Skip to content

Comment on Linux DRM for games is now here

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • On Windows Kernel level anticheat means, that the anticheat programs can do whatever it wants on your system at all times. Some of them even run always. On Linux this implementation works differently, instead using Linux native functionality to enable Kernel level anticheat, but without giving them full control. I’m on board with this implementation. It’s even optional and one does not need to use this if you are not interested into anticheat games.

    The only real drawback to me is, Epic can decide who can sign keys. Off course this makes it possible so that only trusted ones can sign keys, and at least there can be multiple entities who are able to do this. Buut, its a lot of power Epic has over who can sign.

    Overall, this is a good thing. It is optional. It does not have the same drawbacks as using Kernel level on Windows. Finally lot of games will become playable without Windows.

    44
    • I think this take is short-sighted.

      Many things start optional and rare. People accept it for the reasons you cite.

      Eventually - bit by bit - it becomes increasingly common and increasingly mandatory as vigilance and principles are whittled down due to normalization.

      62
      • How do you foresee a Linux kernel module becoming mandatory?

        7
        • Mandatory in the sense that more and more games require it to play; it was impossible before, but because now it’s possible, more publishers/developers are going to require it because it doesn’t cut out 100% of their Linux customers.

          34
          • Ah, like that. Yeah I can see how that would be a problem for some people. On the other hand, I do think the Venn diagram of triple A gamers and Linux kernel purists is going to have very little overlap.

            14
            • I do think the Venn diagram of triple A gamers and Linux kernel purists is going to have very little overlap.

              Then good riddance. People obsessed with AAA slop can just continue dealing with Windows until they develop some actual taste

              3
            • My stance is that “purists” need to advocate for Linux-installed-but-ambivalent people who don’t realize what their buying habits are getting all of us into; there are people who play Triple-A games who installed Bazzite because they’re tired of getting ads in their Windows start menu and they were told Bazzite is good for gamers, but don’t know what a “kernel” is and would happily hand over all the keys to it if that means being able to play Fortnite.

              7
              Continue this thread 12 more replies
          • Yeah that 4% of people that use linux! Thats why they were holding back before!

            1
          • Only online games would require this, right? Without the Linux support, you wouldn’t be able to play them anyway (most of them). As long as it is optional, I’m in favor of this. The benefit outweighs its potential issues; for me.

            1
            • Only online games would require this, right?

              You do realize there’s this thing called the future, right?

              Things change. Even if it’s only 5 or so multiplayer games that use kernel level anticheat as holdouts on not switching to Linux, there’s already other games that use it on Windows

              0
            • Not necessarily; some single-player games already come with anti-cheat.

              The part you’re not realizing is what I mentioned earlier:

              More games will require Kernel-Level Anti-Cheat now.

              If it was the idealist future you envision where only Fortnite and Rocket League require KLAC - that Linux can now comply with - yeah of course there’s no big issue because there’s zero change.

              But as I said earlier, I sincerely doubt that’s what’s coming; Epic Games (and other publishers) would have to go out of their way to be kind to apathetic consumers - the vast majority of whom who don’t even know what KLAC is or does and wouldn’t even notice their kindness.

              2
              Continue this thread 7 more replies
        • Greed. They will invent a way, and we will circumvent that way.

          6
          • If you can circumvent it, its not mandatory. I haven’t pirated games or software since the days of shareware, but still, yar matey!!

            2
        • Would a legal requirement to Red Hat & Canonical be possible?

          2
    • If they are actually doing what I think they are doing, using bpf, then they have full control similar to on windows.

      Bpf is a linux subsystem for adding code to the kernel to be executed at runtime. Bpf programs, executed as root, have full control over the system the same way kernel level anticheat would.

      However, bpf is not quite the same as windows/linux kernel modules, in that unlike crashing kernel modules or other kenel level code), a crashing bpf program does not crash the whole system. Anecdotally, I’ve noticed that kernel level anticheat can cause a massive hit to system stability, causing somewhat irregular random blue screems of death. A bpf based kernel level anticheat wouldn’t do that.

      5
      • What it does and need is listed at https://onlineservices.epicgames.com/news/introducing-easy-anti-cheat-linux-v2 . I thought a Kernel module is only needed to be loaded in, if its not part of the Kernel already. And the epf would just control what is in the Kernel already, with the rights it is given to, not full root access to do whatever it wants. The whole point was to not have the same control over the system as in Windows, if I understood it correctly.

        1
        • No, the whole point is to have the same control over your system as what kernel level anti cheat on windows has.

          Bpf is root. It’s a rootkit. Modern Linux rootkits use (e)bpf because it has more authority over the system than root itself, able to monitor/restrict/intercept what root does.

          7
          • No, the whole point is to have the same control over your system as what kernel level anti cheat on windows has.

            The whole point is to avoid that. There is probably a misunderstanding, either from my side or from your side. I think it is kind of a program that instructs the Linux Kernel to do something, it does not have root rights on its own. Kind of how you instruct to do Kernel functionality to delete a file with a non root application like rm file. You do Kernel access without having root access.

            -3

Sign in to comment. Sign in