Skip to content

Comment on Linux DRM for games is now here

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • @tabular@lemmy.world· · edited

    I don’t want my OS designed with anti-cheat in mind. Anti-cheat is an endless arms-race that sacrifices control of our computer to anti-cheat creators so they can fight on our land, instead of on their own servers. If Microslop adds ‘live camera feeds to AI’ or creates a ‘DRM network router system’ will should Linux try to emulate those? Is this “taking anti-cheat seriously”? Supporting more Digital Restrictions Management is a step in the wrong direction - we need to support video games that respect users’ software freedom.

    (Edit) It’s not Linux doing this, it’s Epic.

    87
    • will Linux try to emulate those?

      To be clear, “Linux” isn’t doing any of this, this is entirely Epic’s EAC.

      But as far as having an “OS designed with anti-cheat in mind”, it depends on what the device is for. Is it my PC that has access to my personal data? No, I want control over my PC, and I don’t want random programs having kernel-level visibility. Is it a game console hooked to my TV that doesn’t have access to my data, and is used to play games that are only fun with effective anti-cheat? Sure, I’d like the choice to allow that.

      But I do fear a future where MSFT coerces applications to use some form of hardware attestation in order to even run, or Epic pushing EAC as an anti-cheat standard on Linux, and now suddenly I have to be running a specific kernel and giving more access than I’d like in order to just run a random steam game.

      6
      • Linux dual boot incoming: one for games, one for everything else. I wish it were only a joke

        2
      • @tabular@lemmy.world· · edited

        You’re right, Linux isn’t doing anything of this. I’ve tried to edit my comment to not give that impression.

        It’s wise to seperate trusted computing and untrusted gaming but yeah we shouldn’t need to do that. I know there are selfhosted Valve game servers without anti-cheat but I assume most games with anti-cheat do not give users that choice.

        I have not liked game consoles since they stopped being easier than PCs in terms of plug-in-and-play. Modern consoles are basically a custom PCs; requiring updates to locked-down software/hardware. It would be better if users had more control over them (and the “smart” TVs people use with the consoles which is creating and sharing data about them).

        0
    • I agree. Incompetent game developers compensate with stuff installed on my machine running in the kernel their inability to detect that there is a player in their game in their server capable of popping heads through walls.

      The problem is also on the customer side, this is the result of democratizing linux: when only the tech nerds used linux such stuff was taboo and unthinkable, but now an entire generation of kids is fine with paying money to install crap in their kernel to do this.

      14
      • That’s not really what client side Anti-Cheat is for. You can’t tell if a player can see through walls just from server side information.

        It is a result of democratising Linux but I’d go further: when the only multiplayer games you could play on Linux were ut2k4 and Wolfenstein: enemy territory, this was less of an issue.

        -2
        • You can avoid sending to the client information about players they are not supposed to see.

          Once you treat all your clients as adversaries that is the pattern of thought a good developer should have.

          0
        • They can’t see from the server but 200 kills in 1 min is suspicious.

          6

Sign in to comment. Sign in