVERY conservative is bigoted? Every tens of millions of them? Hundreds of millions if you include other countries’ conservatives?
I never thought I’d be defending conservatives on the fediverse of all places, but blanketly saying they are all bigoted and/or harmful just doesn’t really sit right with me. It feels like its just “othering” them and possibly dehumanizing them. I don’t think this is what it means to be intolerant of the intolerant.
The nazis in Weimar Germany in the early 30’s didn’t call themselves nazis. Neither did Hitler for the most part. In fact, most nazis didn’t call themselves nazis in daily language until it became required to do so. They just called themselves conservatives, as they always had for generations.
Were they all bigots? I don’t think it’s an insult or bigotry to call them all bigots.
We have concentration camps in the U.S. right now and conservatives won’t stand up and denounce them. We have a violent gesatapo that brutalizes whomever they please and conservatives won’t stand up and speak out against it. You won’t find conservatives at a No Kings protest, not even conservatives who hate Trump. That’s because conservatives who dislike MAGA and Trump still agree with a majority of the same positions. They just dislike the packaging of the current cult.
Conservatism is a hierarchical ideology. That imaginary hierarchy is the foundation upon which bigotry is based and justified in the conservative mind. I think you are taking offense to a word on the conservative’s behalf and missing the most important part of the matter. It’s not intended to be an insult. It’s a description of a situation for which we already have a label. If it makes me a bigot in your mind to use that word to describe bigots, then what is the point in defending myself from your use of that label? It’s more important to me to be accurate in my observation of conservatives at large.
I am old. I was raised in the south (U.S.) and retired in the south from a career with 98% conservative colleagues. I was a good son, brother, nephew, grandson, neighbor and friend to conservatives for over 50 years. I genuinely believe conservatives can be both bigots and my family, neighbors and friends simultaneously because that’s exactly who they have always been in my observation and experience. A discussion with a conservative at just the right time will usually reveal what any friendly conservative’s particular bigotry is if it’s not readily observable.
I don’t know how much time you’ve spent with conservatives, but I spent a lifetime before I moved away and disowned them. I am offering my honest observations, not trying to insult anyone. You can split hairs in your descriptions or label me however you choose, but I won’t pretend to not see what so many of us can plainly see. Conservatism is a bigotry-based ideology. It is lazy, incurious and harmful to everyone and should be called out for what it is without fear.
Paradox of tolerance
doesn’t apply here.
The paradox is about defending the institutions of open society against movements that reject reasoned persuasion and seek power through coercion or violence. The “intolerant” in the paradox are not merely intolerant in the everyday sense. They are intolerant[1] of the open society itself.
The original passage that articulated it
was in a footnote in the political philosophy book The Open Society and Its Enemies by Karl Popper.
An open society is governed through nonviolent political competition that depends on free inquiry, intellectual liberty, open debate. Consequently, someone may hold repugnant, exclusionary views and still remain within the framework of an open society, provided they continue to accept nonviolent public choice and the institutions that sustain it. Such a person is not the target of the paradox.
Rather, those who violate the framework of an open society by suppressing the conditions it depends on (free inquiry, intellectual liberty, open debate) are closer to the target of the paradox.
Popper’s argument is not about silencing disagreeable beliefs as social media commonly claims. Open society can consistently tolerate a wide range of beliefs while refusing to tolerate violations of conditions that make tolerance possible. Since we aren’t specifically talking about such violators, the paradox simply doesn’t apply here.
Tolerance in political philosophy more strictly means the acceptance of an objectionable idea or practice. Intolerance more strictly means the rejection of such idea or practice. A society rejects by prohibiting. A movement rejects a society by violating or suppressing its conditions of existence (or norms). ↑
Yes, it is ok to be intolerant of the intolerant. Lose your everyone deserves to be heard equally mentality. Suck the air out of the room.
I’m quite familiar with the paradox of tolerance and agree wholeheartedly with it. Never said that everyone inherently deserves to be heard equally either. Don’t make up things that I never said or implied.
Calling every conservative a bigot and making sweeping generalizations on an entire group of people is nearly the perfect definition of bigotry itself. I think people are a bit too quick to abuse the paradox of intolerance to just write off entire groups of people, which, I think at least, is the very bigotry that the paradox of intolerance is trying to excise. Marlow’s hammer quote come to mind “It is tempting, if the only tool you have is a hammer, to treat everything as if it were a nail”.
I am as anti-conservative as they can get really, I was raised surrounded by them in the US south. I think just broadly dismissing them as a bigotry-based ideology is a dangerous misunderstanding and/or gross oversimplification of their beliefs, and predisposes people to misunderstand why they are the way they are. And, ultimately, what we can do to bring them towards more pro-social forms of thought. In my personal lived experiences, I more often found your common conservative to be misled or misinformed either through lack of education or propaganda.
We shouldn’t censor the word when we’re quoting bigots. They don’t deserve it. They said it, we should quote the full word. It’s not the string of letters that’s offensive, it’s the context in which it’s used. Quoting another is not offensive, it’s honesty.
That said, I won’t quote it here, because I’m sure the word is banned here, and could possibly get me autobanned from communities, because banned word lists don’t understand context, either, they’re just blunt force, stupid machines that are tasked with doing work people should do instead.
Fun fact, we started censoring the word b/c of OJ Simpson trial. No one was comfortable saying the actual word as many times as the LAPD had felt like using it. They started using N-word to get around that problem, and it stuck.
You don’t want to be the guy remembered for saying ‘n****r’ 100 times on CourtTV.
We should do the thing that I’m not going to do.
I mean, the yoke of your oppressors is not easily thrown homie. Why make a point to no one, that’s wasteful. I’m sorry that they didn’t feel like impressing nothing/nobody/losers on the internet. Next time the universe will make your opinion the only one that matters.
Wat
Jesus Christ America
I assumed the firefighter is black.
I made the same assumption. I hate censorship, especially when it softens how awful that piece of shit firefighter was
wow
Big if true.
And we’re still going with ‘trans women are a danger to society’??
I don’t believe anyone with a quarter of a functioning brain believes that trans women are a danger. They just use it to fuel hate of something they don’t understand or like.
If you want to try and understand their point of view… from their perspective… think of how icky we think about child molestors. That’s the level they consider “changing yer god-given gender!” to be.
I emphasize that they are dehumanizing humans by doing this. But for a lot of them, it is that distasteful. Along with all the fear, manipulation, misinformation on top of that to make it worse.
I really don’t give two shits about their point of view except that it must change or they can shut the fuck up and get back into the transphobia closet. But for anyone that wants to, I think pedophilia is a good analogy. (Not a good analogy for a lot of those folks because they are not horrified by pedophilia)
“Trans women are a danger to my fragile toxic self-image because if I’m attracted to a woman and it turns out she was born a man it will shatter everything I’ve ever believed about myself.”
– Transphobes, probably.
This is the exact truth right here. Theyre terrified they’ll be attracted to a trans person then find out they have a wee wee and their self image will be ruined.
It used to be common to fear transwomen based on the assumption they would try to trick you into sexual situations
There’s also “Trans women are a danger to my fragile toxic self-image b/c being a woman is a martyrdom I’ve built my entire personality around”
Unfortunately medical neglect like this of trans people, especially trans women of color, remains a problem to this day, though fortunately not as blatant or extreme.
THIS is why all the “annoying” pride thing that companies do is worth it. Because it helps to normalize these things - WHICH ARE NORMAL.
Agreed. I still hate that we have to accept all of the abuses and control of late stage capitalism in order to do so. It’s a lose-lose situation, but I suppose I prefer not to be murdered? Something something die on my feet…
Feels like a panic nightmare.
I happen to share that hope. I’d prefer you not to be murdered if it’s all the same to you, thanks. hehe
O.M.G. dont piss me off, what were these fucking american firefighters fucking doing!!!
omfg someone is dying and theyre having a comedic moment???
im also confused abt the ‘failed to diagnose her injuries’ part, i hope that wasnt intention too
Oh thank God. I was missing so many punctuation marks but you’ve filled my quota up again.
It’s the banality of evil. Being evil for them is normal.
Conservatives are genuinely, deeply evil. It’s not an illusion. They really are as cruel and evil as they portray themselves to be. Always have been.
Disown them. Delete them.
I still don’t know or understand how people are so casually racist that slurs are a part of their vocabulary.
Easier inside of a bubble. If everyone around you doesn’t react to it and even laughs at these slurs then the Zeitgeist won’t move on. It’s not even just that, they also assume that YOU use it secretly like they do but just don’t tell anyone.
Sorta why they push back on “woke”, then they’ll have to face the reality that they’re terrible people, in their mind they probably think they’re good people.
I’m not gonna defend slurs but I have friends that use the word: “gay” all the time in a derogatory way. I haven’t seen them since highschool and went to live in the UK for a while. Coming back and hearing it was very jarring. I just said, “you guys still using that? you haven’t moved on from that?”. I think they’ve reduced their usage of it because I don’t notice it anymore but without that … people just keep using it.
Maybe I’m racist, but I assumed the firefighters were black so the n word was just used as “dude”
Racists have no interesting or redeeming personal qualities, so they have to lean on something they were born into in order to feel like they are worth anything instead of improving themselves.
These stories are fucking terrifying to read. Not for me necessarily, but knowing that there are more out there, that don’t have their own memorials, or any record of the humanity that was stripped from them.
Why are people such amazing losers?
This is horrifying and unacceptable but I can’t help wondering why genitals below the waist were exposed or noticed at all 🤔
I hate to defend these awful people but its extremely important in trauma to remove all the patients clothes and inspect them from head to toe for any missed injuries. Part of the primary assessment of trauma.
Her name was Tyra Hunter and she fucking mattered. Rip sister 😢
Thats messed up
When I learn things like this, which happened in the past, I just imagine them happening today, because they are. A lot.
they are.
https://diva-magazine.com/2026/10/20/justice-for-joelle/
Why are we even letting people die because of gendered bed assignments?
Sure yeah people get naked in hospitals and the robes are a bit revealing, but if that’s the only available bed then why is there even a question about it? This is even ignoring the whole issue with not respecting trans rights, like we shouldn’t have anyone dying because of gendered beds
Why are there even gendered bed assignments in the first place??
I genuinely see zero benefit. It just wastes money by requiring the hospital to keep more beds available than necessary. Beds that cannot even be used as redundancy apparently.
I genuinely don’t see any point. A woman with a broken leg can be put in the same room as a man with a broken arm. Same with any number of diseases, injuries etc. Hell, even a pregnancy ward can put trans men into the same room as cis women because why not?
Some women are traumatized by men (and vice versa) but… they are a small minority and can just receive a solo room?? Or just shuffle people a bit around if none are available, hospital beds have wheels.
I think it is true that most people would feel more comfortable not being in a mixed gender setting. Like I said you can end up rather exposed in a hospital with bedpans and a variety of tests/examinations. Increasing patient comfort does help the healing process. Is it right for people to be so prudish? Not really, but the place to heal people isn’t the place to challenge those views.
However, the comfort of a person should not override the treatment of another. The priority should be keeping people alive before anything else and comfort is a secondary goal.
So if there’s no space the policy should be to use available beds regardless of gender. If you have enough beds sure separate if you must, but it should just be a preference and not so inflexible.
I’ve been in a multi-bed hospital room before and there were curtains between the beds for some privacy during more intimate examinations.
Besides, even in a single-gender ward there will be visitors of any gender staying for quite some time.
I doubt many people would be uncomfortable for more than a day if placed in a room with someone of a different gender. The biggest concern is boredom really. And snoring.
Forty years from now someone is going to be shocked that it’s still happening.
I REALLY hope not
!actually_infuriating@lemmy.world
How did they discover she had a penis? Sexually assaulting a dying woman when they were supposed to be saving her? Scum either way.
The article says it was a car crash, so I’m guessing she was maybe wearing a skirt, however if someone dies 2hours after reaching hospital i would imagine there was some pretty severe injuries especially in a car from the 90s more likely the 80s. Maybe a full body exam to check broken pelvis. Still doesn’t excuse what he did
Yes or maybe had a feeling she was trans so looked. Which is even worse
Where I ran calls we had several major hospitals within a 10-minute ride. Even so, after an auto accident a patient is loaded into the unit and made “trauma naked” so we could fully assess any damage. We don’t rely on the patient’s own assessment because they may be in shock, under the influence of drugs or alcohol, etc. We typically left underwear on unless we suspected damage beneath. I hope I don’t need to add that the behavior of this firefighter and his crew is inexcusable.
A paramedic I know has had family members of patients who think like you. He’s in the middle of trying to save a dying person’s life, and has to stop because family gets irrational about something they don’t understand
Usually they just shout and threaten, but he has been attacked. Policy now requires EMS to immediately disengage and call police for protection, when family gets aggressive. A roughly 5 minute slow down for critical care. This had to be instituted after an EMS was seriously injured for just doing their job
Sorry if I’m a bit blunt about it. If makes me viscerally angry because I’m thinking of a specific person who died because their family could not control themselves because EMS was cutting off the female patients pants
The reason, and also the answer to your question, is: Femoral IV. When giving CPR, it’s often the easiest access point for EMS to give IVs quickly
Not uncommon to have your pants and shirt cut off after an accident. If you’re bleeding from places that are covered they’re cutting off your clothes to find the bleed
A cursory examination of an unconscious person involves using your (hopefully gloved) hands to feel around the outsides and the insides of the legs - and arms, back, and chest, for that matter - in order to check for fractures and bleeds. Depending on size, clothes, tuck, etc. it’s not unexpected that a penis may become apparent in the process.
They were probably cutting the pants off. There is no modesty in emergency medicine. Maybe looking for injuries, most likely for an IV, since they were probably performing CPR at the same time
That’s really difficult too read
Sign in to comment. Sign in