-32
You wake up in your home, but in a parallel universe where there are no age of consent laws for anything, and you must define them. How do you do it?
What criteria are you considering?
Catch all or specific to use cases?
Include cultural aspects?
What else goes into your decision?
EDIT: I mean age restrictions for anything. Not just age of consent.
Comments
I’m raising the age of consent to join the armed forces to 82
I’m willing to make an exception for politicians.
As in they must all fight on the front lines. No exceptions.
I don’t like where this could go with some people…
What are you personally wanting OP?
It’s just a question, and that’s the point. Curious what people’s thoughts are on it. Obviously something too sensitive for some people to want to touch.
To me, the ages governments apply seem kind of arbitrary.
It seems that society as a whole seems to be fairly happy with what we’ve (not just a government) has decided what the age of consent is. Otherwise we’d be seeing lobbying for change. Having said that, I don’t know how anyone could be happy that the legal age to drink alcohol in some states of the US is 21. I’d want that changed at least.
Governments lobby for change all the time. In CA, for example, the age to buy tobacco products went from 18 to 21 in 2016. I think I messed up the original question by saying consent, but really meant age restrictions for anything.
You think alcohol age should be higher or lower?
I can somewhat understand the change on tobacco products (less people smoking) but I think once people reach 18, legally an adult, you should be able to make your own decisions.
Being legally an adult but not being able to drink sounds so contradictory to me.
What’s makes somebody an adult at 18?
Eventually, on a long enough time span, I fully expect humanity ro realise age is not a sufficient measurement for consent. I’ve met people who were adults with children who did not seem sufficiently mature or cognisant to give what I would consider meaningful consent. The only reason I wouldn’t argue for laws to be changed at this point is I don’t think any of our current human societies is sufficiently mature and educated enough to not turn any discussion of consent laws into a eugenics project. Some group would push something like ‘literacy tests,’ the kind used in the US south to disenfranchise black voters, to try to make it illegal to have sex while brown or foreign.
Yeah. Damned if you do, damned if you don’t. Do you think 18 is old enough to make the sane decisions that require you to be 21 in some cases? Or maybe even extend past 21?
Couldn’t say. People don’t consistently mature as they age. There is no predictable wisdom curve where you can say ‘by age XX, only a statistically irrelevant subset of the population remains immature.’
So you’re good with the ages set where you live?
I’m probably just going 18 across the board, maybe with some carve outs for Romeo and Juliet law situations.
Does the person understand and accept the risks and consequences of their decision AND do they make that choice in an environment free from serious coercion, monetary or otherwise. There cannot be a life-changing downside to saying ‘no’.
…or ‘yes’. As in are there sufficient protections against stds and unwanted pregnancy. If not can consent really meet the above definition?
What constitutes serious coercion? Are the effects of capitalism coercion?
Also, how do you deem that somebody really understands the risks and consequences?
Just reinstate what I already know?
Am I getting paid to do this?
If not, eat a brick, that’s the kind of shit for society to work out. I’ve got other things to do.
If so, it’s 5 million per judgement. We can talk more once the check clears.
Sign in to comment. Sign in