Skip to content

Comment on TIL in 1995 trans woman Tyra Hunter died because firefighters stopped treatment after discovering she was trans and started to call her slurs

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • @Grizzlybur@piefed.ca· · edited

    And the irony of it… by believing all conservatives are bigots… one could very well argue that makes you bigoted as well!

    Generally speaking I agree with you but I can’t help but point out that irony. We are all bigoted in our own ways, known and unknown, and/or caring or not caring. Some just do a lot less to self improve on it and reign themselves in.

    Not a centrist btw but I see how this can look like a super centrist argument.

    -3
    • You can’t be bigoted against political ideologies. Bigotry applies only to traits people don’t choose for themselves, innate characteristics. Someone choosing to be a conservative is not something they were born with. And it’s something they can change.

      0
    • Unlike a bigot, however, judging a conservative as harmful or “bad” is not a prejudice. It is an educated observation.

      4
      • You really don’t see the hypocrisy in saying that? I’ve personally talked to racists who used nearly that exact phrasing and logic to justify why they aren’t racist. Sorry if I’m splitting hairs , but you are by definition and in the spirit of the meaning, bigoted towards conservatives. Call it an educated observation all you’d like, I don’t think slapping a new coat of paint makes it any more pretty.

        If I understand correctly, you appear to be saying that every conservative is bad and/or harmful, which is casting a massive blanket on a very large group of people. Don’t get me wrong, I dislike conservative politics so much I left the US over it. It actually wouldn’t be a stretch to say I hate conservatism. But EVERY conservative is bigoted? Every tens of millions of them? Hundreds of millions if you include other countries’ conservatives?

        I never thought I’d be defending conservatives on the fediverse of all places, but blanketly saying they are all bigoted and/or harmful just doesn’t really sit right with me. It feels like its just “othering” them and possibly dehumanizing them. I don’t think this is what it means to be intolerant of the intolerant.

        -3
        • The nazis in Weimar Germany in the early 30’s didn’t call themselves nazis. Neither did Hitler for the most part. In fact, most nazis didn’t call themselves nazis in daily language until it became required to do so. They just called themselves conservatives, as they always had for generations.

          Were they all bigots? I don’t think it’s an insult or bigotry to call them all bigots.

          We have concentration camps in the U.S. right now and conservatives won’t stand up and denounce them. We have a violent gesatapo that brutalizes whomever they please and conservatives won’t stand up and speak out against it. You won’t find conservatives at a No Kings protest, not even conservatives who hate Trump. That’s because conservatives who dislike MAGA and Trump still agree with a majority of the same positions. They just dislike the packaging of the current cult.

          Conservatism is a hierarchical ideology. That imaginary hierarchy is the foundation upon which bigotry is based and justified in the conservative mind. I think you are taking offense to a word on the conservative’s behalf and missing the most important part of the matter. It’s not intended to be an insult. It’s a description of a situation for which we already have a label. If it makes me a bigot in your mind to use that word to describe bigots, then what is the point in defending myself from your use of that label? It’s more important to me to be accurate in my observation of conservatives at large.

          I am old. I was raised in the south (U.S.) and retired in the south from a career with 98% conservative colleagues. I was a good son, brother, nephew, grandson, neighbor and friend to conservatives for over 50 years. I genuinely believe conservatives can be both bigots and my family, neighbors and friends simultaneously because that’s exactly who they have always been in my observation and experience. A discussion with a conservative at just the right time will usually reveal what any friendly conservative’s particular bigotry is if it’s not readily observable.

          I don’t know how much time you’ve spent with conservatives, but I spent a lifetime before I moved away and disowned them. I am offering my honest observations, not trying to insult anyone. You can split hairs in your descriptions or label me however you choose, but I won’t pretend to not see what so many of us can plainly see. Conservatism is a bigotry-based ideology. It is lazy, incurious and harmful to everyone and should be called out for what it is without fear.

          1
    • Paradox of tolerance

      1
      • doesn’t apply here.

        The paradox is about defending the institutions of open society against movements that reject reasoned persuasion and seek power through coercion or violence. The “intolerant” in the paradox are not merely intolerant in the everyday sense. They are intolerant[1] of the open society itself.

        The original passage that articulated it

        Less well known is the paradox of tolerance: Unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance. If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant, if we are not prepared to defend a tolerant society against the onslaught of the intolerant, then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them.—In this formulation, I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be most unwise. But we should claim the right to suppress them [intolerant ideologies] if necessary even by force; for it may easily turn out that they are not prepared to meet us on the level of rational argument, but begin by denouncing all argument; they may forbid their followers to listen to rational argument, because it is deceptive, and teach them to answer arguments by the use of their fists or pistols.

        was in a footnote in the political philosophy book The Open Society and Its Enemies by Karl Popper.

        An open society is governed through nonviolent political competition that depends on free inquiry, intellectual liberty, open debate. Consequently, someone may hold repugnant, exclusionary views and still remain within the framework of an open society, provided they continue to accept nonviolent public choice and the institutions that sustain it. Such a person is not the target of the paradox.

        Rather, those who violate the framework of an open society by suppressing the conditions it depends on (free inquiry, intellectual liberty, open debate) are closer to the target of the paradox.

        Popper’s argument is not about silencing disagreeable beliefs as social media commonly claims. Open society can consistently tolerate a wide range of beliefs while refusing to tolerate violations of conditions that make tolerance possible. Since we aren’t specifically talking about such violators, the paradox simply doesn’t apply here.


        1. Tolerance in political philosophy more strictly means the acceptance of an objectionable idea or practice. Intolerance more strictly means the rejection of such idea or practice. A society rejects by prohibiting. A movement rejects a society by violating or suppressing its conditions of existence (or norms). ↑

        0
    • Yes, it is ok to be intolerant of the intolerant. Lose your everyone deserves to be heard equally mentality. Suck the air out of the room.

      1
      • @Grizzlybur@piefed.ca· · edited

        I’m quite familiar with the paradox of tolerance and agree wholeheartedly with it. Never said that everyone inherently deserves to be heard equally either. Don’t make up things that I never said or implied.

        Calling every conservative a bigot and making sweeping generalizations on an entire group of people is nearly the perfect definition of bigotry itself. I think people are a bit too quick to abuse the paradox of intolerance to just write off entire groups of people, which, I think at least, is the very bigotry that the paradox of intolerance is trying to excise. Marlow’s hammer quote come to mind “It is tempting, if the only tool you have is a hammer, to treat everything as if it were a nail”.

        I am as anti-conservative as they can get really, I was raised surrounded by them in the US south. I think just broadly dismissing them as a bigotry-based ideology is a dangerous misunderstanding and/or gross oversimplification of their beliefs, and predisposes people to misunderstand why they are the way they are. And, ultimately, what we can do to bring them towards more pro-social forms of thought. In my personal lived experiences, I more often found your common conservative to be misled or misinformed either through lack of education or propaganda.

        0

Sign in to comment. Sign in