Skip to content

Comment on Would you go on a 1:1 Thanksgiving date with someone you've been on several dates for a month and recently became exclusive with? I honestly don't get why he's so nervous

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • As far as holidays go, a Thanksgiving date is the single most intimate holiday date I could imagine. New Year’s date, Valentine’s date — these are easy peasy. We’re dressed up, we’re going out, we’re looking cute, it’s fun. Thanksgiving is me and my weird family staying inside and and watching sports and wearing frumpy sweatpants so we don’t bust a button when we sneak in to the kitchen late to sneak a 6th piece of pie. If I’d only been dating someone a month, I’m not sure I’d be ready for a Thanksgiving date for next year’s Thanksgiving yet. It’s like my partner pooping while I’m in the shower — it’s a very different kind of intimacy, and one that you generally don’t have until much later in the relationship.

    6
    • Thank you for your help! This makes a lot of sense but I’m really irritated with how he’s handling this. He later followed up on whether a reservation should be made and I gave him an out saying I don’t want to pressure him so he suggested a non-food related idea for that same day which is the plan now. But more recently he let me know that he has Thanksgiving leftovers from an event he went to in case we’re hungry after dinner our next date. This is the first restaurant I’ve picked because he’s been picking the whole time so far. So why is it that when it’s my turn to pick, it’s either “OR we can do xyz” and it always matters whether he’s been there or heard of the place. I want this to work so badly but is it normal there are already issues, and valid to feel a bit frustrated?

      0
    • OP said that his family isn’t in the area though, so that kind of misses the point, doesn’t it?

      0
      • Nah, the tenor of the holiday is the same regardless of how far from your family you are located. If I invite you on a date for Valentine’s Day, there’s nothing you can do or say to remove the implications from the date; Thanksgiving is the same. When you invite me to a Thanksgiving date, you’re saying we’re family now, and that is a lot.

        0
        • Ah I see. I’m from Europe and we don’t have Thanksgiving over here so I’m not familiar with the connotations. Thanks for clarifying!

          0
          • No worries! Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday, and so I love talking about it. Getting together for a day with your family and eating every delicious food you can imagine and not leaving the house and watching sports is my ideal day. If you come from a culture that has a traditional harvest festival, I would strongly recommend having some sort of potluck to celebrate with your favorite humans.

            0

Sign in to comment. Sign in