Comment on TIL in 1995 trans woman Tyra Hunter died because firefighters stopped treatment after discovering she was trans and started to call her slurs
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments
Comments
How did they discover she had a penis? Sexually assaulting a dying woman when they were supposed to be saving her? Scum either way.
The article says it was a car crash, so I’m guessing she was maybe wearing a skirt, however if someone dies 2hours after reaching hospital i would imagine there was some pretty severe injuries especially in a car from the 90s more likely the 80s. Maybe a full body exam to check broken pelvis. Still doesn’t excuse what he did
Yes or maybe had a feeling she was trans so looked. Which is even worse
Where I ran calls we had several major hospitals within a 10-minute ride. Even so, after an auto accident a patient is loaded into the unit and made “trauma naked” so we could fully assess any damage. We don’t rely on the patient’s own assessment because they may be in shock, under the influence of drugs or alcohol, etc. We typically left underwear on unless we suspected damage beneath. I hope I don’t need to add that the behavior of this firefighter and his crew is inexcusable.
A paramedic I know has had family members of patients who think like you. He’s in the middle of trying to save a dying person’s life, and has to stop because family gets irrational about something they don’t understand
Usually they just shout and threaten, but he has been attacked. Policy now requires EMS to immediately disengage and call police for protection, when family gets aggressive. A roughly 5 minute slow down for critical care. This had to be instituted after an EMS was seriously injured for just doing their job
Sorry if I’m a bit blunt about it. If makes me viscerally angry because I’m thinking of a specific person who died because their family could not control themselves because EMS was cutting off the female patients pants
The reason, and also the answer to your question, is: Femoral IV. When giving CPR, it’s often the easiest access point for EMS to give IVs quickly
Not uncommon to have your pants and shirt cut off after an accident. If you’re bleeding from places that are covered they’re cutting off your clothes to find the bleed
A cursory examination of an unconscious person involves using your (hopefully gloved) hands to feel around the outsides and the insides of the legs - and arms, back, and chest, for that matter - in order to check for fractures and bleeds. Depending on size, clothes, tuck, etc. it’s not unexpected that a penis may become apparent in the process.
They were probably cutting the pants off. There is no modesty in emergency medicine. Maybe looking for injuries, most likely for an IV, since they were probably performing CPR at the same time
As mentioned by other - primary trauma assessment - the ABCs of trauma - it is important to fully expose the patient so you can check them all over for injuries. See more here
Weird assumption when the story is plainly stated to be coming from eyewitnesses. What’s obviously being said: “eyewitnesses saw these assholes stop treatment after, during the course of treatment, they determined a penis was present”. Your version of events: “so these two firefighters started sexually assaulting a woman in public at the scene of an accident and then got mad that it was a trans person”. You’re just making up something weird and unlikely in order to hate the clearly dogshit people even more.
It is sexual assault once you decide to forget your duty and start making lewd comments are you kidding? That is very literally sexual assault. You have a responsibility to do your job right and if you don’t in that situation you HAVE inherently by the nature of your actions committed a sexual assault.
Yes, what I said is extremely controversial. “There’s no need to imagine new reasons to hate people we already know are awful.” Clutch those pearls harder. I’m sure next you’ll pretend I’m defending the obviously terrible people.
Is it sexual assault? What the firefighter did? Because you’re saying it’s not
I say it is most definitely sexual assault
A medical provider discovering the anatomy of their patient is not sexual assault
Their comments, I’ll accept your argument they constitute sexual assault
I did not say anything about or like that. I am allowed to make a point without getting dragged into a fully different conversation. What one user said was speculation that the firefighters were physically assaulting the victim. I simply pointed out that this is speculation and not helpful. We already know they are awful people. No need to invent more reasons to think that.
What I don’t understand is what you think it accomplishes to jump into a conversation and claim that your very specific reading of my words proves that I’m a garbage person? What possible outcome do you hope for? That I realize that even though I clearly meant to say one thing, if someone else can twist it into something else, then I should feel ashamed about it? The Internet has destroyed people’s ability to be even slightly charitable. When I responded to the top level comment, I may have ruffled feathers but I did not put words into anyone’s mouth or tell them they’re hurting others by saying what they did. They probably didn’t mean to cause any harm to anyone. I simply pointed out that truth matters. I am not defending anyone, I am not making any statement whatsoever beyond “let’s stick to the evidence”.
It is counterproductive and hurts you and me to cram words into my mouth while ignoring something that honestly ought to be self evident and completely uncontroversial. I think you should have known that “assault” here meant physical. The wording and context made that clear. If you next want to steer the conversation into me supposedly saying that only physical assault matters, keep in mind that I never said that, and if you want to go that route, it’s just your need to feel self righteous at play. Again, all I said is that the speculation that these assholes did things beyond what evidence exists for is not helpful. You should try assuming not everyone is out to hate or hurt.
What treatment required them to grope or examine her genitals?
They probably had to remove clothing to treat them
Got it. Thank you.
Now that we know exposing a patient’s genitals is required by the job, maybe we should not allow conservatives to do this job, given how openly obsessed with genitals they are. It clearly results in a loss of life when they disapprove of the genitals they find.
Funny you should mention that. I think it’s a good reason EMS and fire should be separated across the US. The culture and skillset of the two roles are simply too different
In most cases, the firefighting culture wins out, even though >90% of their calls are medical in nature
In fairness to conservatives, while I’m sure there have been more than just this incident, from the general lack of these things happening more than they do, most of them seem able to treat patients regardless of beliefs.
I wouldn’t need to answer that, it’s pretty fucking obvious these guys didn’t do that publicly, but there are a number of reasons and none of the explanations for it would be as unlikely as the one from this comment.
I guess I thought i was getting treatment those times doctors saw my penis, but they obviously tricked me into showing them.
Sign in to comment. Sign in