Skip to content

Comment on Linux DRM for games is now here

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Call me an idiot, but isn’t server-side input validation a perfectly feasible model which does what it’s supposed to (prevent cheats) and avoids poking its ugly nose where it has no place?

    Also, wouldn’t it be simpler than snooping for any arbitrary program which may or may not alter whatever in whichever way, relating to cheating in a stupid online game?

    23
    • No not necessarily. Lots of cheating can occur in the client that could not be detected by a server side validation, e.g. custom shader that draws an outline of other players behind walls. The fact that you know someone is around the corner is supremely useful knowledge that couldn’t be detected without client control.

      4
      • So analyze player behaviour, duh. It’s been said a million times: one computer running the game, another computer physically does mouse moves and key presses - good luck detecting that with whatever rootkit on the first one. Sorry for the tone, I am extremely irritated by the idiotic hacks performed by damn game companies - heck, banking software does not require anything kike that, and it is far more important that it functions properly than some game

        1
        • Do tell me the difference between a great player and a player who can see players before they come around the corner, statistically. I’ve worked in the gaming industry for decades, and I’m telling you it’s not possible.

          0
          • I have worked zero time in gaming industry, so me should be asking for your knowledge: can we not detect instances where player is actively staring at another through the wall? Not by chance, but many times over. Or anomalies in player performance (say, kill rate)? Or statistics on sniper-through-the-whole-map shots and kills? Come on, this does not sound impossible, but there definitely is lots of something important I do not know

            0
    • Well how are they going to snoop through your system if they can’t get access to your system… You idiot!

      22
    • Server-side input validation puts a huge strain on the server runners and if not properly sanitized can result in exploits.

      3
      • Huge strain on what? Resources or operator time? Resources sounds questionable if you’re just doing some statistical analysis on inputs. I could see wallhacks be more costly since you have to do some 3d checks.

        And for input sanitization, I really hope that servers are validating inputs already given how many CVEs floating around.

        1
        • Well, latency is very important in most multiplayer games, even a lag of 500ms is enough to throw off the rhythm, and SSIV will cause that.

          1
          • OK then trust the client and do periodic server side verifications. You dont have to verify everything constantly. Or offload that check to another server. This isnt some insurmountable obstacle.

            4
    • Call me an idiot, but isn’t server-side input validation a perfectly feasible model which does what it’s supposed to (prevent cheats)

      That is highly costly and doesn’t stop all cheats (e.g. seeing through walls)

      ofc it’s still no excuse for kernel level snooping

      5

Sign in to comment. Sign in