Comment on TIL in 1995 trans woman Tyra Hunter died because firefighters stopped treatment after discovering she was trans and started to call her slurs
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
Yes, what I said is extremely controversial. “There’s no need to imagine new reasons to hate people we already know are awful.” Clutch those pearls harder. I’m sure next you’ll pretend I’m defending the obviously terrible people.
Is it sexual assault? What the firefighter did? Because you’re saying it’s not
I say it is most definitely sexual assault
A medical provider discovering the anatomy of their patient is not sexual assault
Their comments, I’ll accept your argument they constitute sexual assault
I did not say anything about or like that. I am allowed to make a point without getting dragged into a fully different conversation. What one user said was speculation that the firefighters were physically assaulting the victim. I simply pointed out that this is speculation and not helpful. We already know they are awful people. No need to invent more reasons to think that.
What I don’t understand is what you think it accomplishes to jump into a conversation and claim that your very specific reading of my words proves that I’m a garbage person? What possible outcome do you hope for? That I realize that even though I clearly meant to say one thing, if someone else can twist it into something else, then I should feel ashamed about it? The Internet has destroyed people’s ability to be even slightly charitable. When I responded to the top level comment, I may have ruffled feathers but I did not put words into anyone’s mouth or tell them they’re hurting others by saying what they did. They probably didn’t mean to cause any harm to anyone. I simply pointed out that truth matters. I am not defending anyone, I am not making any statement whatsoever beyond “let’s stick to the evidence”.
It is counterproductive and hurts you and me to cram words into my mouth while ignoring something that honestly ought to be self evident and completely uncontroversial. I think you should have known that “assault” here meant physical. The wording and context made that clear. If you next want to steer the conversation into me supposedly saying that only physical assault matters, keep in mind that I never said that, and if you want to go that route, it’s just your need to feel self righteous at play. Again, all I said is that the speculation that these assholes did things beyond what evidence exists for is not helpful. You should try assuming not everyone is out to hate or hurt.
Sign in to comment. Sign in